MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

None of the wagons I've led have fucking flipped I'm cheesed as hell

Yes I see you didn't lead any mislynch wagons but you scumread them. You scumread ghug and me.

I didn't scumread ghug................. Please stop just talking nonsense

[worcej]

We *have* to go after the person who had armor lost - that is the most logical direction.

It has the lowest pool of failure and highest chance of success. Going after Durga, who we believe is scum with a cannon, is less guaranteed than the armor loser to rdr.

[Durga]

I just can't for the life of me figure out why yav would ever claim armour all game when he had fucking electroshield. None of it makes any sense

[Durga]

We *have* to go after the person who had armor lost - that is the most logical direction.

It has the lowest pool of failure and highest chance of success. Going after Durga, who we believe is scum with a cannon, is less guaranteed than the armor loser to rdr.

So **you** also think that Squigs had the second armour? I'm trying to figure out a reason that would incentivize Squigs to hide that second armour when both cannons were used up but I can't figure it out at all.

[yavuzovic]

Durga is much better scum candidate than Vecna y2k. I will stay on her.

You further strengthen my scumread of you + Vecna. But you're much more likely than him so you go first

Hahahha, so mafia has two armours? That's not logical

[worcej]

We *have* to go after the person who had armor lost - that is the most logical direction.

It has the lowest pool of failure and highest chance of success. Going after Durga, who we believe is scum with a cannon, is less guaranteed than the armor loser to rdr.

So **you** also think that Squigs had the second armour? I'm trying to figure out a reason that would incentivize Squigs to hide that second armour when both cannons were used up but I can't figure it out at all.

Because saying an item, such as the hammer - that MF may have had - and keeping the armor in play can create doubt amongst everyone.

[worcej]

Hahahha, so mafia has two armours? That's not logical

It is possible though Yav, just saying.

[y2kjbk]

yav, i actually do think scum had two armor in squigs and vecna.

[worcej]

@Durga - a better thing to think on is why the fuck would scum squigs be honest about his item to the town? That is the worst move he could possibly make. I don't believe ANYTHING about Squig's claim.

What I really wish, and I can't seem to find it easily on peterbot, is when did rdr get the armor?

[flash2015]

I just can't for the life of me figure out why yav would ever claim armour all game when he had fucking electroshield. None of it makes any sense

This is the question, isn't it? Even though I scumread Vecna, his theory makes sense. It explains Yav's behaviour. But it does mean his only possible partner can be ND (i.e. ND stole the electroshield from Xorxes with the repaired thief kit).

[Durga]

@Durga - a better thing to think on is why the fuck would scum squigs be honest about his item to the town? That is the worst move he could possibly make. I don't believe ANYTHING about Squig's claim.

What I really wish, and I can't seem to find it easily on peterbot, is when did rdr get the armor?

the night before the day we all claimed and yav went back on his claim AFTER rdr got the armour.

also, I find it hard to believe scum had 2 armours, but the only armour that can be town is Vecna. so if you think scum don't have two armours, then vecna is not scum

[y2kjbk]

I was roleblocked.

I don't have an armour by the way. I won't claim unless someone asks me for it to keep it secret and I claimed armour to avoid mafia's attack at night. If they killed me, it would lead RHK to die too. After 5 pages he claimed lovely heart, I claimed this armour. It was fake, I say lol. Maybe I should continue this armour claim for one more night but if this is a mass claim you better know armour owner has died - as nobody counterclaimed me.
HEYY, ARMOUR OWNER, IF YOU DIDN'T COUNTERCLAIM ME, YOU CAN DO IT NOW.

So, Yav is scum. He didn't have an Armour because he lost it this night when he roleblocked me. I was Sticky and I have an Armour now. So, we can just lynch Yav now and then try to find the last scum.

##vote Yav

##end

[flash2015]

@Durga - a better thing to think on is why the fuck would scum squigs be honest about his item to the town? That is the worst move he could possibly make. I don't believe ANYTHING about Squig's claim.

What I really wish, and I can't seem to find it easily on peterbot, is when did rdr get the armor?

He said he was roleblocked on D3 so N2.

[y2kjbk]

rdrivera's problem was that he preempted Vecna having to say anything

[worcej]

rdrivera's problem was that he preempted Vecna having to say anything

Which is part of why I think Vecna's very late claim was horseshit. It allowed him to create a story.

I am avoiding Yav entirely because if he's town and demon is town, we're at 3-2 after kills and it comes down to mylo and it can be even worse if they have the head still, which I believe they do.

Someone is lying about their items - that pool is, to me, only between yav/nd/vecna. Based on this, and the yav situation above, I am stuck on ND/Vecna and thus ultimately Vecna.

I will not move my vote to yav. Voting yav now, if you're town, is retarded because you're almost forfeiting the game.

[worcej]

Town - we missed our yav chance a day ago when you fucks killed rdr.

[Durga]

rdrivera's problem was that he preempted Vecna having to say anything

Which is part of why I think Vecna's very late claim was horseshit. It allowed him to create a story.

I am avoiding Yav entirely because if he's town and demon is town, we're at 3-2 after kills and it comes down to mylo and it can be even worse if they have the head still, which I believe they do.

Someone is lying about their items - that pool is, to me, only between yav/nd/vecna. Based on this, and the yav situation above, I am stuck on ND/Vecna and thus ultimately Vecna.

I will not move my vote to yav. Voting yav now, if you're town, is retarded because you're almost forfeiting the game.

that's ridiculous, he's unlynchable after today, whereas vecna will still be lynchable. if you're not voting for yav you're crazy

[flash2015]

rdrivera's problem was that he preempted Vecna having to say anything

So what do you believe happened with Yav? You believe he really had electroshield all along?

[worcej]

that's ridiculous, he's unlynchable after today, whereas vecna will still be lynchable. if you're not voting for yav you're crazy

Totally not true - if we hit the other scum in the small pool I named, we can still lynch him.

Do better math Durga and stop sounding like I need to vote for you and not Vecna for an ez scum hit.

[flash2015]

rdrivera's problem was that he preempted Vecna having to say anything

Which is part of why I think Vecna's very late claim was horseshit. It allowed him to create a story.

I am avoiding Yav entirely because if he's town and demon is town, we're at 3-2 after kills and it comes down to mylo and it can be even worse if they have the head still, which I believe they do.

Someone is lying about their items - that pool is, to me, only between yav/nd/vecna. Based on this, and the yav situation above, I am stuck on ND/Vecna and thus ultimately Vecna.

I will not move my vote to yav. Voting yav now, if you're town, is retarded because you're almost forfeiting the game.

You aren't forfeiting the game if he really is scum.