M1028: The Sweet Food Consensus - Game Thread

[rdrivera2005]

@RD when you come around to reading the thread, I'd like your input about the jamie situation, and who do you currently think is the most likely mafia, please.

I think Jamie original post isn't scummy but his reaction is weird.


I think Will is town and probably also Brain.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

@RD when you come around to reading the thread, I'd like your input about the jamie situation, and who do you currently think is the most likely mafia, please.

I think Jamie original post isn't scummy but his reaction is weird.


I think Will is town and probably also Brain.

Thats nice.

Anything else?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

James Dean for President

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

James Dean for President

I like Monument Mythos. Good show

[worcej]

How did you guys already break Jamie?

[damo666]

I don’t know. ‘Yes’ seems like a weird answer to ‘this or that’

It was obvious ghug shorthand for Yes and Yes or Yes. Yes.

Too many daft lines of enquiry methinks.

I can speak ghug

I didn’t think it was that obvious lol

[damo666]

Bloody phone

[damo666]

How did you guys already break Jamie?

The beer's stronger down here.

[Jamiet99uk]

##Unvote
##Unend

Anyone who thinks I am scum:

1. Provide evidence of a scum-motivated thing I have done.

2. Explain clearly what my scum motivation was for doing it.

[Jamiet99uk]

Why would you lie about this? It’s so inconsequential…

I wonder if it's possible that I'm not lying and you just didn't understand me.

I don’t know. ‘Yes’ seems like a weird answer to ‘this or that’

The normal definition of a "lie": "An intentionally false statement."

JustWill's definition of a lie: "Anything Will disagrees with or does not understand."

[Jamiet99uk]

So, as far as I can tell, Jamiet said there were 7 people, brain said no, there's 9, and Jamiet concluded that brain is scum.

Where did I say Brain was scum?

Point to the post.

Quote it.

I did not say that.

Fucking fool. Try reading.

Behold:

1. Jamiet99uk
2. JustAGuyNamedWill
3. ghug
4. worcej
5. Diplomacy&Warfare
6. Rdrivera2005
7. Damo666
8. brainbomb
9. Kakarroto

Oh, I meant on my team.

You're implying brain is not on your team.
You have disagreed with me, brain, and will. We are obviously not all mafia. It could be that two of us are mafia and the other one is simply a town who got this wrong, but brain and will are smart enough and overanalyze enough that neither of them is likely to have been fooled completely, definitely not both, and while it's valid that I could have been fooled by mafias brain and will, that option requires two of the three biggest posters conveniently being mafia.
I offer three explanations someone who is not me, you, brain, or will might come to in this situation:
A: Brain and Will are mafia, while you are town. I am an idiot who has no idea what I'm doing and am suspicious of you for no good reason. As discussed above, this is extremely convenient for you to claim and also very ludicrous for anyone to believe. Also,

I have vague townreads on brain and Will, but that's about it right now.

B: You are Mafia. At the start of the game, you tried to immediately implicate me to hopefully get a votekill on a town in the first day. Brain and will got suspicious of you, and your defensive attitude is a result of being concerned we will votekill you.
C: You are a town who was suspicious of me for a frankly bad reason and then got defensive because brain and will were being aggressive. Yes, you were being defensive. Yes, brain and will were being aggressive. Meanwhile, two quiet players like rdr are watching us argue over misunderstandings.

You (for viewers, this is addressed to jamiet), will, brain and I should probably consider the possibility it is C. We may have spent the last ten pages arguing over a misunderstanding. Having said that, you have been really unhelpful this game and with a good chance you are mafia, I still think we should vote you out.
(For reference I voted for jamiet)
##END

This is better work and I appreciate you putting in effort. You are however jumping to conclusions.

I did not imply that Brainbomb was not on my team.

Your option C is the closest to the right answer.

[Jamiet99uk]

I don’t know. ‘Yes’ seems like a weird answer to ‘this or that’

It was obvious ghug shorthand for Yes and Yes or Yes. Yes.

Too many daft lines of enquiry methinks.

I didn’t think it was that obvious hahahahahahahahaha.

It was obvious to me.

[Jamiet99uk]

We are not hammering Jamie you daft punks.

Thanks Ghug, I hope you are not buddying me. But thanks.

[Jamiet99uk]

Scum ghug and scum damo had already predetermined jamie was not the free daykill they wanted today.

Darn

Interesting you said this when your vote was still on me.

[Jamiet99uk]

He told me to shove it up my ass. So here we are. Gerbil town

ARMAGEDDON!

[Jamiet99uk]

I assume he is scum and is still watching discreetely what is happening anyway. You can always log off and still view the game.

It's four AM there.

Hes on vacation in London probably having an orgy or whatever they do to unwind for a weekend.

I am not on vacation, I am here for work. I went out for the evening with Jasmine. No other participants were invited.

[Jamiet99uk]

It's four AM there.

Hes on vacation in London probably having an orgy or whatever they do to unwind for a weekend.

If he's secretly reading webDip, it's not a very good orgy.

I would have checked my phone, but there was oil all over my hands.

[Jamiet99uk]

##Unend
##Unvote

Okay but really hammering would make rdrivera annoyed based on how hes reacted in the past. And it also hurts worcej chance to be part of the first day.

So ill table my bloodlust for now

My impressions of everyone so far:
jamiet: aggressive, possibly mafia. Hates me.
Will: townlean, very actively posting
ghug: posts somewhat often but hasn't actually contributed much.
worcej: On a business trip
Dip&War: Has unpopular opinions about burger
rdr: Slow reader
damo: Similar to ghug, posting often but not contributing much
brain: similar to Will, townlean and posting actively
Kak: Relaxed, posts more jokingly and less seriously. Did vote though.
Ghug and damo have been playing very similarly, so if jamiet's not mafia it might be them. Nobody except brain, will, jamiet and me(?) has done much investigating.
Thoughts on any of this except my opinions on burgers?

I do not hate you. I don't even know who you are. Don't be so self-obsessed.

Active posting from Will is not a towntell. He actively posted in his recent, very high-performance, scum game.

[Jamiet99uk]

James Dean for President

I like Monument Mythos. Good show. You're strong and smart, William... Everybody likes you.

Why, thank you, Polly Prissy Pants. How nice of you.

Why are you talking to yourself?

[Jamiet99uk]

How did you guys already break Jamie?

I used the number 7 instead of the number 9 when making reference to the number of players.

This was clearly a devious scum plot to get Will and Brainbomb daykilled, but those meddling kids saw through my evil scheme.