@goldie -- I've heard such analysis - it's a gamers concole, yadda yadda. I just simply do not buy that. Both systems will have their stash of awesome games, a bunch of OK games and then other games. But in our house, the camera is essential (girls...Just Dance...). Also, we use the XBox as our media hub probably more than a game console - no cable / no sat tv, so Netflix streaming, music streaming, etc is a primary function too, and the interface on XBox is well done, and looks to be even better on the XBox One.
Free games...all good and well, but I can't finish most of the games that I speficially purchased, so getting a shitload of free games becomes less important for me. if I were unmarried, that would be good....but if I were unmarried, my decision would probably be "Whatever most of my friends are getting" because I would rock on kicking their asses in multi-player.
@ILN -- tried a free-to-play 4 a couple week a few years back on Eve....complex, never got in to it. I know it is a niche space game with complex controls, and incredibly loyal following and I am intrigued by it. Read articles about shit that happens in there sometimes (guild stuff) and it cracksme up and I wish I was a part of it...but I'll probably never go there, just because i think it would require more of a time commitment than I have at this point (until the kids go to college....3 years from now...at which time I will be too broke for the next 5 years to upgrade my graphics card!!! lol)
@CF - Marvel Heroes? Wife and I did play City of Heroes for a while and loved the super hero thing. Joule's Law was my cigar-chompin' bad-ass hero, with electric power as his main thing and he could fly. <sigh....> Yeah....Joule's Law definitely kicked some ass!