Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

I can't stop thinking about what Balki did last day. I don't think there's a person more fun to play this game with. Who actually does that. I was convinced he was BA because of how willing he was to follow rdr.

I don't like teacon's analysis very much - Balki was very willing to vote with rdr and pushed his scummate xorxes so the shit about pushing damo is either trying to manipulate town into a mislynch or just flat out bad misguided analysis.

If there's a CC for judge it has to happen now.

I need to think through the implications of a judge CC some more, but I don't think it necessarily needs to happen today. If Neph doesn't use his powers today in a way that clears himself we can safely assume he is not the real judge, so a CC might not be necessary.

Or the real judge can just put up Neph

I don't know. I really dislike this town PR and feel like it hinders more than helps. But maybe it's a good idea to use it today. I just don't know on who, and I'm uncomfortable with the idea of limiting the lynch.

Who do you think is the scum team again?

[ND]

Well seeing how he (Neph) confirms Balki. Either Balki got a very lucky guess or Neph is scum. It will be interesting to see what Neph says and if he does use his power (if he is real judge). If so I think ET needs to be one of the two chosen. We know from my ET review that ET is almost certainly scum and two of the actual scum members voted for Espresso over ET. In either case, waiting to see what Neph does here.

[Nephthys]

Neph don't use your power unilaterally. I'd like to discuss the candidates with you.

Hit me with ideas currently percy vs teacon. I reckon we can kill ba now

[ND]

Will you consider ET again?

[Squigs44]

Wow, this game just got good. Once I get home from work I'll recrunch the numbers, iso Balki, and try to figure out what in the world is going on.

Durga is even more of a townclear now for all the stuff N3

@squiggs- at what point do you think xorxes told his team to bus him?

Honestly, I feel some kinship towards Xorxes in that I am a decent town player because I can solve, and always die as mafia because I can't lie or solve. I have told mafia teams to bus me D1 before because I knew I would die eventually. Xorxes as secretary probably didn't go as far as telling his team to bus him D1, but he probably accepted that he would die by D2/N2. So I could see bussing happening as early as N2.

[Durga]

Neph don't use your power unilaterally. I'd like to discuss the candidates with you.

Hit me with ideas currently percy vs teacon. I reckon we can kill ba now

I really dislike Percy as a choice for today. I'm actually leaning not mafia on him. Yeah. We don't really need to worry about lynching BA or not I think. We probably need to scout them out soon, I imagine they're someone we town read bc they too have to find scum. My best guess is Chippe but idk.

Agh I want to do like an in depth analysis before you use your power but I don't think I'll have the time.

What are the numbers, do we have a mislynch now?

[Durga]

Will you consider ET again?

[Squigs44]

Neph don't use your power unilaterally. I'd like to discuss the candidates with you.

Hit me with ideas currently percy vs teacon. I reckon we can kill ba now

I really dislike Percy as a choice for today. I'm actually leaning not mafia on him. Yeah. We don't really need to worry about lynching BA or not I think. We probably need to scout them out soon, I imagine they're someone we town read bc they too have to find scum. My best guess is Chippe but idk.

Agh I want to do like an in depth analysis before you use your power but I don't think I'll have the time.

What are the numbers, do we have a mislynch now?

My scum team was teacon, ND, damo, but after today... I need to reconsider.

I'll crunch the numbers in a bit, but we should be able to afford to kill BA now

[Durga]

I want to hear more from peterlund and damo.

I think I find teacon always scummy so I don't know what to do. Might be best to just lynch him.

[Durga]

Fox. Fox is probably a good bet for scum too. He's not the assassin but he's probably something

[Durga]

I think I'll start there

##vote fox

[Squigs44]

Neph I'll do analysis later today. Whats your availability like? I want you to use your powers with around 30 hours left in the day probably. Gives us time to discuss before and after

[Squigs44]

I think I'll start there

##vote fox

Rdriveras comments on Fox got me leaning more this way too. I owe Fox (and like 5 others) a reread

[ND]

If you do use the power I would recommend using it people from this bracket of players: Conner, ET, Percy, Fox, Peter, Damo, Flav

I am re-reading Conner/Peter first then I am going to move on to the rest of this list with the exception of ET as I have already re-read him and done two full reviews on him.

[Nephthys]

Neph I'll do analysis later today. Whats your availability like? I want you to use your powers with around 30 hours left in the day probably. Gives us time to discuss before and after

Horrific. I will be out most of today and then I'll likely sleep through 24hrs change so all discussion needs to be done in about 12 hrs time. Unfortunately no one is ever on then so discussing it further could be niggly. I have an exam tomorrow so will be dodge then as well.

[teacon7]

Wow, this game just got good. Once I get home from work I'll recrunch the numbers, iso Balki, and try to figure out what in the world is going on.

Durga is even more of a townclear now for all the stuff N3

@squiggs- at what point do you think xorxes told his team to bus him?

Honestly, I feel some kinship towards Xorxes in that I am a decent town player because I can solve, and always die as mafia because I can't lie or solve. I have told mafia teams to bus me D1 before because I knew I would die eventually. Xorxes as secretary probably didn't go as far as telling his team to bus him D1, but he probably accepted that he would die by D2/N2. So I could see bussing happening as early as N2.

Yeah I don't envy him the results of the reputation he has, though tbf he's earned it.

My question was meant to translate into terms of votes. When did xorx' scumteam start voting for him?

[teacon7]

@squiggs - hey also: does durga scumread me? what's your read on this?

[Durga]

This is vital. Who was roleblocked?

[Squigs44]

Neph I'll do analysis later today. Whats your availability like? I want you to use your powers with around 30 hours left in the day probably. Gives us time to discuss before and after

Horrific. I will be out most of today and then I'll likely sleep through 24hrs change so all discussion needs to be done in about 12 hrs time. Unfortunately no one is ever on then so discussing it further could be niggly. I have an exam tomorrow so will be dodge then as well.

I can stay up late if you need someone to talk to. 12 hours time?

[Squigs44]

@squiggs- at what point do you think xorxes told his team to bus him?

Honestly, I feel some kinship towards Xorxes in that I am a decent town player because I can solve, and always die as mafia because I can't lie or solve. I have told mafia teams to bus me D1 before because I knew I would die eventually. Xorxes as secretary probably didn't go as far as telling his team to bus him D1, but he probably accepted that he would die by D2/N2. So I could see bussing happening as early as N2.

Yeah I don't envy him the results of the reputation he has, though tbf he's earned it.

My question was meant to translate into terms of votes. When did xorx' scumteam start voting for him?

I would have to relook at specific votes for specific answers, but honestly I could see his team voting him anytime from out of the gate D3 to just before EoD.