Okay, since you're not krellin, let me tone it down a bit:
I'm white myself. I don't hate my race. I don't hate masculinity, heterosexuality, Texas, America, none of it. All of these things are my identity. So first off, let me get that out of the way.
Now, let me address what's going on here. You hear a "white boogey man" story. It is somewhat more complicated than that.
You hear that "if you are white you are oppressing black people."
It's more complex than that.
Here is what is actually going on in the main. If you are white like me, immigrant or not, irrespective of other status (this is the essence of intersectionality) such as class, sexuality, gender, and so on, you get a certain leg up in American society, indeed the world over, by virtue of your race.
This is just a fact. Can you find a time when there are disadvantages to being white? Of course. Right now I'm in Senegal. Often I'm the only white person in a crowd. There are distinct disadvantages to my complexion.
This does not erase white privilege.
You may hate this term. You may think it doesn't exist. But please keep reading.
Because although yes, at times being white is a disadvantageous position, this is just, plain and simple, not the norm. At all. Not even close. Nowhere is this the norm. Even here, where I am a one in ten thousand minority, I have a kind of privilege, thanks to a history of racist colonialism. Even though that era is historically over, declared ended, its legacy persists.
An example: I walk into a store to buy some sweets. The shopkeeper refers to every other one of his customers with the familiar "tu" (it means you in French). This is how Senegalese people refer to each other in a conversational setting. They inhereted the habit from the French who used the familiar "tu" on every. single. African. Why did they do that? Because they're black Africans. They're not civilized, obviously.
Maybe the French today don't believe that. But the legacy is still there. And what do you know - it plays out right there as I ask for some candies - the shopkeepers uses the formal you, "vous," on me. Just because I'm white. He's twice as old as me. I'm 22, in shorts in a t-shirt, and have a thick accent. Nothing about commands respect.
Except my white skin.
You may dismiss this as a trifle. But I say to you - how would you feel if your entire life the message was drilled into your head, explicitly, subliminally, in every way you can cook up - white people are better than you. This is in a *nation of black people*.
What about in America? Where black people are something like 20% of the population? Where that population was enslaved only four-odd generations ago? Where they were institutionalized as second class citizens only ONE generation ago?
What effect does that have today? None? Do you really believe that?
I don't need to cite you the figures about the jailing of black men over white men on the same offenses. You've seen them, you're well-read enough. I don't need to repeat what you've already heard, from, I hope, black people themselves, about their experience of racism in the 21st century.
The microaggressions, the marginalization of their history, the police brutality, the black jokes, the casual way in which black people are mocked, loathed, feared, and ultimately, discriminated against by the whole of American society.
It's a world where a black kid who goes to college is still, in the back of many of our minds, seen as a "credit to his race." But when I go to college, a white boy, it's only right.
Surely you've heard this all before, so let me get to what often gets bandied about by the likes of Draugnar and others. These people don't believe they're racist. For the most part they aren't trying to marginalize other people.
They genuinely don't believe that racism is that serious of a problem. Tellingly, something they usually have in common is being white, but whatever, I'll even leave that to the side.
What they often cite are statistics "well, black people commit crimes more on average, so you bet I locked my door." Or whatever. It's an appeal to the facts on the ground.
Even if they agree there's nothing inherent about being black that makes you act a certain way, they say that this is irrelevant. In real life, black people don't go to college, talk back to authority, commit petty crime, and so on.
They blame this on the black people themselves.
Here's where I am bothered by this: the facts are that an entire group who has really only one inherent thing in common - their race - and the cultural experience that history has attached to being a certain race, "act a certain way."
It's systematic. There's a pattern. Why are black men always sentenced more harshly? Arrested more? Why are there more black single mothers? What's going on?
There's a phrase from the namesake of our friend Tolstoy:
"Tout comprendre, c'est tout pardonner."
To understand all is to forgive all.
I have found, and I hope that you may find, the more I delved into these questions myself, the more I saw how these things played out. The less willing I was to blame the people themselves. The more I realized - if I were born in their circumstances I would be no different.
Are their outliers? "Successful black men," if you will? Of course. Frederick Douglass accomplished what he did in a time when *his brethren were literally considered property*.
But we don't sit around and pontificate that his fellow-slaves should have done what he did. No doubt they would have liked that very much.
No, he was an exception to a rule. A racist rule - black people are not set up to succeed in a world with a racist heritage. And with a racist heritage, the world is still racist. Our institutions are still racist. Our culture itself is still racist.
Look at the tropes in the media "angry black woman", "fat sassy black woman," "welfare queen," and that modern minstrel, the black comedian that makes white people laugh.
This is a culture that is not finished with it's racial struggles.
And this, this is why I think it's wrong to treat someone differently based on "statistics" about their group or race, whether they be true or not. Because they are a person first, a color last.
Am I more likely to be robbed by a black guy than a white woman? Yes. That's the truth. But I will approach black men as warmly as I would hope they would approach me. This is the only morality that I can defend. This is the only way the world can slowly heal from the wounds of the past.
Undoubtedly there are non-white people who have judged me badly because of my race, my whiteness. You call this racism, I call it reverse racism and mock how big a deal many of you make about it.
There's a reason for this - it simply is not relevant compared to the massive injustices that continue to face historically marginalized groups. I do take it seriously and think it unfortunate. It hurts to be judged by race. But 99 times out 100 this harsh judgment comes from a reaction against the same oppressive system that history has handed us that I wish did not exist anymore.
And so no, I don't lock my doors as the black guy walks by, like Obama I think rightly pointed out.
If everyone looked at you and assumed you were up to no good, and you were poor, with no support from your family because they have problems of their own making, and the teachers at your school antagonized you because they think you're disrespectful, and you just wanted some money to impress a girl you liked or some other crushingly familiar human thing, would you not perhaps decide to take after your friend and join him in stealing someone's jewelry?
"Tout comprendre c'est tout pardonner."
I know what you'll say. I would never do that. I have morals. I'd like to think I'd never do that either. But I also find it repulsive to say to someone like that: "*I* would never do that." I'm not them. I didn't grow up the way they did.
If I had been born in Texas in 1840, fuck, I probably would have died on an Arkansas battlefield in the name of slavery ahem I mean, excuse me, states rights. I would have believed it was a just cause. If I had been born in Germany in 1920 I would have probably died in a French town fighting the Allies in the name of the master race. I'd like to think I'd be better, that I would have been an outlier. I would have plotted to assassinate Hitler. I would have informed for the Resistance.
But let's face it. We can't all be above average.
And so, I hope now you can see, that there are some very fucked up things that continue to happen in this world on the basis of race, gender, class, sexuality, and many others. They should end. The most grievous of these continue to stem from the domination of the world by Euro-American men.
These are the injustices that most badly need healing. So many things stem from them. And to the extent that I can do my part by listening, as a white person, to these other groups and trying my best to understand their experience, without inserting my own (irrelevant, since I'm white and not whatever they are) experience, I do so. To the extent that I can not allow latent racism, produced not by a person (i.e. Draugnar) but by a culture we are all a part of, so as to habituate people to the contrary, I will.
And to the extent that I can treat people of other demographics like a person and not an identity, I will, without claiming a counter-productive and even hypocritical "color-blindness."
I do not hate myself, or my group, but what I do hate is that my ancestors left of a legacy of hatred and domination. I am not responsible for what they did, but I am responsible for what occurs between my birth and death. And since their heinous crimes still echo through the present, inaction simply will not do.
I hope this makes sense, and if you read all this (though krellin will not), thank you.