Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 1242 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
CommanderByron (801 D(S))
24 Mar 15 UTC
Realistic Rebellion Diplomacy
So I was thinking of a new variant idea. The variant would play like regular diplomacy except that if you leave a occupied supply center open for a full year then that nation gets to build an Army on that area. It would simulate the effects of occupation in that occupation doesn't always go as planned. (more to follow)
7 replies
Open
GOD (389 D)
24 Mar 15 UTC
LIVE GAME
Saw that the old live game thread is closed...anyone up to play?
4 replies
Open
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
24 Mar 15 UTC
(+1)
Cancelling
It's disgraceful to cancel ONLY when you realize the NMR doesn't favor you.
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
24 Mar 15 UTC
I was Russia in Fluffhead-26, and I had my cancel vote up as soon as there was an S01 NMR. So did Austria. The other four of you, besides Turkey who didn't ever vote cancel, of you only did so when you realize I'd roll over you guys and/or kept making the right moves and had 10 centers in 1903 and became a solo threat.

If a game should be cancelled, that means it should never have happened due to some reason, such as often a S01 NMR for example. It doesn't mean "oh fuck I'm not gonna win". If you actually mean to honestly cancel you would have done so right away, when the impetus for cancelling actually happens. If something like this happens and people don't cancel for multiple game years I have no moral qualms taking it down later (I put it up A01 and would leave it up until S04, I ended up leaving it up until S05) even if the stubborn people then throw it up. Cancels should be done immediately if you want them, because they should be based on the philosophical/ethical parts of the game, no ot on the current game board. Otherwise you forfeit your right to.

And yes, the people who put up cancel got screwed, but two things
1) Just like you can get screwed by them playing like shit or not putting up the draw or not knowing stalemate lines, which also happens
2) People who don't want to cancel unless it disfavors them wouldn't have cancelled in the lead by definition, and there are some people who don't understand or refuse to cancel, and also would have eliminated you if they were the ones who shot ahead.

/rant

I don't know what Turkey's deal was. Either
A) Doesn't believe in cancels...and then there's nothing I can do
B) Was trying to exploit by holding out and only cancelling if he's about to be eliminated and I'm not going to put up with that shit.

P.S., for those who don't know because it's not necessarily obvious, here's what "Cancel" does:
The game will be un-existed. There will be no record of it anywhere, everyone is returned their bet no matter their current position/state. It does not go on your record. It is for games that, effectively, never should have happened (such as when one player doesn't show up at all as ATC alludes to). It is annulled. It's useful for games where an early civil disorder means that you no longer have everyone at the table, and the game hasn't got very far.

P.P.S. normally I'd attack whoever isn't cancelling but I couldn't do that as a Russia who decided to go North to a Turkey who Austria fucked up attack and decided to suicide into Italy instead. And I shouldn't be expected to either.

P.P.P.S. I meant to support SER-BUL not BUL-SER in A03. Sorry Austria, that was a misorder.

P.P.P.P.S. It is now S05 and I have removed my cancel vote.(I'm writing this post live)

P.P.P.P.P.S. again, this isn't about how Turkey didn't cancel. It's about the people who only cancelled once they realized they weren't the ones to get the most out of the NMR. Although it is my opinion that Turkey is in the wrong here and if he waited to just cut three people out before ending the game rather than doing the just and nice and not-wasting-our-time thing I'm going to be pissed for an entirely different reason.

P.P.P.P.P.S. It is now S07 and I have returned my cancel vote.(I'm writing this post live) It's clear Turkey won't cancel no matter what. This game should be cancelled not drawn but whatever makes it end right now is fine with me.

P.P.P.P.P.P.S. and now a Turkey NMR? WTF dude

P.P.P.P.P.P.P.S. turns out Turkey finally went into CD and we got the three way draw. He's really knew but it doesn't excuse this behavior. At all. What a waste of time. gameID=157420 for reference
Games with NMRs (especially multiple ones) in the first turn should be cancelled automatically without requiring the consent of the players.
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
24 Mar 15 UTC
Not without more severe punishment, because other wise one could get out of bad openings or even just not liking your country. There's a reason that hasn't been implemented. And it's not trivial adding much more severe punishments.

Ideally it should be a sportsmanship thing.
Jamiet99uk (808 D)
24 Mar 15 UTC
Diplomacy is not a game that lends itself to sportsmanship, to be fair.
ssorenn (0 DX)
24 Mar 15 UTC
(+2)
I don't agree with that at all. Just because,bending the truth or blatantly lying is part of the game, sportsmanship is a big part. It requires 7 people to play game, and half or more know they're going to lose from the start, but they play it out anyway.
dyager_nh (619 D)
24 Mar 15 UTC
Best learn to just play with NMRs.
It just changes the game and people need to react properly inside of the game to counter the effects of the NMR just as you would any unbalancing event in the game.
dyager_nh (619 D)
24 Mar 15 UTC
Shit dude...this was a Live Game?

You play live you best just accept NMRs and CDs.
ssorenn (0 DX)
24 Mar 15 UTC
As forced cxl is looking like it's not happening for S01 NMRs in live games, another thought could be, when you NMR a certain amount of times, you can't play live anymore , or for an extended period of time
Valis, how about this:

If you sign up for a game and it begins and you check into webdip and don't enter orders and NMR, the game should be canceled and you should suffer point loss.

If you sign up for a game and it begins and you don't check in and NMR, the game should be canceled.
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
24 Mar 15 UTC
I'd say bring these thoughts to the improvements thread.


10 replies
steephie22 (182 D(S))
24 Mar 15 UTC
Putting a new product on the market..
So I built my first prototype of an idea for a product I had and it's better than expected. I still am trying to figure out the best materials etc., but I plan to produce and sell the products eventually.
Anything I should keep in mind? I guess I should get a patent? Other things?
11 replies
Open
ejb0527 (967 D)
23 Mar 15 UTC
Thinking of starting a league of honest
Many people who play web diplomacy cheat together or lie. I would like to start a brotherhood in which live games are played and everyone has to be honest with each other when it comes to being allies....thoughts?
26 replies
Open
MaximillianTheFirst (0 DX)
24 Mar 15 UTC
Joining new games
has anyone had issues joining new games with the password? I've reset my password, and logged back in twice, and the password won't work for joining a new game. Am I supposed to use a different password than my login?
4 replies
Open
grking (100 D)
23 Mar 15 UTC
(+1)
Mint Chocolate Chip is hands down the best ice cream flavor
Prove me wrong.
12 replies
Open
thdfrance (162 D)
24 Mar 15 UTC
Inviting a friend
I have a close friend who I would love to introduce to the site. He's never played diplomacy but he's expressed an interest in learning. I'm looking for advice from people who actually know some of the people they play with on this site. How do I introduce my friend without breaking any of the meta rules?
8 replies
Open
Wusti (725 D)
23 Mar 15 UTC
Do any of you WebDippers play EVE Online?
Simple question - love to see your answers and list Alliance and sign up date too please:

Wusti - June 2006 - C0NVICTED
17 replies
Open
CommanderByron (801 D(S))
23 Mar 15 UTC
Vote Byron 2032
See Inside
17 replies
Open
ejb0527 (967 D)
24 Mar 15 UTC
Need 1 Please
1 reply
Open
ejb0527 (967 D)
23 Mar 15 UTC
Live Gameeeeee
gameID=157405

Would really like to fill up this live game with good players, starting in an hour
0 replies
Open
abgemacht (1076 D(G))
23 Mar 15 UTC
(+1)
The Boroughs Tournament/webDip F2F
The Boroughs will be held from Aug 22-23 in Marlborough, Ma. We will be hosting the second webDip F2F and a meet-and-great on Friday evening for those who arrive early. See https://sites.google.com/site/boroughsdiplomacy/home for info on Tournament, Hotels, etc. Please contact TheBoroughsDiplomacy to register.
3 replies
Open
TrPrado (461 D)
22 Mar 15 UTC
This is my 2000th post
I officially have no life.
9 replies
Open
Hellenic Riot (1626 D(G))
21 Mar 15 UTC
(+1)
Mod Team Announcement
See inside for details.
31 replies
Open
Tolstoy (1962 D)
20 Mar 15 UTC
What would happen if an 800 kiloton nuclear bomb detonated over Manhattan?
https://www.lewrockwell.com/2015/03/no_author/if-an-800-kiloton-nuclear-warhead-detonated-above-manhattan/
37 replies
Open
KingCyrus (511 D)
22 Mar 15 UTC
Chuck Norris is Dead
(not literally)
3 replies
Open
Sylvania (4104 D)
22 Mar 15 UTC
New gunboat game - one spot left
Modern Diplomacy II, 36-hr phases, 80 point buy in, PPSC, anon
gameID=157258
0 replies
Open
trip (696 D(B))
22 Mar 15 UTC
The Lusthog Squad-20
A friendly reminder that voting to draw is prohibited until the game has been stalemated. Thx.
0 replies
Open
abgemacht (1076 D(G))
21 Jan 15 UTC
(+3)
webDiplomacy Player Map
Interested in playing a F2F game? Just want to know where people live? Check out the webDip Player Map! Post your city, country, and color preference here to be included on the map.
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=zkz1OHicklqk.ky67Va8gNVi0
55 replies
Open
Hannibal76 (100 D(B))
21 Mar 15 UTC
Choosing Nations
I've been playing on this site for a while and something is really bugging me. I've played 8 games so far and I love this site just to be clear. BUT what's absolutely annoying is the fact that when you're nation is chosen it seems to be completely random. Why? Because of the 8 games I've had: Russia 3 times, Italy 3 times, and Turkey 2 times. I have 2 requests.
11 replies
Open
KingCyrus (511 D)
20 Mar 15 UTC
(+1)
ISIS BOMBING
ISIS is claiming credit for an attack today in Yemen that killed over 120 people. Two mosques were simultaneously attacked by as many as four possible suicide attackers.
27 replies
Open
santosh (335 D)
21 Mar 15 UTC
Gunboat with friends
Hullo. A few friends and I started a gunboat game at gameID=157247...

1 reply
Open
VashtaNeurotic (2394 D)
13 Feb 15 UTC
Mafia VII Sign Up Thread.
See Inside.
190 replies
Open
CommanderByron (801 D(S))
20 Mar 15 UTC
Overplayed Music
So it seems that today radio and media in general get hold of a good song and overplay it until people become sick of it. Why do they do it? Why not give time to lesser known music, and thus prevent the dreaded overplayed feeling with good songs?
14 replies
Open
Strauss (758 D)
20 Mar 15 UTC
Eclipse has begun
http://c.tadst.com/gfx/eclipses/20150320/path-760.png
16 replies
Open
What in the world is this game?
gameID=93086

1978?!
3 replies
Open
Rodgersd09 (100 D)
20 Mar 15 UTC
Changing Username
Is it in anyway possible to change my username? I was a bit of twaddle and didn't realise it was username and not email on start up, and obviously I can't create a new account as that's meta gaming - is it at all possible? :)
4 replies
Open
Porthmeus (104 D)
19 Mar 15 UTC
What is the vote "Cancel" and what does it do?
I understand the votes for draw and pause, but what does the 'cancel' vote do? Does it cancel the last turn?
5 replies
Open
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
17 Mar 15 UTC
Rating Systems Question
I want to canvas for opinion on an aspect of rating system design. Please see inside.
66 replies
Open
Page 1242 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top