Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 1291 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
basvanopheusden (2176 D)
07 Dec 15 UTC
Help me buy a scientific computing desktop
Inspired by the other thread, can I ask you guys for some more advice? I'm looking to buy a desktop for $1000-2000, to use for my work in the lab. Almost every project I do has a serious numerical computation component to it, so I want to max out on computational power. I don't care about graphics though.
36 replies
Open
Jamiet99uk (808 D)
07 Dec 15 UTC
Trump: Ban ALL Muslims from entering the USA
Is this guy for real?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-35035190
21 replies
Open
Peregrine Falcon (9010 D(S))
03 Dec 15 UTC
Most or least favourite to play
I was just curious what people's most and least favourite countries to play were and why. Does it correspond to the rankings of which countries win the most games?
28 replies
Open
peterwiggin (15158 D)
16 Jul 15 UTC
(+6)
Welcome to the Peanut Gallery
A few of us have been talking about having a game where anybody not in the game can comment on it. Well, it's happening! gameID=164615
Page 13 of 20
FirstPreviousNextLast
 
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
13 Aug 15 UTC
F Ank is by far his leas useful unit. That would be my initial supposition for the Turkish disband.
JamesYanik (548 D)
14 Aug 15 UTC
Eng-Fra VS Rus-Aus
my boy Yaleunc not doing bad...
TrPrado (461 D)
14 Aug 15 UTC
Now would be a perfect time to debut the AF alliance.
TrPrado (461 D)
14 Aug 15 UTC
Meanwhile, Chumbles will pull out a solo based on his Star Wars references.
JamesYanik (548 D)
14 Aug 15 UTC
(+1)
peterwiggin deserves death with his opening crap though
thorfi (1023 D)
14 Aug 15 UTC
I'm with Valis - disband F Ank - even if he keeps it he can't defend Ankara or recover C Constantinople with it.

But I'm also going to put it out there that I don't think it matters what unit Turkey disbands. It seems extremely doubtful that it's in either Russia *or* Austria's interests to keep units in that corner of the world any longer than they have to, and the quicker they wipe out Turkey, the quicker they can get on with the business of either stabbing each other or trying to smash the rest of the board.
VillageIdiot (7813 D)
14 Aug 15 UTC
It really makes no difference independent of any successful negotiation with either Russia or Austria to stab the other or keep him alive for whatever usefulness he could provide.

Pretty grim options there thought. Would take some very creative ideas to save Turkey if he wants any chance, maybe an arrangement to convoy Smy into Naples or something overly desperate like that.
thorfi (1023 D)
18 Aug 15 UTC
Bump! So as everyone probably expected, builds around the board were indeed F Mar, F StP/nc, F Edi, F Rom, F Nap.

Turkey did indeed disband Ankara.

Germany disbanded Silesia... Interesting choice, although it's not like there were necessarily any obviously *better* alternatives.

Anyone want to bet on F Bal Convoy A Lvn - Kie ? :-) Although Lvn-War really does seem more likely.

What about that Turkish pie anyway, will Austria get a piece of it, or is Russia going to keep it all?

What's France gonna do with them armies? Still doesn't look profitable to stab...

Will we see Italian F Nap-Tys?

Turn is going to process in only a few hours. :-) Guess we find out soon.
Balrog (219 D)
18 Aug 15 UTC
This just got more interesting..! :-)
I bet you Bul-Rum was agreed on. It seems a very reasonable way of dividing the centers: Russia gets Turkey, Austria the Balkan. Apu-Alb is there to retake Greece if Turkey had taken it this turn. Although Smy-Gre would have been a great move for Turkey that they either missed or decided to gamble on.

The really interesting question is how far E/F will get in the center and whether Scandinavia will fall. As it stands, R/G can keep it forever, but if England puts a fleet in Kiel they can cut Bal. But that could also expose England to French stabs...

On that note, France is going to have to give a center to England in exchange for Munich. Berlin is thr obvious option, but that could conveniently fail if Austria cuts Munich or Russia supports Berlin. But switching Hol takes time away from the offensive. I'm curious how they'll manage that. And if France can tenths into an opportunity to stab England better than before.
VillageIdiot (7813 D)
18 Aug 15 UTC
Well yeah, of course Bul-Rum was agreed on. Got to keep the alliance balanced somehow.

I do have to admit i'm a little confused by the convoy back to Alb. With Ion covering Greece there really was no need to "retake Greece if Turkey had taken it". Even if he predicted losing Ion and was worried about the Aeg/Ion pressure on Greece he still was in a situation where he either would have been in Bulg/Gre or Gre/Alb and could have managed it while still keeping pressure on Nap/Rom. Either he made a sub-par move there or there was a deal somewhere that either hasn't come to fruition yet or went sour.

We're probably looking at an Alb support of Greece and Con/Rum bounce in Bulg. Personally if i were Turkey i'd mess with Austria use Aeg to support Rum into Bulg. But then again, i'm a bit of a dick.

E/F has a chance of taking Berlin or Denmark if they're clever and R/G make a mistake. The wide open Warsaw helps open up opportunities for a lucky guess.

I'd bet E/F is willing to gamble a bit of inequality for sake of trying to break through some stalemate lines. England can afford a destroy if he absolutely has to.
basvanopheusden (2176 D)
23 Aug 15 UTC
(+1)
I'm switching to team uclabb. Sorry, ATC, but after almost losing to him twice in the webdip F2F, I gotta say none of you stand a chance ;)
uclabb (589 D)
23 Aug 15 UTC
<3
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
23 Aug 15 UTC
I'm still on the Yale x uclabb ship!
thorfi (1023 D)
25 Aug 15 UTC
Alas poor Chumbles.
GG Chumbles. Can Chumbles now join the peanut throwing?
thorfi (1023 D)
25 Aug 15 UTC
Well, technically he's still in the game... I mean, if he convinces everyone to vote draw some time in the next 1 day 14 hours, then it's a 7 way draw. Rules are quite clear, all powers with *units* on the board participate in draws. ;-)

(And yes, for the sake of clarity I do think this is about as unlikely as Yaleunc actually vacating Tunis the other turn when I made a ridiculous "technically" suggestion.)
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
25 Aug 15 UTC
@thorfi

All powers with "pieces". Pieces can be unit markers or center-ownership markers.
goldfinger0303 (3157 DMod)
25 Aug 15 UTC
(+1)
I tried warning everyone in the beginning - ATC will win this game. He's in great shape going into the midgame
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
25 Aug 15 UTC
All I know is that uclabb is the most handsome player on the board, but Yaleunc is my favorite player on the board. and unless E/G/R went to MIT or NEU, I don't have much to change my mind on.
LittleItaly (355 D)
25 Aug 15 UTC
(+1)
!!!ATC ATC!!!

Join the ATC fan club!

Balki and Yaleunc can make it difficult, But I want ATC to win.
Hellenic Riot (1626 D(G))
25 Aug 15 UTC
So; I got rather out of habit with that pause but time to do a catch up of the entire year:

England: Taking Silesia in spring was smart - crossing the line early and putting Russia and Austria into a bit of a tight spot. Really though, what was the point of Denmark? After Germany kept Baltic it was obvious he'd be support holding it, and Berlin cutting was the logic move to make. Realistically; the only way you could take Denmark was from Kiel - which could've been arranged if you let France into Kiel behind you and then convoyed yourself into Holland in Autumn if you built an army. That Edinburgh fleet isn't going anywhere. And of course, in Autumn, you tried the same thing and failed again because now there are two units to support hold Denmark and you're stalemated. You might've got into Warsaw but Russia knew he could afford that by taking out Turkey, so at the end of that year you have 6 units; of which 5 are completely out of play. Not exactly leaving yourself with many options, are you? Warsaw might be able to go on a one (or two, if Bohemia helps) man crusade, but you've lost any ability to shape this board for yourself. Which means you're of less and less use to France and could easily be cut out for a 3 way later. I would criticise you not supporting France to Munich but that'd actually make you eve more of his bitch than you are now, so I can just about forgive it. Except of course, had you done that, then they'd have bounced and you'd have got a build, which would've been excellent. Major screw-up. You need to turn this around to stop that happening - you have a bargaining chip in the East. Use it to cut a deal with Russia. 100 lines of "I must not put 83% of my units into a stalemate by 1904".

France: Well; what can I say? Spring was very solid - taking the Ionian; getting into Munich, using England as little more than a frontal assault force. But what the hell was that Autumn? Catastrophic errors all over the place. Why you let England try another pointless attack on Denmark instead of supporting you to Munich I don't know - Denmark was never going to succeed and you let Austria into Munich in the process. Poor move. Still, one mistake happens. To err once is human; to make the same mistake twice is stupid. Why on earth did you dislodge Italy from the Tyrrhenian? Italy can now do exactly what he's probably wanted to do all along - sail off into the MAO or Spain, and put himself into a position where it's incredibly difficult to dislodge him. You should've been covering Western Med there and using Tunis to support hold the Ionian - either supporting Turkey to Greece or letting him shoot for Bulgaria. That Turkish fleet could've been a handy ally and you completely wrote it off. Awful set of moves down south that's going to cost you dear. 200 lines of "I must not let desperate minor powers into the wide open space behind my lines"

Germany: Good solid year. Correctly identifying Denmark as the key SC to hold to stay alive in Spring and defending that worked well, and then by England going for that instead of Berlin, you got to keep Berlin too as it was safe by Autumn. Correctly supporting Austria into Munich was another good stroke; and you've now got 3 different powers bordering you - a good way to keep yourself alive as it's far harder for them to cut to a three way deal to cut you out. Of course, you've still got a lot of work to do to pull yourself out, so you need to break up the A/R here. Preferably by managing to somehow put together an EA that doesn't then charge you hundreds of dollars for every DLC, err, SC, that you want to gain. Still, probably the best year you've had, and you can have a cookie as a result.

Italy: Pretty easy commentary here. Spring was sensible; opening up the trap that France fell for hook line and sinker by putting yourself in Tyrrhenian. And then he fell face first into it by dislodging you and putting you in WMed. You have a way to try and survive as a very minor power now; though defending both Rome and Naples with one unit next year will take further miracles of guesswork. If you can manage that, though, then Portugal, Brest, or Liverpool could be very nice places to park yourself and hope for some good luck later. So you can have a cookie for giving yourself the only shot you had at surviving, and for making France walk into the trap.

Austria: I can't help but think you rather rode your luck this year. I can only assume the spring convoy to Albania was you knowing you were losing Ionian Sea, and it worked out quite nicely for you. Still, Turkey bouncing Bulgaria made Autumn some very hard guesswork - and Galicia being open to England was even worse. So your spring moves were merely meh, with Rumania obviously not being a stab. Autumn though, you made up for it. Whilst England bouncing you in Galicia would've been truly perfect, as the second build would've put you in a fantastic spot, the capture of Munich was brilliant and combined with your recapture of the Ionian Sea, you made that into a terrible year for France. Russia, however, has now finished with Turkey, and that means you should be a bit wary there. Consider making a deal with England - he's in a very tough place after all; and with German help you could time a stab pretty well - though Russia has a very good line so you'll have to fight very hard to get far. An FA is also possible, of course, but you and France don't seem to get on well, and France is in a horrible position for turning on England. Have a small cookie for that year; but I look forward to the future here.

Russia: Very good stuff. Destruction of Turkey complete; giving you 3 units in the South which you can play with, and the option to send a fleet into the Med. Perfect line in Scandinavia with Germany that's taken most of England's units out of play. And whilst Warsaw is an annoying loss; the fact you got a build anyway because Austria left Rumania means that you should be able to deal with that English army quite well as long as he doesn't start working with Austria. An EA (with German support) is a big threat to you because you can't really form an R/F in return - France has very little he can do to aid you for a year or so, by which time, England and Austria would've gained the upper hand. And Italy floating around creating trouble for France makes that even harder. Positionally, however, you definitely have the best spot on the map. The capture of all of Anatolia (copying the Turkish starting position right down to the units) gives you a fantastically defensible position; and Austria would be walking through a mire to get anywhere against you. Now to ensure that your diplomacy matches your tactics here. Another cookie for you, sir.

Turkey: Well, Spring was solid - bouncing Bulgaria meant that Austria couldn't definitely defend all his SC's against you in Autumn, so you deserve credit for that. Sadly, you guessed wrong on the 50/50, and that's that. Requiescat in pace. You sewed the seeds of your defeat right back in A1901, and then just seemed to go from one neighbour to another to let them bitchslap you as every time you tried to trust one they just shafted you from behind. Pretty brutal. Corpses can't write lines, though, so here's some popcorn for your afterlife in Asphodel.
What I don't understand - and maybe some people can help me out with this - is why Austria didn't move to Sev and stab Russia this year.

It's settling down into a stalematish situation on large parts of the board. You want to keep the board as fluid as possible, no? It didn't need to be a solo run situation, but he and France could've easily come to an understanding where France remains in Munich and takes Belgium while Austria moves en force on Russia.
TrPrado (461 D)
26 Aug 15 UTC
Because France and Austria hate each other. Seriously, it's like this guy doesn't even read global.
goldfinger0303 (3157 DMod)
26 Aug 15 UTC
(+2)
No, I don't read global, because anything that goes on in global should not be taken as indicative of private press.
basvanopheusden (2176 D)
26 Aug 15 UTC
(+1)
Here's my take on the whole Austria/France/Italy situation around Tys and Ion. Italy spent the majority of last year trying to exchange his army for another fleet to be more useful to Austria. However, he's playing multiple angles and in the spring supports France into Ionian while convincing Austria to move out of Apulia. He guarantees to hold both his home centers by self-bouncing in Rome. Defending those centers from Austria in the long term is hard without fleets, so France/Italy decide to give Austria a "cookie of his own dough", and exchange the fleet back into an army. However, Italy was playing for Austria all along, and retreats to Wes! Surprised faces all around, and uclabb & peterwiggin high-five the shit out of each other.

Of course, what really happened is that peterwiggin delayed his choice between Austria and France until fall retreats, after all the moves had resolved. There's a reason this retreats phase took the full 2 days...

So well done, peterwiggin for putting himself in a position where his decision matters for the entire board. And well done uclabb for convincing peterwiggin you're the better ally.
basvanopheusden (2176 D)
26 Aug 15 UTC
(+2)
Goldfinger: that sounds like a dubious stab to me. Russia and Austria obviously agreed that it would be okay if Austria kept Rumania this turn, so stabbing for Sevastopol would be a zero-center stab. Of course, given that England took Warsaw and France couldn't defend Munich, and France didn't get Venice and Turkey didn't try taking Bul, we can chastise uclabb for playing too conservative, but imagine what this turn would've looked like if uclabb moved Rum-Sev, England moved Sil-Gal, France supported Munich and Turkey moved Aeg-Bul. Russia would have one build, Austria none and he'd be surrounded by literally every other power on the board. Sorry to say, but that looks more like a losing attempt than a winning attempt to me.
thorfi (1023 D)
26 Aug 15 UTC
Even if Austria was always supposed to move out of Rum, it would still only be a 1 SC stab, and France and England are all over Austria's northwestern corner. I don't think Austria can afford the units to defend against the three Russian units sitting on the Turkish home SCs *and* handle France and England with loose units to the north. And that's assuming good old Italy doesn't look at the board after such a "stab" and go "ohhhh my" and switch teams.
thorfi (1023 D)
26 Aug 15 UTC
But I'm with goldfinger on the nature of public press - for all we know that "fight" is entirely fake. It might not be, but the only people who know for sure are the players.
Sigh. I just don't like conservative play, I suppose. I see this going in a very boring direction to a 4WD.

Page 13 of 20
FirstPreviousNextLast
 

572 replies
sitting_ovation (0 DX)
07 Dec 15 UTC
Ideas for fun special rule variants
Hi all, I was wondering if anyone played or has any ideas to play some special ruled variants of the game just to shake things up?
2 replies
Open
brainbomb (290 D)
07 Dec 15 UTC
Idea for a Diplomacy Game
I know there is a vdip variant where you only have one SC but I think it would be interesting to get a game going on here where It has unique rules.
1. You can only move one unit per turn. And you can only move additional units for every SC you gain.
2. By Spring of the 2nd year you could be moving 2 units, and so on and so forth.
anyone ever done anything like that?
3 replies
Open
2ndWhiteLine (2606 D(B))
06 Dec 15 UTC
Metagaming Policy Reminder
I feel the need to clarify our stance on playing games with friends. See below.
41 replies
Open
Ranscott47 (2874 D)
07 Dec 15 UTC
Austria missed 1st turn. Any takers?
Game ID=170684 Looking for someone to take the challenge of taking over Austria in Fall 1901. Don't want to have to cancel game so please help!
3 replies
Open
jaydog (125 D)
06 Dec 15 UTC
Rules question?
Hi there, got a question about how the rules work.
14 replies
Open
Nescio (1059 D)
02 Dec 15 UTC
In California ...
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-34987697
14 replies
Open
ghug (5068 D(B))
06 Dec 15 UTC
(+2)
December GR
http://tournaments.webdiplomacy.net/theghost-ratingslist

Have fun!
17 replies
Open
brainbomb (290 D)
05 Dec 15 UTC
Iowa vs Michigan State
Id bet you anything Iowa fucks this up lol. Theres no way Iowa is gonna make the college football playoffs.

Mich State - 35
Iowa - 13
5 replies
Open
SandgooseXXI (113 D)
03 Dec 15 UTC
(+5)
That baby I was gonna have
Well he finally decided to show up and meet the world! Gents, and rare ladies of WebDip...my offspring!

http://imgur.com/8tDt1XO
12 replies
Open
Hellenic Riot (1626 D(G))
16 Nov 15 UTC
November Ghost Ratings
November GR is now up!
42 replies
Open
wjessop (100 DX)
03 Dec 15 UTC
Star Wars: The Force Awakens
Discussion, questions, concerns, excitement.
37 replies
Open
SkiingCougar (1581 D)
03 Dec 15 UTC
(+1)
Is this the longest game ever?
This game has been going for 2 (100 in game years) years as it is the 2012 world cup. It must be the longest or most back and forth game ever. In fact Austria was down to 1 supply centres near the 1/3 mark but is still alive! Imagine the commitment. If anyone has spectated all the way through I congratulate you, also well done to the players for the commitment they have shown.

http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=93086
19 replies
Open
brainbomb (290 D)
04 Dec 15 UTC
Endless Legend = amazing civ style thrill ride
Im gonna say this takes warlock master of the arcane and makes it about a thousand times cooler. very hard game actually.
1 reply
Open
brainbomb (290 D)
04 Dec 15 UTC
Wanna give a shout out to..
My DETROIT LIONS. I dont think weve swept the fudgepackers in my lifetime!!!
5 replies
Open
Baskineli (100 D(B))
03 Dec 15 UTC
New game
Two of my games are about to be finished. Anyone in for a game?

WTA, full press, high RR. Who's in?
2 replies
Open
KingCyrus (511 D)
28 Nov 15 UTC
(+1)
Our Almighty Master...
... has graced us with his presence today. I have seen a grand total of three, yes, THREE, whole comments by the omnipotent kestas today.

We must celebrate with a feast.
48 replies
Open
abgemacht (1076 D(G))
03 Dec 15 UTC
US Military to open all combat roles to women
http://hereandnow.wbur.org/2015/12/03/open-all-combat-jobs-to-women

Thoughts?
20 replies
Open
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
04 Dec 15 UTC
ITT: MFW I send/receive press
as above, below.
7 replies
Open
wjessop (100 DX)
04 Dec 15 UTC
LIVE REPLACEMENT NEEDED
France gameID=170630
1 reply
Open
wjessop (100 DX)
03 Dec 15 UTC
Wjessop inteacts with...
It's a game where you can post any word or phrase that Wjessop interacts with.

It's fun. It's new. Everyone's doing it!
21 replies
Open
steephie22 (182 D(S))
28 Nov 15 UTC
So if I wanted to produce a pc-game...
How would I go about that? I probably need a team because I don't have the technical know-how. Where to start though?
No, I won't be jumping into this without knowing what the hell I'm doing. In fact, I won't start anytime soon. This is just the very first reconnaissance. What kind of people do I need and how do I know they'll do the job well? What can I reasonably do myself? I decide what the game should be like for the biggest part.
93 replies
Open
lauridsena (910 D)
03 Dec 15 UTC
Rules question
What happens to a unit if retreat orders are not entered for it?
7 replies
Open
Ludwig Van (50 DX)
02 Dec 15 UTC
New game special rules. World Match!
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=170504

This is special rules for a world game. It's a Role Play of a United nations meeting.
0 replies
Open
Octavious (2701 D)
02 Dec 15 UTC
(+1)
cancelled game message
An anonymous game was cancelled today and I never got the chance to say a final message to the Russian player who was at the centre of the game.

Sir, I salute you and your actions. Don't let that game get you down. Highest regards, Oct.
1 reply
Open
Ludwig Van (50 DX)
02 Dec 15 UTC
tell me this isn't slightly disturbing
http://m.bradfordexchange.com/products/301881001_lifelike-breathing-baby-doll-.html?CATALOG_UPSELL=Y&SOURCE=Y&RECOMM=Y
5 replies
Open
shield (3929 D)
27 Nov 15 UTC
Syrian Refugees
Http://www.barenakedislam.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/unnamed7.jpg

Does anyone recall how during ww2 when the Allies started discovering concentration camps they set up a 2 year background check to make sure the jews weren't serial killers and rapists? Me niether. Discuss.
45 replies
Open
Page 1291 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top