Mafia 42 - Space Ghost Coast to Coast - OFFICIAL GAME THREAD

[DoubtingThomas]

Brainbomb Town

[DoubtingThomas]

Brainbomb being genuinely frustrated at nongame related stuff like he is here about people refusing to work w him and town not having a town leader always comes from town

For example on mu he complains about how mu’ers treated lhf’s like shit and just mislynch them for not being skilled. He never did this as scum

As scum he doesnt care nor talk about these type of shits just tries to have fun and fool people

On top of that he is still trying to solve his tone seems pure when he is concerned w quas

He is town and we should make a towj core around him

[Tom Bombadil]

I don’t have additional thoughts than what I’ve said. I slightly townread ND. Scumlean on Moscow. Null on most of the rest. I don’t like town falling into the trap of lynching high volume posters because they have more content to critique D1 where most everyone is going in blind. It seems lazy

Most everyone is null.

True, yep. Lynch the people who talk, and you end up with a game of silent mindreading xD

Any other reasons for scumlean on Moscow (other than strange logic for voting DT? Could be just being triggerhappy with thinking/posting--but it does seem lazy or something done with little time). From the way people talk about him, he was an active player from awhile back, do you know anything regarding his style?

As for misrepresenting DT's argument, how did you interpret it?

No other reason for my feeling on Moscow. He’s only made 3 posts after all..

To expound - DT found thd suspicious because of his lack of caring about hi read. thd voted emc implying that emc was lying about being new to mafia. Then right after that the voted ghug without any follow up to his implication that emc was lying. Correct me if I am wrong, but the crux of DTs argument is that thamrick posted a question or thought, then showed no follow through on it and switched to a different vote for no reason.

Then MF comes in here and tries to characterize DTs reasoning as faulty by saying “scum being more likely to lie about being new is a pretty reasonable stance.” - which is totally not the rationale DT presented.

So either MF is trying to shade DT by misrepresenting him (scummy)
Or is not reading the thread closely (either scummy by not reading and scumhunting well, or bad town by not reading and scumbunting well

[Tom Bombadil]

Sorry - I posted thamrick instead of thd in there - my phone autocorrect is used to my mafia play when it has thamrick as an autocorrect option

[DoubtingThomas]

I don’t have additional thoughts than what I’ve said. I slightly townread ND. Scumlean on Moscow. Null on most of the rest. I don’t like town falling into the trap of lynching high volume posters because they have more content to critique D1 where most everyone is going in blind. It seems lazy

Most everyone is null.

True, yep. Lynch the people who talk, and you end up with a game of silent mindreading xD

Any other reasons for scumlean on Moscow (other than strange logic for voting DT? Could be just being triggerhappy with thinking/posting--but it does seem lazy or something done with little time). From the way people talk about him, he was an active player from awhile back, do you know anything regarding his style?

As for misrepresenting DT's argument, how did you interpret it?

No other reason for my feeling on Moscow. He’s only made 3 posts after all..

To expound - DT found thd suspicious because of his lack of caring about hi read. thd voted emc implying that emc was lying about being new to mafia. Then right after that the voted ghug without any follow up to his implication that emc was lying. Correct me if I am wrong, but the crux of DTs argument is that thamrick posted a question or thought, then showed no follow through on it and switched to a different vote for no reason.

Then MF comes in here and tries to characterize DTs reasoning as faulty by saying “scum being more likely to lie about being new is a pretty reasonable stance.” - which is totally not the rationale DT presented.

So either MF is trying to shade DT by misrepresenting him (scummy)
Or is not reading the thread closely (either scummy by not reading and scumhunting well, or bad town by not reading and scumbunting well

You are correct and this is a good post independent of that

[Tom Bombadil]

##vote MoscowFleet

[brainbomb]

Im not gonna try to understabd why yall think moscow is scum because hes not.

I havent slept tho so meh

[RagingIke297]

This is a gross amount of pages. Every time I vote someone to make them show up they show up like magic. ##vote Bozo come out and play

[Jamiet99uk]

Im not gonna try to understabd why yall think moscow is scum because hes not.

I havent slept tho so meh

You seem surprisingly certain.

[rdrivera2005]

Im not gonna try to understabd why yall think moscow is scum because hes not.

I havent slept tho so meh

I don't scumread Moscow but I still have problems understanding why you so strongly townread him.
Tom have a decent reasoning to vote him, I don't completely agree as it has an assumption everybody play logically and consistently which isn't true at all. But just dismiss the case the way you do is weird.

[Jamiet99uk]

Brainbomb: "Some people have made arguments that Moscow is scum. I am not going to engage with those arguments, I am merely going to assert that Moscow is town because I know better."

Sure.

[DoubtingThomas]

Im not gonna try to understabd why yall think moscow is scum because hes not.

I havent slept tho so meh

You seem surprisingly certain.

Wrong way to think

[peterlund]

Hmm 25 pages already. I need to sit down some hours now to skim through them all before I try to say something that may be useful...

It is a pitty Durga is not playing. I would have loved to put my first D1 vote on her.

[Jamiet99uk]

Im not gonna try to understabd why yall think moscow is scum because hes not.

I havent slept tho so meh

I don't scumread Moscow but I still have problems understanding why you so strongly townread him.
Tom have a decent reasoning to vote him, I don't completely agree as it has an assumption everybody play logically and consistently which isn't true at all. But just dismiss the case the way you do is weird.

Do you think Brainbomb would act like this if he was scum with Moscow?

##vote Moscowfleet

Ok Brain, now persuade me my vote is wrong.

[Jamiet99uk]

Im not gonna try to understabd why yall think moscow is scum because hes not.

I havent slept tho so meh

You seem surprisingly certain.

Wrong way to think

Oh?

Educate me, Thomas.

[DoubtingThomas]

You seem surprisingly certain.

Wrong way to think

Oh?

Educate me, Thomas.

Because people make "certain statements" in mafia all the time

You and I haven't played with Brainbomb starting today

We both know he makes certain statements both as town and as mafia that kinda shit is NAI for brainbomb

[DoubtingThomas]

Im not gonna try to understabd why yall think moscow is scum because hes not.

I havent slept tho so meh

I don't scumread Moscow but I still have problems understanding why you so strongly townread him.
Tom have a decent reasoning to vote him, I don't completely agree as it has an assumption everybody play logically and consistently which isn't true at all. But just dismiss the case the way you do is weird.

Do you think Brainbomb would act like this if he was scum with Moscow?

##vote Moscowfleet

Ok Brain, now persuade me my vote is wrong.

why are you voting moscow for being a team with brainbomb instead of voting brainbomb who you tried to shade in the previous two posts

[Jamiet99uk]

why are you voting moscow for being a team with brainbomb instead of voting brainbomb who you tried to shade in the previous two posts

Let's see, shall we?

Why are you so committed to defending Brainbomb?

[DoubtingThomas]

why are you voting moscow for being a team with brainbomb instead of voting brainbomb who you tried to shade in the previous two posts

Let's see, shall we?

Why are you so committed to defending Brainbomb?

I am not

why are you so committed to attacking Brainbomb?

[Jamiet99uk]

I am not

Lol. Fake News!
♤♡◇■