Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 386 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
tilMletokill (100 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
What is this NOOO not another fast game by tilMletokill?
gameID=14737
Yep its me
19 replies
Open
trainedkilla (444 D)
28 Oct 09 UTC
Looking for a seventh!
Group of players looking for a seventh player. We've played together before but have no predetermined alliances. gameID=14718. Password is saigon.
11 replies
Open
Sicarius (673 D)
26 Oct 09 UTC
Writers
How about in the spirit of friendship, we share poems and short stories and jokes we've made up and things like that? Of course we all have opposing political ideas, they wouldnt be politics if we didnt right? but we can still all get along and value each others input too.
20 replies
Open
cwute (0 DX)
28 Oct 09 UTC
Fast game!
Pls list names here- need 6 more

5 bet WTA
5 replies
Open
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
25 Oct 09 UTC
diplomacy statistics
As promised, I have compiled a listing of a variety of statistics covering 1001 consecutive games. I did not calculate the following types of games since they throw off the statistics in one way or another:
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
25 Oct 09 UTC
Games that ended before 1904
Solo wins when the winner had less than 18 supply centers
Gunboat games
Public press games
Games with 3 or more countries ending with a "resigned" status
Games with clear evidence of multi-accounting

*note that any time draw wins are calculated, percentages do not tally to 100% since in any draw situation, more than one country is calculated as the 'winner'

% of total wins (solo or drawn wins):
France: 30.0%
Turkey: 29.3%
Russia: 28.7%
England: 27.0%
Germany: 26.4%
Italy 18.2%
Austria: 17.9

% of solo wins out of all total games / out of all solo wins
Russia: 13.9% / 20.3%
Turkey: 12.4% / 18.1%
France: 10.7% / 15.6%
Germany/England: 9.8% / 14.3 %
Austria: 6.8% / 9.8%
Italy: 5.0% / 7.3%

% of drawn games out of all games / out of all drawn games
France: 19.3 / 60.9%
England: 17.2% / 54.3%
Turkey: 16.8% / 53.0%
Germany: 16.6% / 52.4%
Russia: 14.8% / 46.7%
Italy: 13.2% / 41.6%
Austria: 11.1% / 35.0%

% of eliminations out of all games / out of all solo games
Austria: 60.8% / 58.8%
Russia: 48.2% / 45.8%
Italy: 47.3% / 42.1%
Germany: 46.7% / 46.2%
England: 38.3% / 34.8%
France: 34.0% / 31.6%
Turkey: 27.0 / 17.7%

concerning drawn games, the breakdown of the percentage of number of players participating in a draw is as follows:

out of all games / out of all draws
3-way: 15.2% / 47.9%
4-way: 7.2% / 22.7%
2-way: 4.9% / 15.5%
5-way: 2.0% / 6.3%
6-way: 1.5% / 4.7%
7-way: 0.9% / 2.8%
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
25 Oct 09 UTC
next, i will work on the individual countries and supply a variety of other statistics that may be fun or useful.
WhiteSammy (132 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
im confused regarding the percentages....can you explain the logic behind percents adding to be over 100% total?
Don Corleone (277 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
e.g. in a two way draw, two players "won" as computed in the first statistic.
Ivo_ivanov (7545 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
This is the solo wins by country, if I understand it correctly.
Russia: 20.3%
Turkey: 18.1%
France: 15.6%
Germany 14.3%
England: 14.3%
Austria: 9.8%
Italy: 7.3%
jarrah (185 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
Nice!!
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
25 Oct 09 UTC
to explain the stats a little more:

the % of total wins is a calculation of all wins and draws combined by a country over the 1001 games and listed in order from highest pct to lowest, thusfrance came out ahead winning or drawing in 30.0% of all games.

the % of solo wins out of all games / out of all solos are the calculations of a country's solo win percentage first given out of the 1001 games followed by the pct of all solo wins out of all games that ended with solo wins (684). thus in this case, russia solo won 13.9% of all games and solo won 20.3% of all games in which a country took a solo victory.

the next set of percentages are the same as they are for the solos but for draws instead. france drew 19.3% of all games and france participated in 60.9% of all drawn games (amazing!)

the final country statistic series is a calculation of all eliminations a country had (both in drawn games and solo win games) followed by all eliminations a country had in which a country took a solo. austria came out as the biggest loser here by being eliminated 60.8% of the time out of all 1001 games regardless of whether it came through a draw or solo win and they were eliminated in 58.8% of all games in which a player solo won.

the last statistic is the percentage of all n-way draws first as a percentage of all games played followed by a percentage of all drawn games (317). thus, the highest percentage of draws was with 3-way draws in 15.2% of all games played (1001) and 47.9% of all draws ended in a 3-way draw.
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
25 Oct 09 UTC
the reason some percentages go over 100% is because of draws. for example if we take 3 3-way draw games as follows:

game 1: drawn by austria, france, italy
game 2: drawn by russia, france, turkey
game 3 drawn by england, germany, russia

this means that france and russia drew 66.7% of the time while the other countries drew 33.3% of the time. thus if we look at the stats to it, it will read as follows:

france: 66.7%
russia 66.7%
england 33.3%
italy 33.3%
turkey 33.3%
germany 33.3%
austria 33.3%

clearly this does not add to 100%. instead, it will add to 300% (100% calculated over 3 games).

the only way to get percentages of draws to add to 100% is to grant a partial win instead of a complete win by dividing the 1 win over the n-players thus each player in the games listed above would get 1/3 of a win.

in order to do that for this list, you would have to take the average number of players per draw (its a little over 3) and divide all of the percentages by 3.

if people are interested in seeing this manipulation of the percent, i can calculate it when i get time. it wouldnt take much.
airborne (154 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
According to convential wisdom of Geography is Destiny (http://www.diplom.org/Zine/F1999R/Windsor/dipmap.html) the stats should of been
Russia
France
England
Turkey
Austria
Germany
Italy
Acosmist (0 DX)
25 Oct 09 UTC
The central powers are hard if you suck, sure.
Centurian (3257 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
France is hard to kill. So if there is a draw, shes likely to be in it.

Nice work TruNinja. I would be interested in knowing percentages for games with pot buy-ins over 100 D, or something along those lines. Because as Acosmist wisely quips, some countries suck if you suck, while other countries (like France) you can win with basically by accident.
Acosmist (0 DX)
25 Oct 09 UTC
France certainly is a pleasant experience, whereas Germany is a skill-tester. Austria is peculiar because you depend on convincing other people not to destroy you immediately, and few people pass up that chance at an easy early kill, but once you survive the holocaust Austria is a powerhouse. Proximity to the typical stalemate line and to the Balkans = GOOD TIMES
Acosmist (0 DX)
25 Oct 09 UTC
I think Turkey's good numbers can be attributed to proximity to the Balkans as well. Unlike Austria, Turkey is defensively very solid, so it doesn't suffer early crises as much, meaning it typically emerges from the Balkan Blitz (as I'll name the early struggle among Austria, Italy, Russia, and Turkey for regional control) alive. Being alive in the midgame + being near the Balkans = good times. And Turkey's position IS a lot better than Italy's.
Centurian (3257 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
I think Austria would be more of a force if she had better fleet capabilities. All armies limit expansion. Next to the early vulnerability this is Austria's biggest weakness.
Acosmist (0 DX)
25 Oct 09 UTC
Armies are very useful going south and east, though; not such a big deal if you can resolve the Italian issue.
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
France is the best country to play in high end WTA games.
Draugnar (0 DX)
25 Oct 09 UTC
@Tru Ninja, while your numbers ring true on draws, your explanation of the higher percentage is flawed.

Let's take your same three sample games and remove france from game 1, making it a 2-way draw.

game 1: drawn by austria, italy
game 2: drawn by russia, france, turkey
game 3 drawn by england, germany, russia

You logic of three games = 300% should still apply, but we'll show why it doesn't:

Austria draws 1/3 of the time
Italy draws 1/3 of the time
France, who used to draw 2/3 of the time now draws 1/3 of the time
Turkey, England, and Germany still draw 1/3 of the time each and Russia still draws 2/3 of the time.

That adds up to 8/3 or 266.7%. Where did the other 33.3% go?

I'll explain.

The real logic is that the total percent is based on the total number of a given type of draw/total number of drawn games then multiplied by the number of players in that type of draw (2 for 2-ways, 3 for 3-ways). So, in this example 1/3 of the games are 2-way draws and 2/3rds are three way draws. The total percentage is then 2*33.3333 (the 2 times the percent of 2-way draws) + 3*66.6667 (3 * the percent of 3-way draws) which equals 266.7%.

TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
Apparently among drawn games there is an average of 2.9 players. I'd have thought it would be between 3 and 4 myself.
Draugnar (0 DX)
25 Oct 09 UTC
So using this table of numbers:
out of all games / out of all draws
3-way: 15.2% / 47.9%
4-way: 7.2% / 22.7%
2-way: 4.9% / 15.5%
5-way: 2.0% / 6.3%
6-way: 1.5% / 4.7%
7-way: 0.9% / 2.8%

Solos: 68.3% / N/A

So, your "out of all games" draw percentages should add up to:
(.9*7) + (1.5*6) + (2*5) + (4.9*2) + (7.2*4) + (15.2*3) = 109.5
(another 68.3% of the games are solo victories)

And your out of draw percentages add up to 344.8%

A check of this confirms:

% of drawn games out of all games / out of all drawn games
France: 19.3 / 60.9%
England: 17.2% / 54.3%
Turkey: 16.8% / 53.0%
Germany: 16.6% / 52.4%
Russia: 14.8% / 46.7%
Italy: 13.2% / 41.6%
Austria: 11.1% / 35.0%
----------------------------------
Total 109% / 343.9%

This is roughly correct when you figure in rounding errors.
Draugnar (0 DX)
25 Oct 09 UTC
I compute the average size to be 3.4 players in a draw? There is no way it is below three when the top 2 types of draws or 3-way and 4-way and together they hold more than 2/3 of all drawn games.
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
25 Oct 09 UTC
@ draugnar: thats what i was explaining is that you have to total all of the draws in a way that 2-ways are 1/2, 3-way draws are 1/3, etc. in my example, all of the draws were 3-way since its easier to show. if you look at the total number of the 317 drawn games, the average is somewhere between 3 and 4. (hence 344.8% total)

yes, TGM, the average is between 3 and 4. you can find this by looking at the actual numbers.
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
25 Oct 09 UTC
@draugnar, the reason your math is flawed is because you tabulated the example game 1 as a 2-way draw. you forgot a country :)
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
25 Oct 09 UTC
@ centurian, good point. i can certainly tabulate that given some time.

right now, im working on some austrian percentages on thru to the other 7 countries
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
Draugnar, Tru Ninja: Must have missed a country out or something.
Draugnar (0 DX)
25 Oct 09 UTC
No, Tru Ninja, That was to show that it isn't then number of games * 100% as you said. I intentionally took France out. Reread my post. My numbers are 100% accurate. I write statistical software for a living.
Draugnar (0 DX)
25 Oct 09 UTC
@Tru Ninja - read this sentence form my post. It shows why I removed France to show where you explanation was wrong.

"Let's take your same three sample games and remove france from game 1, making it a 2-way draw."
Draugnar (0 DX)
25 Oct 09 UTC
Oh, and your numbers are fine, it was just you explanation of the tabulation being over 100% that was slightly flawed. You "number of games * 100%) should produce a percentage in the 10s of thousands (assuming more than 100 draws which I'm sure there are).
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
26 Oct 09 UTC
ah, ic. its either cuz its been late or lack of sleep from baby. i see what youre saying.
Draugnar (0 DX)
26 Oct 09 UTC
Probably a combination of both. Congrats on being a dad (assuming you are dad, not mom or <gasp> sibling).
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
26 Oct 09 UTC
yes, a two-time dad. i couldnt handle being a mom. something about another human being syphoning liquid from my nipples does things to my mind.
JECE (1248 D)
28 Oct 09 UTC
I'm just making sure this is in my replies.


31 replies
tilMletokill (100 D)
28 Oct 09 UTC
School Security or work Security?
I got a school Laptop and I want to know a proxy to get on this site on that computer if anyone knows one please share.
4 replies
Open
jahir5 (100 D)
28 Oct 09 UTC
join
i need three more persons so we can begin the game
any one is welcome to join the start of WWI
0 replies
Open
jahir5 (100 D)
28 Oct 09 UTC
join
come on ppl join the start of WWI so we can finally play.
0 replies
Open
hellalt (80 D)
26 Oct 09 UTC
Noobs annoyingly stupid
There is this game in which Austria, a noob in his first game ever doesn't want to ally with I and T and prefers to grant E a victory instead of going for a draw.
66 replies
Open
ottovanbis (150 DX)
28 Oct 09 UTC
New Game Thus Spoke Zarathustra
15 pt buy in three day phases
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=14664
bring your skill!!! the password is the name of the man who wrote the piece in the title (father of existentialism... Ecce Homo... etc) spell it correctly.
0 replies
Open
DJEcc24 (246 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
join a game with DJEcc24!
i have realized jsut now i have never played a game on here with the many forum posters like Draugnar and hellalt and crazyter and the rest. if interested i will be making a game. no password needed. winner takes all 15 point bet
13 replies
Open
chinter (100 D)
25 Oct 09 UTC
Why are so many games passworded?
Can someone explain why most games require a password. Surely new and inexperienced payers will only get better by playing with good and experienced players.
26 replies
Open
gilgatex (100 D)
26 Oct 09 UTC
Looking for some variant/beta testers
I'm looking testers to join a game, specifically testing 1) in-game instant messaging and 2) Adaptation of the "Fall of the American Empire" 10-player variant (see http://careyj.com/dip/map/EMP/initialMap_small.png )
26 replies
Open
Maniac (184 D(B))
26 Oct 09 UTC
In defence of Noob179
We the undersigned welcome Noob179 to our community and hope that any unpleasentness directed at you by Hellalt does not spoil your enjoyment of the game. We defend a player's right to play the game [for it is a game] how they wish.
95 replies
Open
airborne (154 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Superior of a system
one reason why webdiplomacy is better than worldleaders
7 replies
Open
kestasjk (95 DMod(P))
26 Oct 09 UTC
Anyone speak Swedish?
Browsing Wikipedia I read that one of the founders of The Pirate Bay was implicated in a robbery of a primary school, and his blood was found at the scene of the crime. The source is in Swedish though, thought I'd try my luck and see if anyone could translate the relevant parts?
http://www.realtid.se/ArticlePages/200901/20/20090120115505_Realtid725/20090120115505_Realtid725.dbp.asp?sAction=lk
14 replies
Open
cwute (0 DX)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Fast game!
Created as above name- 5 pts, 20 min turns.... PLS join;)
0 replies
Open
cwute (0 DX)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Anyone for a fast 5 or 10 min game?
5pt bet?
0 replies
Open
Iggy (753 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Admin!!
Pic cannot move to Burgundy and cannot support any move to Burgundy!!!!
14 replies
Open
paulsantac (179 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
movement question
Are North Africa and spain a land border? Can an army not a fleet move from North Africa to Spain without a convoy?
8 replies
Open
tailboarder (100 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Need a new Russian
13 replies
Open
BarrackObama (368 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Winning percentages by Country?
Does anyone have the statistics for winning percentages by country?
3 replies
Open
Jamiet99uk (808 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
November Ghost-ratings?
I see that the Ghostratings for November are now online.
Can someone explain why? I thought it was still October!
31 replies
Open
california (100 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Live Game
gameID=14733
Best game ever. Must join. 10 minute phases(so it doesn't crash).
0 replies
Open
Tantris (2456 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Austria left - someone takeover to end game...
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=13740#gamePanel
0 replies
Open
Mostly Harmless (134 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Moderator needed - game stuck in pause
We've voted to unpause the game, but it doesn't seem to have any effect. Here's the URL: http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=14082

Thanks in advance.
5 replies
Open
california (100 D)
26 Oct 09 UTC
Football Teams
Whats your favorite football team and who do you think will win the super bowl?

I like the Giants!!!
12 replies
Open
Zman (207 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Movement question
Ok say Turkish Army A is moving from Area A to Area B, and Turk army B is moving to Area A supported by Turk Army C. But, Rus Army A is moving to Area B, and Rus Army B is moving to Area A supported by Rus army C. What happens?
13 replies
Open
SteevoKun (588 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Live Game?
Eh?
2 replies
Open
denis (864 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
Black Stars.
In shool of war a black stars apeered next to the builds, but most were still yellow.
10 replies
Open
Page 386 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top