Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[connorcompton]

Oh no. I'm on the fence, I'm going to fall off the fence, I don't know which garden I'm going to end up in, I know it's going to hurt though.

The chance of Fox being scum today have fallen, and the chances of ND being BA has risen... I think BA-ND being so relaxed about being away with the knowledge Fox is getting lynched is adding momentum.

I don't know what to think... I could not live with myself supporting yet another VT lynch...

I absolutely despise you if your scum, Fox, but ##VOTE ND.

[Foxcastle]

The spreadsheet was kinda dumb, but it was based on POE that I made an effort to find. (And no, you can't solve the game like that, but it called Damo and Peter! And Teacon was in the not-scum end of the rankings, so that was right, too. But I'll resurrect it if Connor is also scum, since he was number 2 (you can see on p. 265) but I excluded him and Damo because of the RB situation.) It's all WIFOM of course, because I didn't explain what in particular made me exclude certain pairs of people. (If I were scum willing to do that kind of project, you'd think I'd have done that.)

Another point on this that I think is in my favor as not being scum: I produced a list on page 265 that had Peterlund as "indeterminate" (due to lurking/not enough data) and then subsequently upgraded him (based on a comment by Squigs) to the third scumread.

Again, the spreadsheet may be dumb, but if I'm scum, why did I go from a reads list that had Peterlund as unknown to Damo and Peterlund together in the top 3? If I had been scum, I should have been working to keep Peter hidden, and it would have been very easy for me to either ignore Squigs comment or massage the spreadsheet to keep him indeterminate.

[connorcompton]

Fox - Connor mafia?

BA - ND?

I remember Fox pretty easily marking Connor in green on his weird list thing and I really didn't like it

He took Squigs' and your word immediately. I suspect it was him trying to appear agreeable, pandering to your viewpoint for doubt.

It may be impossible for me to be objective about this, but I am pretty sure "agreeable" is not how you would characterize my overall engagement with Squigs and Durga recently...

Fair enough. I don't look much into that.

[et]

ND is obviously scum.
He don't flip vote for me in spite of Percy's vote.
He vote just easy target.

[Durga]

And what does this mean Flav? Why are you so sure Balki is scum not BA. Who are the people BA killed. Who!!!

He's scum, so let the BA kill him, no need to waste our lynch on him
With the people, the BA has killed it literally makes no sense for it to be Balki
Those people weren't even close to being scum
but they also weren't suspecting Balki
I think the BA was self-preserving and that doesnt fit in with Balki

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT 6.5:

ND (4) - Foxcastle, et, Durga, connorcompton
Foxcastle (3) - ND, FlaviusAetius, Squigs44
et (1) - Percy Williams

Currently ND is set to be lynched.
Everyone has posted a valid vote.

DAY ENDS IN 2 HOURS, 57 MINUTES

[Percy Williams]

So the Mafia 100% knows who BA is, and the BA was a person who wanted Chippe dead.

I don't understand this. Do you believe this?

I posted this After I saw the Gm note that said the NK cannot be held, and I had a brain fart and forgot some possibilities, like NK and SK both being Chippe. So no, I don't believe this, I'm just dumb sometimes.

[Durga]

Fox asks Connor to vote for teacon, himself or for xorxes.

Connor replies:

To be frank, I don't have a clue about you, and I'm not making a useless vote, so I'll be happy to make a ##VOTE teacon7 instead.

[Durga]

@fox - why did you stay on teacon instead of voting xorxes again?

[Durga]

This game is hard because not only is there a third party but two of our days are useless for information.

[Foxcastle]

Fox asks Connor to vote for teacon, himself or for xorxes.

Connor replies:

To be frank, I don't have a clue about you, and I'm not making a useless vote, so I'll be happy to make a ##VOTE teacon7 instead.

Additional context: this is Day 3 with 1:41 to go, and Connor is making his first vote of the day to put Teacon in a tie with Xorxes at 5-5.

[Foxcastle]

This game is hard because not only is there a third party but two of our days are useless for information.

Four of our days, I'd say. But are you referring to the obv lynches on scum or the judge votes?

[Percy Williams]

I won't be here EOD, so if you want me to change my vote make your case in the next 15 minutes or so. (And yes, I might actually change my vote this phase )

[Foxcastle]

@fox - why did you stay on teacon instead of voting xorxes again?

I guess contrary to what I just posted, Xorxes was not an obv lynch. But the point was that if everyone piled on Xorxes, there wouldn't have been anything to analyze after the fact. The vote on Teacon (whom I was scumreading at the time) was to at least keep some potential vote movement alternatives open for us to analyze later.

[Durga]

This game is hard because not only is there a third party but two of our days are useless for information.

Four of our days, I'd say. But are you referring to the obv lynches on scum or the judge votes?

3 days is probably accurate. I'm referring to judge votes. Damo day is also useless.

[Durga]

Oh no. I'm on the fence, I'm going to fall off the fence, I don't know which garden I'm going to end up in, I know it's going to hurt though.

The chance of Fox being scum today have fallen, and the chances of ND being BA has risen... I think BA-ND being so relaxed about being away with the knowledge Fox is getting lynched is adding momentum.

I don't know what to think... I could not live with myself supporting yet another VT lynch...

I absolutely despise you if your scum, Fox, but ##VOTE ND.

Why have the chances of fox being scum fallen?

Why can you not live with yourself supporting yet another VT lynch? Didn't you say this game was overwhelming for you?

[Durga]

Squigs I think we should vote together. I don't really like the people on the ND wagon with me but I'm hoping it's because he's the BA. What are your thoughts.

[connorcompton]

Fox asks Connor to vote for teacon, himself or for xorxes.

Connor replies:

To be frank, I don't have a clue about you, and I'm not making a useless vote, so I'll be happy to make a ##VOTE teacon7 instead.

Can I ask what your point is here?

[connorcompton]

Oh no. I'm on the fence, I'm going to fall off the fence, I don't know which garden I'm going to end up in, I know it's going to hurt though.

The chance of Fox being scum today have fallen, and the chances of ND being BA has risen... I think BA-ND being so relaxed about being away with the knowledge Fox is getting lynched is adding momentum.

I don't know what to think... I could not live with myself supporting yet another VT lynch...

I absolutely despise you if your scum, Fox, but ##VOTE ND.

Why have the chances of fox being scum fallen?

Why can you not live with yourself supporting yet another VT lynch? Didn't you say this game was overwhelming for you?

1. I find myself easily manipulated by recency bias, I guess today Fox has corrected the way he's acted on D4 and is acting much more normally and sincere. Thinking about it the chances have rebounded for me. My guess is about 80% chance of scum.

2. I'm not sure what you're trying to say there.

[Squigs44]

Fox why is the last 12 hours the only time this game you have been townie? Why actually provide content that makes sense now and not earlier in the game?