Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 944 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
LegatusMentiri (100 D)
09 Aug 12 UTC
the ultimate nation building diplomacy war game?
You have been charged to design the next big strategy game. What do you put in it?
26 replies
Open
stauros (159 D)
09 Aug 12 UTC
Ancient Mediterranean
2 for Ancient Mediterranean. Looking for more.

gameID=96962
0 replies
Open
orathaic (1009 D(B))
09 Aug 12 UTC
Trouble getting up in the morning?
Please +1 the post which is true for you (or add the correct option)
12 replies
Open
Hydro Globus (100 D)
08 Aug 12 UTC
WebDip rules question
Is there a difference between drawing or cancelling a game if no players have been defeated, the scoring is WTA, and four (!) players are NMR?
11 replies
Open
krellin (80 DX)
24 Jul 12 UTC
Ban the G***
Ganja....the drugs....pot...hashish...cocaine...meth...Hell, ban cigarettes...ban it ALL....BAN THE GUNS!!!!.....and you know what happens? BLAKC MARKETS! We can't keep HUMAN BEINGS from crossing the border. We can't stop drugs. You Anti-gun fools think you can ban guns????
322 replies
Open
Rhyme621 (356 D)
07 Aug 12 UTC
Quick rules question
If a country support holds a country that is support moving a country, is this the same effect on the country that's holding as if the same country was to hold and another country was to support hold it?
17 replies
Open
thatwasawkward (4690 D(B))
08 Aug 12 UTC
First person to post loses.
Oops.
11 replies
Open
dangermouse (5551 D)
08 Aug 12 UTC
I'm back!
Looks like we've still got a few old timers out there. Hello again to them and a first time to the newer players.

I see the forums haven't changed much, 50% philosophical debates, 49% trolling and 1% game related stuff.
12 replies
Open
FlemGem (1297 D)
07 Aug 12 UTC
any home brewers out there?
I just started my first batch yesterday, just curious if anyone else has any experience to share.
19 replies
Open
Sbyvl36 (439 D)
07 Aug 12 UTC
The Greatest Comedians of All Time
My personal opinion would be the Marx Brothers, but who do you think are the greatest comedians?
27 replies
Open
SplitDiplomat (101466 D)
08 Aug 12 UTC
10 SC-s Germany replacement
gameID=96898,live game.
4 replies
Open
orathaic (1009 D(B))
26 Jul 12 UTC
If at first you don't succeed...
... Send in the Physicists.

http://phys.org/news/2012-07-physicists-classics-hidden-truths.html
6 replies
Open
obiwanobiwan (248 D)
07 Aug 12 UTC
So Jesus, Mohammad, Moses, Buddha, Vishnu, and Hitchens all Have a Beer Summit... :P
Just for a change of pace, as we're wrapping up The Great Debate now (sorry again for my last submission being a bit late, Thucy) and because it'd be interesting...
One nice thing about Judaism/Christianity/Islam if you're atheistic like me...
One nice thing about atheism and its authors/books if you're theistic.
Let's see if we can all get along... ;)
29 replies
Open
Putin33 (111 D)
07 Aug 12 UTC
Most Overrated Philosophers
By overrated I mean philosophers whose reputations are excessively high in light of their originality, insight, or quality of work.
19 replies
Open
seth24c (5659 D)
07 Aug 12 UTC
EoG Gunboats can FLY!?!?!?
gameID=96865 france is the kind guy that if you knew him in real life you would beat his face in. If he would have stayed in cd we would have had the stalemate, but then he comes back and supports austria into burgundy.
7 replies
Open
Klaas (229 D)
07 Aug 12 UTC
World map Dark Summer still missing a few
gameID=96591
Join us, we are still a few players short! Would be great I we can get going.
0 replies
Open
2ndWhiteLine (2601 D(B))
07 Aug 12 UTC
wta gunboat 198
See below.
19 replies
Open
goldfinger0303 (3157 DMod)
06 Aug 12 UTC
How do you convince the Board to let you Solo?
See below
The scenario: Mid-game, 6 countries alive. You are the largest power, standing at 7-10 centers and have not yet crossed the stalemate line (though if you hypothesize for Russia, you hold Swe). You have one direct enemy, who is at 4 SC's, and are friendly with the rest of the board. Another power, just a few SC's below you, has grown suspicious of you and is cautiously moving a unit or two to "help out" your enemy.

I have my own thoughts on how to do this, and it does not affect or reflect any game I am in (thought "was in" might be closer to the truth).
And lets narrow down your SC count to 8 centers.
London198 (0 DX)
06 Aug 12 UTC
Do you mean trick the other players, allowing you to solo, or changing their opinions so that they want you to solo (perhaps so they survive instead of die), because the 2nd option i would find practically impossible in a skilled game
bo_sox48 (5202 DMod(G))
06 Aug 12 UTC
If you play in PPSC games, here, take this knife and help the gene pool out.

I think it's pretty easy to convince the rest of the board to allow you to solo. The first thing you have to do is take out that 4 SC nation, but not on your own. Your small friend at the bottom of the board needs to do it. Support them through that nation, give them 3 of the 4 centers, and all of a sudden it's 9 and 7, plus you've got a powerful alliance budding. If he's skilled enough, he'll keep pressing you to give him a tad more so he can be more comfortable with it and he'll do so without angering you. If he's like me, he'll just say fuck it and attack you with his newly found power, at which point you solo.

If he does stick alongside you, you can work for a two-way ending, and if you can manipulate it enough, you will solo in the end.

The only way you're going to get an "easy" solo from that situation is if the rest of the board is either held up by ignorant neighbors or just not skilled at all. In other words, someone has to inadvertently make it easy for you. I find it immoral to take advantage of a new player like that, but if they give it to you, you can't say no, right? Otherwise, you're going to need an ally.
2ndWhiteLine (2601 D(B))
06 Aug 12 UTC
With that many countries still alive, it's going to be difficult to solo regardless of your trickery or diplomacy. The situation is similar to the dangers inherent in "early leader syndrome," which is why it's often a poor idea for Germany to try for three builds in 1901, as they become a clear target for the rest of the board. The second option is impossible, and if you're playing with even one or two players of halfway decent ability, your ploy will never work. You're probably stuck with a disappointing four or five way draw.
London198 (0 DX)
06 Aug 12 UTC
i dont think the idea of the proposed two way draw followed by a stab/solo would work with skillful players (or whatever playstyle i have). To me a 2 way draw is unstable because whoever is the odd man out can offer to let one of the 2 win if they dont 3 way. If nobody takes the offer they are not playing in their best interest (a win is better than a draw right?) and to me thats not the kind of play i like.
Anyone have ideas? I left this open so people could format their response for any country they want. Should I give a more specific scenario?

But here's my thoughts on it. When you're at 8 SC's and are the largest power on the board, you have a big target painted on your back, so what I suggest to do is wait. You're not strong enough to make a solo bid, so aggressively pushing forward would just solidify a front against you. Therefore, it makes sense to bide your time, and help other countries around you gain centers, keeping your neighbors in conflict against each other whilst making sure the east or the west doesn't solidify into a single power or single alliance.

This is one thing that I don't believe enough people grasp. Your actions influence every other member on the board, no matter how far. If Turkey attacks Russia, that draws Russia's forces south, perhaps sparing England and Germany from losing Scandinavia. If England moves a fleet to NAO or Irish, then France will have to pull a fleet out of the Med and there's one less unit to pressure Italy. As the largest power on the board with most of the nations alive you can quite literally shape the board how you want to with just unit movements. Add press into the matter, and that simply amplifies the affect.

Back to the matter though, my strategy would be to keep my neighbors at conflict with each other. So if I was England, I'd try to keep G and F fighting, if Russia, then keep I and T fighting, etc. The stab would have to be swift and decisive, earning me 3 builds, two at the least. The jump from 8 SC's to 11 SC's is a large one, and the momentum from such a jump would be enough to carry a player straight through the stalemate line, before the opposition can realize how much of a threat you are.

If there's one thing that I've learned best, is that the merits of placing a unit beyond the stalemate line are decisive. As Turkey or as England, I will always try to slip fleets through MAO, and they pay more than enough in dividends to compensate for the lack of territorial gains.
@2ndWhiteLine - Trickery is a more appropriate word for it.

But I have found that the more players there are alive, the better a shot for solo is. You can make up all kinds of excuses for keeping the game going "Oh, just until X is dead and then I'll draw" or you will likely find someone who is so pissed off that he'll help you out, consequences be damned.
Draugnar (0 DX)
06 Aug 12 UTC
There are so many possible combinations, btu in a classic full press WTA, you aren't going to pull that solo off with skilled players. In full press PPSC, you might be bale tyo help #2 approach your level and convince hom to work with you knowing he will get a larger portion of the pot than a 3 or 4 way draw would get. Of course, that is why I hate PPSC.
Al Swearengen (0 DX)
07 Aug 12 UTC
I think the way to sell this is the way to sell anything: make your particular offer seem considerably more attractive than their remaining offers. For you to achieve this you'll have to spend some energy manipulating game events for this to be the case, and then understand the psychology and motives of the players enough to begin an appeal to them.
@Draug - I disagree. With the games I've been in lately, the solo is certainly possible, but its just a matter of how long you're willing to wait for it. I have had games going into the late 1920s, early 1930s where the solo was possible, but either misunderstandings or lack of interest forced draws.

Which is why I hold the position that if you want to solo, you either rip it out quick and solo by 1907-8 or you slow everything down, pushing units past the stalemate line slowly until you smash everyone in one deadly stab.

gameID=60765 is probably my favorite game on this site and a major reason why I posted this, as I just don't see how one can solo as Turkey.
dipplayer2004 (1110 D)
07 Aug 12 UTC
goldfinger, that looks like it was one hell of a game!
bo_sox48 (5202 DMod(G))
07 Aug 12 UTC
^


13 replies
William Flint (220 D)
07 Aug 12 UTC
2 more needed for beginners game
Bunch of new players looking to have a practice game. Game starts in 13 hours, standard game, 1 day/phase. Contact me for password if you're interested. game url is http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=96734#gamePanel
0 replies
Open
Sbyvl36 (439 D)
06 Aug 12 UTC
Wikipedia is broken.
Why isn't wikipedia working today?
15 replies
Open
gramilaj (100 D)
27 Jul 12 UTC
Chicago World Diplomacy Championship
Hey everyone, I've been away for a while, but I was wondering if anyone from the site would be attending World Dip Champ in Chicago in 2 weeks?
13 replies
Open
dipplayer2004 (1110 D)
02 Aug 12 UTC
Classical Music
In a classical listening mood today, as I work here in my home. Any suggestions? I already have the following in my playlist:

57 replies
Open
krellin (80 DX)
06 Aug 12 UTC
Why is ONE national News???
http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2012/08/06/7-people-shot-following-detroit-princess-cruise/
http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-201_162-57487094/sikh-temple-shooting-suspect-identified-as-wade-michael-page-motivation-unclear/
26 replies
Open
2ndWhiteLine (2601 D(B))
31 Jul 12 UTC
Handball
...the fuck did I just watch?
56 replies
Open
Conservative Man (100 D)
05 Aug 12 UTC
My opinion on a certain subject keeps changing.
I'm trying to keep this as ambiguous as possible, because before when I've come on here with similar problems, all I've been getting is other people's opinions on the matter, which isn't what I want. I want help in forming my own opinion. Whether or not that's possible without telling you the problem, I don't know. We'll find out. More inside.
66 replies
Open
urallLESBlANS (0 DX)
06 Aug 12 UTC
Teaching racism
I've seen this interview of Morgan Freeman before, and I know its pretty old, but I saw it again recently, and I felt like discussing it.
28 replies
Open
SantaClausowitz (360 D)
06 Aug 12 UTC
Work Ethic
Is it hypocritical that those who gripe the most about bad work ethic post during the work day?
14 replies
Open
Gerry (3173 D(S))
06 Aug 12 UTC
Anonymous
How I can enter a game as "Anonymous" player? And have I understood right that After the game the players will be shown?
5 replies
Open
Svidrigailov (100 D)
04 Aug 12 UTC
Film
Another one of my passions, what are you favorites? perhaps we can get a discussion going too.
75 replies
Open
madarn (105 D)
05 Aug 12 UTC
How do I get email announcements if something happens in my games?
Hi. Read the FAQ, but didn't find anything about it.
6 replies
Open
Page 944 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top