M1028: The Sweet Food Consensus - Game Thread

[brainbomb]

So the mafia guess who town chooses as a consensus vote and can alter the result.

So there is actually far less incentive than usual to announce who we scumread after d1 ends because mafia could then get a gauge on who town is majority going to vote to cop scan

[brainbomb]

Hi Jamie,
i see you reading.


You fight me every game, on prodcedural bullshit.
I said you could be lying a few times early this game and moved on.
Yet late day you kept repeating my name and blaming me for your own problems. You told me to shove it up my ass and repeatedly swore at players; spent all your energy defending yourself rather than just trying to do something useful.

Some of the things you said will probably require an apology. Especially to me as I was never disrepesctful to you at all. We have a better chance now without the pages of fighting.

What is especially irresponsible was you flooding the pages at an end of day with a bunch of fighting. You couldve ignored will and done literally anything else. Hope all is well and you are resting
Peacefully in ye olde god chat land.

[damo666]

Howdyyyyy hooo

Good morning.

Im still a little foggy on what were supposed to submit to the gm. Is it both or just one or the other?

Just one,

either

doc saves x

or

cop scans y

[brainbomb]

I kind of feel bad for jamiet and will give him credit for trying very hard to win this game, whether he is mafia or not. If he thinks will is mafia, given that will has been basically bullying jamiet all game I don't have much of a problem voting will out.
##VOTE WILL

The vote tally is inaccurate because d&w voted will so will is up to die

If you think will is town you should be aware he is actually in the lead.
Just fyi

Damn. I’m doctor.

If you think will is town you should be aware he is actually in the lead.
Just fyi

No he isn't it's a 2-2-2- tie

If Will is actually doctor people need to vote kak, jamie or d&w

Unless anyone wants a ghug waggy

I kind of feel bad for jamiet and will give him credit for trying very hard to win this game, whether he is mafia or not. If he thinks will is mafia, given that will has been basically bullying jamiet all game I don't have much of a problem voting will out.
##VOTE WILL

Jamie its not. The vote is 3-2-2

See the gms rulings

If Will is actually doctor people need to vote kak, jamie or d&w

Unless anyone wants a ghug waggy

Why did you misrepresent the totals?

Jamie its not. The vote is 3-2-2

See the gms rulings

I was only looking at the bot

Vote here was:
JustaguynamedWill (3) Jamiet99uk, worcej, Diplomacy&Warfare
Diplomacy&Warfare (2) kakarrotto, ghug
kakarrotto (2) rdrivera, brainbomb
worcej (1) damo666
Jamiet99uk (1) JustaguynamedWill

At this point, Jamie is using the bot, and so busy arguing that he doesnt even realize the GMs are going to count the vote on Will as (3), and he tells me I am wrong and argues more. Then a mad scramble happens when Will PR Claims.

Oh I see.

Let's kill Dip.

Jamiet and will are getting extremely toxic towards each other. I have no intention of continuing to play without voting one out. That will be will unless I have any particular reason other than jamiet's past aggressions to vote for them.

Jamie is not gonna die I guess.

##VOTE KAK

Time is running out.

##Vote Brainbomb

##vote Jamie

Im seeing with refreshing 2 minutes to go, Jamie is arguing with people, a PR is being voted for. Ghug is calling for D&W wagon to take off. I want kak or ghug and then I see jamie now trying to get a wagon going on me, and worcej joining the Jamie train.

I see D&W advocating jamie dies because of his toxicity.

and I agreed. I thought Jamie was mafia at the end there for how much filth he was spamming into the game, causing confusion and chaos.

[brainbomb]

Good morning.

Im still a little foggy on what were supposed to submit to the gm. Is it both or just one or the other?

Just one,

either

doc saves x

or

cop scans y

got it. Okay, ive submitted mine. the first one I sent in had both lol.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

well M1028 has not been my best game lol. I haven’t been in the right headspace but that’s no excuse. I guess this is my good-game hangover

Sorry Jamie

Well I wont be on until like 230 so I’ll post my solutions around then

[rdrivera2005]

Just passing to say I submitted my order and that I don't see any reason to comment on game state at night.

[damo666]

Just passing to say I submitted my order and that I don't see any reason to comment on game state at night.

So have I

Players who claim to have submitted night votes

brain
rdrivera
damo

[ghug]

As mafia can screw with doc save Will is doomed and we should vote for who cop scans.

If we decide who cop will scan then mafia can either kill them while blocking the doc sabe or fake the copscan.

I'm not saying make your vote public. I'm saying no point wasting vote on a doc save. Vote for who cop scans.

Will should still vote for a docsave to force mafia to deal with him, though.

[ghug]

Just passing to say I submitted my order and that I don't see any reason to comment on game state at night.

So have I

Players who claim to have submitted night votes

brain
rdrivera
damo

I did too.

[Diplomacy&Warfare]

Time to analyze rdr!
They were gone at the start, apparently not knowing the game started. Once they (mostly) caught up, they said jamiet was acting weird and townread brain and will. They complemented brain for being helpful and voted kak for not being helpful. They basically ignored most of the jamiet being toxic saga. Near the end of D1 they said they could vote me or ghug but neither would cause a tie, which makes me think they wanted a tie. They haven't posted N1.
Rdr overall appears to be intentionally not commenting on jamiet's arguments with will and brain, but supported brain a little bit. This seems like the play of a deep-threat with brain as a misdirector.
If rdr is mafia, brain is the most likely partner. If rdr is town, brain is probably also town. Unfortunately, I don't have any particular evidence that rdr is town or mafia.


I have submitted my night PR action vote.

[worcej]

Team solve: worcej damo

Worcej knows I am almost always #1 poster. This seems like an attempt to get me MKed and then have a reason for doing so.

Do I know you always are #1 poster? I know you're actually not always #1.

Last game:

• You barely beat BB on D1 last game (literally by only 1 post)
• You lost D2 to food
• You lost D3 to Bunny
• You lost D4 to Bunny
• You lost D5 to food
• You won D6
• You won D7

Why are you a loser?

Ooof... good question...

[Diplomacy&Warfare]

Time to analyze worcej!
The game started without worcej knowing. Later in D1, worcej started spouting theories about why jamiet self-hammered. They voted will and disagreed with will over will disagreeing with them, which feels like WIFOM to me (But you must have known I would not agree with your logic, which is why I cannot choose the wine in front of me). They proceeded to argue with will, tell jamiet to "breathe" after jamiet's rant about will doing psychological warfare, and then voted jamiet with two seconds left in D1.
I would say worcej was a bit quick to vote will, but I really don't agree with anybody's reasons to vote during D1. I don't want to start an argument about this, but D1 was chaotic and I don't understand why people took everything so seriously. I nearly got voted out for starting the day with a joke. Kak nearly got voted out for making a bad post at some point. Jamiet got voted out for arguing with will. Will nearly got voted out for arguing with jamiet. In N1 worcej revealed their strategy: vote for whoever posts the most. This seems mildly scummy as it encourages not posting and therefore not looking for evidence, which may influence the way people play D2. There's not enough evidence here by far to vote worcej out, but their playstyle is not helpful to the group.

[damo666]

Players who claim to have submitted night votes

brain
rdrivera
damo
ghug
dip

So, with Will as doc it's worcej and Kak. Game solved.

[brainbomb]

Players who claim to have submitted night votes

brain
rdrivera
damo
ghug
dip

So, with Will as doc it's worcej and Kak. Game solved.

Might be the best take youve ever had.

[ghug]

Time to analyze rdr!
They were gone at the start, apparently not knowing the game started. Once they (mostly) caught up, they said jamiet was acting weird and townread brain and will. They complemented brain for being helpful and voted kak for not being helpful. They basically ignored most of the jamiet being toxic saga. Near the end of D1 they said they could vote me or ghug but neither would cause a tie, which makes me think they wanted a tie. They haven't posted N1.
Rdr overall appears to be intentionally not commenting on jamiet's arguments with will and brain, but supported brain a little bit. This seems like the play of a deep-threat with brain as a misdirector.
If rdr is mafia, brain is the most likely partner. If rdr is town, brain is probably also town. Unfortunately, I don't have any particular evidence that rdr is town or mafia.


I have submitted my night PR action vote.

What's leading you to the rd/brain connection?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Players who claim to have submitted night votes

brain
rdrivera
damo
ghug
dip

So, with Will as doc it's worcej and Kak. Game solved.

I did

[Diplomacy&Warfare]

Time to analyze rdr!
They were gone at the start, apparently not knowing the game started. Once they (mostly) caught up, they said jamiet was acting weird and townread brain and will. They complemented brain for being helpful and voted kak for not being helpful. They basically ignored most of the jamiet being toxic saga. Near the end of D1 they said they could vote me or ghug but neither would cause a tie, which makes me think they wanted a tie. They haven't posted N1.
Rdr overall appears to be intentionally not commenting on jamiet's arguments with will and brain, but supported brain a little bit. This seems like the play of a deep-threat with brain as a misdirector.
If rdr is mafia, brain is the most likely partner. If rdr is town, brain is probably also town. Unfortunately, I don't have any particular evidence that rdr is town or mafia.


I have submitted my night PR action vote.

What's leading you to the rd/brain connection?

Rdr townread brain, complemented brain on being overly helpful, then didn't support brain afterwards. There's no explanation for this, and I see it as a potential move to get brain enough credit to vote out jamiet without associating rdr too much with brain.
Also, will helped.
Rdr has posted, apparently before my analysis, although I did not see that post. The statement that they "don't see any reason to comment on game state" could be interpreted as scummy, but I think it's just rdr being relaxed, trying to calm everyone down after chaotic D1.

[brainbomb]

D&W is clearly town. They actually have reasoning and theories about the game.

[brainbomb]

Id be very shocked if the mafia was anyone other than ghug/kak this game.