Mafia XL - A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum

[brainbomb]

9 hours remain Day 1!!

[damo666]

How long left in day 1?

[Foxcastle]

How long left in day 1?

##GM NOTE: 8 hours and 52 minutes, approximately.

[damo666]

Vecna - my Xorxes read based on early comment re Observer & his contribution to boxclaim discussion, in particular posts 73 & 94

[damo666]

Vecna - worcej read based on his alert to boxholder to not claim

[damo666]

Pandora’s Box is most likely in the hands of a Townie, and it offers that person a power. Let’s keep that info hidden for that reason.

Also, Town has an Observer and Mafia doesn’t. Observer is pretty darn critical, and will help us assess claims about the Box and PR claims later on.

Let’s keep PR and Box information quiet on Day 1. No fake claims. No real claims. Let’s just hunt scum.

Vecna - the above post is the basis of my Balki read

[damo666]

Vecna - re RagingIke - post 108

[rdrivera2005]

Can someone in Peters wagon summarize the reason he is the leading wagon?
Tom gave no reason, ND sheeped Tom (weird), Bozo gave a convoluted reason that involved Jamiet and Damo voted the "biggest wagon" (it could be self defense, but with 9 hours to go it's lame).

[thdfrance]

In the first pages there was some interesting interactions between Jamie, ND, and xorxes. And whether it was reaction testing or not I think that xorxes was consistently moving his vote around to be pushing buttons, but not leading any conversations. I know this is a tough ask on the first day...but I think based on what I've seen he is the best candidate for a Lynch at the moment.

Is “pushing buttons” scum-indicative or town-indicative and why?

I think it's town indicative if you're using it as a tool to get people to converse with one another. But as I said in the post xorxes posts didn't seem like that to me, it looked like he was moving his vote around AFTER others had already applied this tool in an attempt to get a wagon forming. I think that is scummy.

[thdfrance]

No real scumreads yet but gotta vote so will go with a light poster.

Of these peter is the biggest wagon so ##vote peter

I think this is scummy as all hell

[xorxes]

##vote DemonRHK

Don't like the damo wagon at all. I'm null on Peter, it's a shot in the dark, but better than damo. Demon for his vote on Yavu (i know damo did as well, but he has shown towniness after that). Still watching thd, I wish he would answer my question.

[damo666]

Can someone in Peters wagon summarize the reason he is the leading wagon?
Tom gave no reason, ND sheeped Tom (weird), Bozo gave a convoluted reason that involved Jamiet and Damo voted the "biggest wagon" (it could be self defense, but with 9 hours to go it's lame).

There is an element of self defence here obviously. I genuinely don't have a scumread on anyone to justify a vote. I admit the vote on Peter is a bit of a cop out but he needs to engage.

I could be persuaded to switch to DemonRHK if that wagon starts to roll.

[thdfrance]

I think the wagon on Peter is very interesting...not really clear on how it started or why certain people are on it but something about the formation of it feels scummy to me.

##Vote RagingIke

I had been town reading Tom up until I looked back through all the posts mentioning Peter but now I am not so sure.

[thdfrance]

Can someone in Peters wagon summarize the reason he is the leading wagon?
Tom gave no reason, ND sheeped Tom (weird), Bozo gave a convoluted reason that involved Jamiet and Damo voted the "biggest wagon" (it could be self defense, but with 9 hours to go it's lame).

There is an element of self defence here obviously. I genuinely don't have a scumread on anyone to justify a vote. I admit the vote on Peter is a bit of a cop out but he needs to engage.

I could be persuaded to switch to DemonRHK if that wagon starts to roll.

I think the 'element of self defense' thing here is scummy...and I agree with rdrivera that the way you justify being on the biggest wagon is scummy.

[Tom Bombadil]

No real scumreads yet but gotta vote so will go with a light poster.

Of these peter is the biggest wagon so ##vote peter

I think this is scummy as all hell

Why do you fee this is scummy as all hell?

[Tom Bombadil]

Also, if you find it scummy as all hell, why aren’t you voting for damo?

[thdfrance]

No real scumreads yet but gotta vote so will go with a light poster.

Of these peter is the biggest wagon so ##vote peter

I think this is scummy as all hell

Why do you fee this is scummy as all hell?

because he's sheeping a vote literally because it's the biggest wagon. I would think it a little less suspicious if he made SOME effort to give a reason for putting his vote on peter...even if it was just saying that he thought he was lurking. As I've been looking back on it this peter wagon just keeps feeling scummier and scummier

[Vecna]

Im also totally willing to lynch DrCJG

[thdfrance]

Also, if you find it scummy as all hell, why aren’t you voting for damo?

I had a bit of a scum lean on Ike based on the posts earlier in the day and I wanted to move my vote over to him...but you make a good point, perhaps I should move my vote over to damo.

I'm impressed...this is a creative way to come to the aid of your scum teammate tom

[thdfrance]

Im also totally willing to lynch DrCJG

why?