Mafia 42 - Space Ghost Coast to Coast - OFFICIAL GAME THREAD

[Tom Bombadil]

Info lynch is lame because it creates a blanket excuse for everybody not to push scumreads. And even if you do keep scumhunting, tossing your vote around loses meaning if everything thinks your just going to info-lynch

[Vecna]

I still have like 22 pages of stuff to catch up on. Very little interesting to respond to in the pages I did read sadly. Try and like be more interesting.

##Vote Thamrick

Fucking hell is it too much to ask people to justify their choices?

Why do you think that Thamrick is scum?

Ive only explained this like three times before

[damo666]

Also, why is that town??

Why is what town?

Why is tham town?? (Sorry, still not used to playing on my phone)

late vote switch from flash to thdfrance would not make sense as scum

[Vecna]

Why is what town?

Why is tham town?? (Sorry, still not used to playing on my phone)

late vote switch from flash to thdfrance would not make sense as scum

This almost sounds like a scumslip knowing that THD is scum.

Or just some terrible reasoning, because scum would totally love the scrutiny for being on a vanity wagon right?

Damo is probably scum as well here

[Tom Bombadil]

Why is what town?

Why is tham town?? (Sorry, still not used to playing on my phone)

late vote switch from flash to thdfrance would not make sense as scum

I’m not following this conclusion. I’m not trying to be difficult, just trying to understand. Can you try to explain more?

[damo666]

Why is tham town?? (Sorry, still not used to playing on my phone)

late vote switch from flash to thdfrance would not make sense as scum

I’m not following this conclusion. I’m not trying to be difficult, just trying to understand. Can you try to explain more?

because if he were scum he would know ND was town so why vote for thd and risk a tie?

[damo666]

Why is tham town?? (Sorry, still not used to playing on my phone)

late vote switch from flash to thdfrance would not make sense as scum

This almost sounds like a scumslip knowing that THD is scum.

Or just some terrible reasoning, because scum would totally love the scrutiny for being on a vanity wagon right?

Damo is probably scum as well here

Then join me on the thd vote

[damo666]

I still have like 22 pages of stuff to catch up on. Very little interesting to respond to in the pages I did read sadly. Try and like be more interesting.

##Vote Thamrick

Fucking hell is it too much to ask people to justify their choices?

Why do you think that Thamrick is scum?

Ive only explained this like three times before

I can't find it

[damo666]

Info lynch is lame because it creates a blanket excuse for everybody not to push scumreads. And even if you do keep scumhunting, tossing your vote around loses meaning if everything thinks your just going to info-lynch

That's a fair point and I am not advocating we don't scumhunt but in the absence of a strong scumread I think a lynch providing a deal of info is next best (and still potentially could be scum).

If anyone has a strong scumread and a really persuasive argument to back it up I would gladly follow.

We have 114 pages but not a lot of hard data.

[Jamiet99uk]

90 of all posts so far are shitposting.

Worst game evar

[damo666]

drinking Jamie?

[Jamiet99uk]

drinking Jamie?

Not yet

[rdrivera2005]

drinking Jamie?

Not yet

Not drinking today too, not at beach anymore

I don't think Damo bad logic on town cleaning Tham is scummy, what would be a scum motivation to do this? I find the focus on info more worrying as it's usually a scum tactics to avoid real reads and it's exactly what I was pushing on Dargo.

[thdfrance]

Have done a day 1 vca and draw the following conclusions:

thamrick is town

today's best lynch by far is thdfrance because if he scumflips it provides a lot of useful info virtually townclearing 5 people and highlighting 2 others as highly dubious. If he townflips then that puts those 2 in a very different light.

So, ##vote thdfrance.

thd - in the event you are lynched and flip town I trust you will understand.

I think a CFox lynch would provide less info (and I don't think he is scum).

I would understand completely if I agreed with you...but in what way does this townclear five people? I don't understand your logic. Can you list out who you think this clears and why?

[thdfrance]

ok damo lets play this out your way

##vote thdfrance

[damo666]

Have done a day 1 vca and draw the following conclusions:

thamrick is town

today's best lynch by far is thdfrance because if he scumflips it provides a lot of useful info virtually townclearing 5 people and highlighting 2 others as highly dubious. If he townflips then that puts those 2 in a very different light.

So, ##vote thdfrance.

thd - in the event you are lynched and flip town I trust you will understand.

I think a CFox lynch would provide less info (and I don't think he is scum).

I would understand completely if I agreed with you...but in what way does this townclear five people? I don't understand your logic. Can you list out who you think this clears and why?

It wouldn't absolutely townclear, it would virtually townclear. I do not wish to name names at this stage but it should be discernible from d1 vote patterns.

[damo666]

ok damo lets play this out your way

##vote thdfrance

hmmm wasn't expecting that

[thdfrance]

Have done a day 1 vca and draw the following conclusions:

thamrick is town

today's best lynch by far is thdfrance because if he scumflips it provides a lot of useful info virtually townclearing 5 people and highlighting 2 others as highly dubious. If he townflips then that puts those 2 in a very different light.

So, ##vote thdfrance.

thd - in the event you are lynched and flip town I trust you will understand.

I think a CFox lynch would provide less info (and I don't think he is scum).

I would understand completely if I agreed with you...but in what way does this townclear five people? I don't understand your logic. Can you list out who you think this clears and why?

It wouldn't absolutely townclear, it would virtually townclear. I do not wish to name names at this stage but it should be discernible from d1 vote patterns.

so it would virtually townclear a bunch of people....but you wont share your thoughts until after the lynch goes through?? Not really thinking that this makes sense. ##unvote

[damo666]

drinking Jamie?

Not yet

Not drinking today too, not at beach anymore

I don't think Damo bad logic on town cleaning Tham is scummy, what would be a scum motivation to do this? I find the focus on info more worrying as it's usually a scum tactics to avoid real reads and it's exactly what I was pushing on Dargo.

why is it bad logic?

[damo666]

I would understand completely if I agreed with you...but in what way does this townclear five people? I don't understand your logic. Can you list out who you think this clears and why?

It wouldn't absolutely townclear, it would virtually townclear. I do not wish to name names at this stage but it should be discernible from d1 vote patterns.

so it would virtually townclear a bunch of people....but you wont share your thoughts until after the lynch goes through?? Not really thinking that this makes sense. ##unvote

that didn't last long