Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 522 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
ava2790 (232 D(S))
06 Mar 10 UTC
Announcement
I finally have a bunch of points. LIVE GAME ANYONE?
2 replies
Open
C-K (2037 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Live Public Press Game!
"Too Drunk To Be Chatty!"

http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23383
40 D, WTA, Anon, 5 mins-Live
7 replies
Open
vlajko (224 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
New Anonymous Game 12hours phase
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23377
Pot is 100; Anonymous Players; In game messaging; 12h phase; Points per SC
Anyone can join.
1 reply
Open
dep5greg (644 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
2 players live game
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23376
1 reply
Open
ottovanbis (150 DX)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Sex Jokes
I'm sure this has been done before, just wondering if there are any good one's you guys and gals would care to share.
8 replies
Open
jimgov (219 D(B))
06 Mar 10 UTC
Anyone up for a gunboat?
Looking for some of the regulars who want to pull one off. If enough say yes, I will hook us up.
14 replies
Open
dep5greg (644 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Live game
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23370
0 replies
Open
Jimbozig (0 DX)
06 Mar 10 UTC
High stakes live gunboat this afternoon anyone?
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23358
0 replies
Open
h0lein0ne (178 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
High stakes gunboat
Please Join!!

gameID=23229
0 replies
Open
Muffin_Man (134 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Fast 5 minute phase game
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23354#gamePanel
Enjoy! ^^
0 replies
Open
The_Master_Warrior (10 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
Forum Categories?
When will there be separate Forums? Is anyone working on it?
11 replies
Open
noiseunit (853 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
The End of History (World Map 36 hours/phase)
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23349

World Map, 36 hours/phase, Anonymous
0 replies
Open
noiseunit (853 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Fantabulous Live Med Action (Join Game)
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23347
1 reply
Open
C-K (2037 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Public Press Game.
4 players needed.

http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23136
0 replies
Open
Jean Luc (640 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
bryn 5 needs one player
bryn5 needs only 1 player. It is anom and no comms. Password is pps.

Anyone is welcome!
3 replies
Open
Ycos3D (100 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
come out and play , gunboat 5D
Enjoy gameID=23341
0 replies
Open
Ycos3D (100 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
gunboat, 5D, we have coffe
enjoy gameID=23340, pls hurry up :)
1 reply
Open
dep5greg (644 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
GAME ANYONE?
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23333
1 reply
Open
dep5greg (644 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
GAME NOW LETS START
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23334
0 replies
Open
Conservative Man (100 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
My first solo!
gameID=23257
Any comments?
3 replies
Open
hellalt (113 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Burton's Alice in Wonderland
I watched the film today.
Nice costumes and direction but the movie was deprived of the philosophical value of the original script.
Actually it wasn't even childish. It was just crap.
Is that the future of cinema? A lot of costumes but no script?
22 replies
Open
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
03 Mar 10 UTC
March Ghost-Ratings List
Uploaded Current and All Time on my site:
tournaments.webdiplomacy.net

Use F3 or Ctrl+F to find your name.
Page 2 of 2
FirstPreviousNextLast
 
MadMarx (36299 D(G))
04 Mar 10 UTC
I like the idea of a time element to the rating system, but don't think it should be based on the number of games finished in the last month. Is there a reasonable amount of games we should be expected to play/finish in a given year (or six months) to be considered active? One a month? So, maybe our GR should be multiplied by x/12 (x = number of games played in the last year) so if you haven't played 12 games in the last year, your GR is zero, BUT, if you come back and start playing, as soon as you get up to 12 games your GR is fully restored, yet highly influenced by the 12 recent games you've just played?

Also, with someone like Berstein, he'll drop off naturally or a zero could be manually placed in this time factor to drop him off?
Alderian (2425 D(S))
04 Mar 10 UTC
Wouldn't you want to multiple by min(x,12)/12?

That way it is a detriment if you do not finish 12 per year and not a benefit for finishing more.
MadMarx (36299 D(G))
04 Mar 10 UTC
I don't know the code, but yeah, we (i.e. I) don't want Ivo to be #1 just because he plays 50 games every month! ;-)
KaptinKool (408 D)
04 Mar 10 UTC
I don't understand MadMarx already is #1...
sean (3490 D(B))
04 Mar 10 UTC
i think cheats like berstein should just be removed from both lists manually.
as for current list- why not something simple like if you are not in a current game (just one will do) or haven't been in a current game for say....3 months? then you are not displayed on the current list
Alderian (2425 D(S))
04 Mar 10 UTC
There are some players that haven't logged on in over a year but have a current (paused) game. If you want to keep it simple, then just don't display players who haven't finished a game in 3 months or however long. It is a question of defining an "active" player.
MadMarx (36299 D(G))
04 Mar 10 UTC
KaptinKool, my idea of the x/12 factor was meant to be equal to or less than one, but Alerian pointed out, for example, if you played 48 games a month, something I am jokingly accusing Ivo of doing each and every month, then Ivo's GR would be four times the actual number and thus have him #1, an outcome I'd prefer to avoid, for various reasons.
Stripy (2759 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
There is a huge variance in how often people play though. For every person who plays dozens of games a month there will be other people who play less than one a month.

My average is about one game a month since I joined and that will probably drop lower over the next year. Just going on one decent holiday can cause a 2 or 3 month break in gaming but I still consider myself a regular player here.

I personally wouldn't want to consider someone inactive unless they hadn't played for maybe a year which isn't really that long in a time consuming game like this.
figlesquidge (2131 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
Perhaps scale down by 0.9 each hour.
Maybe if Bearnstein was deleted from the GRL he wouldn't care to come back here.
hellalt (113 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
I think whoever doesn't play at least 1 game/month should not be included in the ghost ratings list.
jimgov (219 D(B))
05 Mar 10 UTC
How about just counting games that have finished within the past year. That way, we would know who the current best player is because the only points that count would be...wait for it...current.
figlesquidge (2131 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
well then hell I think I'd barely get in then - I finished one last month.
Ivo_ivanov (7545 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
Hey, MM, I'm not playing 50 games/month, closer to 10 actually, but I do agree to your point :)

I think the goal is not the change the system in a way which will, effectively, change how ratings are calculated... but simply to have a system that drops out inactive players.

Hence, it might be easier to just 'hide' players who have not finished a game in the past 3 months (1 seems too little, 6 seems too much), rather than having some formula to reduce their rating. This way, if the player comes back, he would not have lost anything, and if he doesn't the others don't need to see his GR in any case.

I think this is quite similar to what Alderian suggested, if I got it right?
IKE (3845 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
All I want to know is why can't I see the list? Would someone just please tell me how far I have fallen? Thanks.
jimgov (219 D(B))
05 Mar 10 UTC
Who cares about someone keeping their rating? I don't see that as being its purpose. It is about current players. If you aren't playing, why should you remain on the list? Let people who are actually playing work towards attaining the top spot. The all time list is for the purpose of showing the best of the best. Not the current list, IMO.
Ike...you are ranked 109th with a GR of 251.65. You fell 26 positions.
ottovanbis (150 DX)
05 Mar 10 UTC
That's not as bad as me, I fell like 31 spots I think, people started hating last month big time.
SEcki (1171 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
I like the idea to let people keep their rating, but only display active players (have a current game or last game is at most 3 months old) to show up in the ranking. Also get rid of the cheats.

You can also look at fics.org for a rating system that changes your rating shift based on the activity of your play - the more you play, the less your rating changes.
Alderian (2425 D(S))
05 Mar 10 UTC
@ivo, yes, that is basically one of the things I suggested, and would seem to be the simplist and probably best. One potential problem would be if the system only stores the date the game started and not the date it finished.
figlesquidge (2131 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
Finish date is stored
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
"Hence, it might be easier to just 'hide' players who have not finished a game in the past 3 months (1 seems too little, 6 seems too much), rather than having some formula to reduce their rating. This way, if the player comes back, he would not have lost anything, and if he doesn't the others don't need to see his GR in any case."

That's exactly what I'm planning on doing from as soon as is possible.
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
Scaling down ratings etc. is not a good idea, as it causes deflation.
jimgov (219 D(B))
05 Mar 10 UTC
Hey Ghost. I just want you to know that I am almost everybody on this forum (I believe) really appreciate your rankings. I could be very cool with you just leaving it as it is if it is going to cause you any headache. I just like the "what ifs" associated with trying to tweak it. Thanks.
Alderian (2425 D(S))
05 Mar 10 UTC
jimgov +1
ghost +1,000,000,000
IKE (3845 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Thanks Spell, wow I did not finish a game in February because of this world variant.
Is GR taking into account more SCs? In 2 of them I have more 18 SCs.
esrever88 (100 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Good news, I rose 543 places. Bad news, my ranking's still in four digits. Breaking the top 999 next month? Maybe?
figlesquidge (2131 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
re esrever: good luck :)
re Ike: no it doesn't. you sure you didn't finish a game? If so then enough people above you performed badly to give you the rain
MadMarx (36299 D(G))
06 Mar 10 UTC
Maybe it should be no games finished in the last 6 months? Or even 4 months? I could see someone taking a month off or so and then come back and join a couple 48 hour phase games and not finish a game for a couple months... Six months is probably too long, but 4 months seems reasonable and better than 3 months to me, though I suppose it doesn't matter too much...
figlesquidge (2131 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
I'm not sure what data you get access to Ghost (talk to you on msn about this soon?) but as MM points out, people could have returned yet be in slow games, so perhaps you could check for newly started games as well?


60 replies
5nk (0 DX)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Live WTA Gunboat
1 reply
Open
NEW MAP TRY OUT
join Third map variant try out to test the new map available!

bet to join : 20, anon, PpSC
1 reply
Open
caesariandiplomat (100 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
New Game- Please Join
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23260
We only need 2 more players to start!
1 reply
Open
5nk (0 DX)
06 Mar 10 UTC
AncMed Gunboat in 1 hr
1 reply
Open
StevenC. (1047 D(B))
06 Mar 10 UTC
Attention please.....
I am officially getting bored of WebDiplomacy.....enjoy.
6 replies
Open
The Wolf (100 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Live: Freaky Friday 2
dude only 2 more left like 2 minutes 2 join plz do
9 replies
Open
BrightEyes (1030 D)
05 Mar 10 UTC
New Game starting one day!
One day phase
101 D to buy in
PPSC
gameID=23290
1 reply
Open
dr_lovehammer (170 D)
06 Mar 10 UTC
Live Freaky Friday 2.
Live game: Same as Freaky Friday!
All who joined Freaky Friday please join Freaky Friday 2.
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=23311
2 replies
Open
Page 522 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top