Yeah, but come on, Fasces...
Suppose those injuries were legit--then your fellow Pats fans will have just acted like Grade-A assholes.
And the Pats defense won them PLENTY of games...6-10 years ago, anyway.
The Dynasty Era Patriots defense was GOOD, I'd argue that that's what really made that team a contender after Tom Brady and Bill Belichick. Wasn't the receivers, those came and went...wasn't the running backs...and even when the offense was good, often they still has plenty to work with and a great cushion courtesy of that defense.
Brady couldn't win a Super Bowl after Vinatieri left...
And he can't win one now that Ty Law and Mike Vrabel and Tedy Bruschi and all those good guys from the Dynasty Pats teams are long gone.
Another reason I'll always argue Montana was the better QB:
He won before Jerry Rice, Roger Craig, and John Taylor, and he won with them.
He won before a lot of the players on the '88 and '89 squads arrived, and he won with them.
He won in 1989 when his 49ers were arguably the best team this side of the '78 Steelers, '72 Dolphins and '85 Bears (and I exclude the '07 Pats there, sorry, but the players will be the first to say it--losing the Super Bowl knocks you down a peg...if they'd won you could've made a strong case they were the best team of all time, but great teams FINISH.)
AND he won in 1981, when he was just a 3rd year nobody, when all he had was Freddie Solomon, Dwight Clark, and Ronnie Lott on defense.
He was on arguably the best offensive team ever, and on one of the great Cinderella teams ever.
Joe Montana--best QB of all-time...
The only argument I could really entertain vs. Montana would be Elway, given that he made it so many times and did so much with so little, if he'd had just a bit more help he'd have had three or four rings easily...but Montana beat Elway in a SB, so that breaks any tie there for me.
Favre and Peyton Manning will probably be tied with one another by the time Peyton's done...
Marino was great, but he never won a SB...
And then if you wanted to go REALLY old school you could argue for Johnny Unitas, but that was such a different game in Unitas' heyday of the 1950s and early 1960s that I think he's better left as an asterisk off to the side, the #1 of the pre-Super Bowl era (and yeah, he played into the SB era, but he wasn't the same player.)
Aaaaaaand that's my pointless aside on the Greatest QB Ever Controversy...
Goodnight, everybody! ;)