Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 255 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
lulzworth (366 D)
27 Apr 09 UTC
Rules Question - What happens?
Let's say you have territories A, B, C, and D all of which can move into one another.
Country 1 controls A and B, country 2 controls C and D.
Country one moves A to C with support from B, meanwhile Country two moves C to A with support from D.
2 replies
Open
superchunk (4890 D)
27 Apr 09 UTC
JOIN NOW 8hrs 25pts ppsc
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=10394
0 replies
Open
iMurk789 (100 D)
27 Apr 09 UTC
rules question
say i have an army in provinces A, B and C. A and B border each other, and C borders A. can the army in B and the army in A switch places if i order the army in A into B, the army in B into A, and C supports B into A?
Draugnar (0 DX)
27 Apr 09 UTC
Nope. A support of an attack on oneself can only be used to hold off an attack from somewhere else. It can not be used to dislodge your unit.

And, even if it could, the dislodged unit cannot retreat to the territory from which it was attacked.

The only way two units can swap places is through the use of a convoy.
jbalcorn (429 D)
27 Apr 09 UTC
They cannot switch places. B goes to A, A Retreats.
Draugnar (0 DX)
27 Apr 09 UTC
jbalcorn is wrong. B does not go to A as you CANNOT displace your own nation by supporting an attack on your territory. It's in the rules.
jbalcorn (429 D)
27 Apr 09 UTC
I didn't realize that he was talkking all the same player.

In that case, I stand corrected - thanks Draugnar. You cannot displace your own units - you can bounce them, but not displace them.
Draugnar (0 DX)
27 Apr 09 UTC
I guess the bigger question is: why would you want to swap armies? One army is as good as another.
Robyrt (113 D)
27 Apr 09 UTC
I can see wanting to swap if a fleet is involved - the ol' Coastal Crawl where you swap around Spain or Bulgaria to switch the coast a fleet is on - but yeah, armies A and B can't switch places unless you have a fleet to convoy A to B.
iMurk789 (100 D)
27 Apr 09 UTC
yea i want to swap a fleet and an army. i just said all armies so that no questions were asked like 'is it an landlocked province? or which coast is the fleet on?'
iMurk789 (100 D)
27 Apr 09 UTC
by the way, thanks for clarifying it.


8 replies
figlesquidge (2131 D)
26 Apr 09 UTC
Crealey
http://www.phpdiplomacy.net/profile.php?userID=13939
Please will you email me, I couldn't get through to you with the email address in your profile. If anyone else gets this and shares a game with him, please pass on this message
3 replies
Open
mapleleaf (0 DX)
27 Apr 09 UTC
Another new game...
All are welcome....
1 reply
Open
mapleleaf (0 DX)
25 Apr 09 UTC
New game
All are welcome(a good way to bury points for the league games)
;0)
12 replies
Open
davinci (0 DX)
27 Apr 09 UTC
Hurry Join Beginners Game.
Only 77 minutes left until 1st phase!! beginners only!!
0 replies
Open
Denzel73 (100 D)
27 Apr 09 UTC
Slow Gunboat game
http://www.phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=10396
36 hours, 102 pt entry, ppsc

If you like being brutal while keeping your mouth shut, please join!
0 replies
Open
danikine74 (167 D)
22 Apr 09 UTC
Change passwords

Can two countries playing the same game change his passwords so one can make the turn of the other?? is this allowed??
27 replies
Open
djbent (2572 D(S))
24 Apr 09 UTC
stalemate ethics
seeking the community's perspective on the right thing to do when a stalemate line has been reached. please chime in!
46 replies
Open
davinci (0 DX)
27 Apr 09 UTC
Beginners Game!!!!
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=10389
14 Hour Phases.
Only Beginners allowed!!
22 point buy in.
0 replies
Open
Onar (131 D)
25 Apr 09 UTC
Help with moves?
Turkey and Italy seem to be my worst two countries. Anyone have any advice to offer with good opening moves for them?
9 replies
Open
Captain_Jay (241 D)
26 Apr 09 UTC
Player Won't Finalize!
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=10214

In this game, the player of Austria (mutface) won't finalize because he wants to survive for as long as possible. He clearly stated this in the global chat. Is there a way to force the game to continue? I for one, do not have the patience to wait 35 hours.
7 replies
Open
OMGNSO (415 D)
26 Apr 09 UTC
Are their polite chat rules?
Specifically does what Russia (ThEaNgEl7) said to me (Turkey) break these rules.
6 replies
Open
P.Ginsberg (125 D)
26 Apr 09 UTC
New Game
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=10382
24 hours, 10 points, PPSC
4 replies
Open
tom12 (0 DX)
26 Apr 09 UTC
New game
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=10380
58 points (all of mine) 24 hour phases
0 replies
Open
jbalcorn (429 D)
25 Apr 09 UTC
Mechanics of CD
I thought when someone went CD that was it. I'm in a game where a player in a losing position purposely won't finalize because he's being obnoxious (That's not speculation. He said so in global chat). He went CD, but now he's active again, even though he's not putting in any orders. If a CD player comes into a game, do they have the option of re-activating?
5 replies
Open
Lord&Master (146 D)
25 Apr 09 UTC
Profanity has no place in diplomacy
This is the whole conversation in the A Clash of Kings. iMurk is a sore loser that has resorted to profanity and personal attacks. Please deal with him.
18 replies
Open
TheSleepingBear (100 D)
25 Apr 09 UTC
Rule issue.
My Diplomacy rulebook at home says that support can be supported (the 2000 version). I thought this site followed to normal rules of Diplomacy. If so, I should have gotten Tunis, right (see the next post for the link)?
31 replies
Open
laurenceofarabia (100 D)
25 Apr 09 UTC
Question
If Italy takes Constantinople with Ankara and Smyrna supporting, and if Turkey takes Ankara with Constantinople and Black Sea supporting, what happens? Do both Ankara & Constinople switch owners?
17 replies
Open
flashman (2274 D(G))
24 Apr 09 UTC
Waiting so long for the Leagues and GFDT to restart!
Just as it says on the tin...
16 replies
Open
Kea (254 D)
26 Apr 09 UTC
what will happen to orders which are not finalized?
will the orders be executed or is it a hold to every fleet / army?

thx in adv
3 replies
Open
Xapi (194 D)
26 Apr 09 UTC
A multi account acusation
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=10328
2 replies
Open
Skenderbeg (370 D)
25 Apr 09 UTC
Question about support
Hi. I'd appreciate if someone could shed some light on this situation.

Here's the game in question:
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=9864n
12 replies
Open
ThEaNgEl7 (100 D)
26 Apr 09 UTC
...
Join the NOOOOBS R US game
0 replies
Open
ThEaNgEl7 (100 D)
26 Apr 09 UTC
Noob only game
the game is called wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
2 replies
Open
mlempic2 (377 D)
25 Apr 09 UTC
Realtime game
Anyone in? 1 hr phases, only 5 pts
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=10364
0 replies
Open
Suleiman II (339 D)
25 Apr 09 UTC
Riders of Rohan!
A new game, 20 point buy in, for all you LoTR fans.

http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=10362
3 replies
Open
Geofram (130 D(B))
25 Apr 09 UTC
Any mods online?
We started that live game and everyone but Italy is here. Is it possible to force him into CD or do we need to wait the hour?
1 reply
Open
TheWizard (5364 D(S))
25 Apr 09 UTC
Sitter needed...
from sunday until tuesday afternoon.
3 replies
Open
Page 255 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top