MAFIA XXXVIII: INFINITY WAR

[ChippeRock]

ike stop engaging the players
do it on the god qt when people start dying

##vote xorxes

Why is snowy voting his biggest supporter? Seems scummy in an attempt to appear town.

[ghug]

ike stop engaging the players
do it on the god qt when people start dying

##vote xorxes

I'm gently encouraging people to follow the rules. Would you like me to be more straightforward from now on?

Honestly yes, though it's more the posts like the one where you joked with darg about his grandkid. It's hard to force yourself to be boring as GM, but it's worth doing.

[ChippeRock]

ike stop engaging the players
do it on the god qt when people start dying

##vote xorxes

I'm gently encouraging people to follow the rules. Would you like me to be more straightforward from now on?

Honestly yes, though it's more the posts like the one where you joked with darg about his grandkid. It's hard to force yourself to be boring as GM, but it's worth doing.

Agreed, I want a boring old GM who I can get pissed off at!

[RagingIke297]

ike stop engaging the players
do it on the god qt when people start dying

##vote xorxes

I'm gently encouraging people to follow the rules. Would you like me to be more straightforward from now on?

Honestly yes, though it's more the posts like the one where you joked with darg about his grandkid. It's hard to force yourself to be boring as GM, but it's worth doing.

Noted

[ChippeRock]

I betcha several of the people on the snowy wagon are scum and will switch from snowy to someone else last minute... Snowy would be scum in that scenario as well.

[ghug]

I betcha several of the people on the snowy wagon are scum and will switch from snowy to someone else last minute... Snowy would be scum in that scenario as well.

So let's talk through this. If you were scum, would you do this? Without coordination on the first day? If so, why? If not, why do you expect others to?

[DoubtingThomas]

I betcha several of the people on the snowy wagon are scum and will switch from snowy to someone else last minute... Snowy would be scum in that scenario as well.

So let's talk through this. If you were scum, would you do this? Without coordination on the first day? If so, why? If not, why do you expect others to?

good points, ghug. very townie questions.

as for chippe, kinda absurd comment and assumption that really came out of nowhere. scum equity level increased to +2

[ghug]

Thomas, you seem like you've played elsewhere. Where?

[Squigs44]

good points, ghug. very townie questions.

Don't let him fool you. He's very good at asking questions regardless of alignment. I do remember him being much more abrasive when he doesn't like comments like the one Chippe made though.

You going soft ghug?

[ghug]

I have a very strong feeling Chippe's town, new obvtownies tend to survive far longer than I do, and I'd like someone to be useful when I'm gone.

[Squigs44]

Bo's case on Yav seems a little reachy. Although most cases D1 are reachy. His just seems overly complicated. Like he sat down and thought, how can I spin this one interaction into a scum read? Maybe I'm just too dense to follow all of his logic.

[DoubtingThomas]

Thomas, you seem like you've played elsewhere. Where?

M37 was my first game, but I tried other sites and have couple games in now/in couple at the moment

[ChippeRock]

Well I think snowy might possibly be trying to alert the others he's scum without alerting the townies...

Perhaps voting xorxes does this?

[ChippeRock]

I betcha several of the people on the snowy wagon are scum and will switch from snowy to someone else last minute... Snowy would be scum in that scenario as well.

So let's talk through this. If you were scum, would you do this? Without coordination on the first day? If so, why? If not, why do you expect others to?

good points, ghug. very townie questions.

as for chippe, kinda absurd comment and assumption that really came out of nowhere. scum equity level increased to +2

Came out of nowhere? There was a sudden snowy wagon and than snowy votes with no explanation for his biggest supporter...

[ChippeRock]

So let's talk through this. If you were scum, would you do this? Without coordination on the first day? If so, why? If not, why do you expect others to?

good points, ghug. very townie questions.

as for chippe, kinda absurd comment and assumption that really came out of nowhere. scum equity level increased to +2

Seems a little bit scummy to try making others appear scum...

[Squigs44]

Well I think snowy might possibly be trying to alert the others he's scum without alerting the townies...

Perhaps voting xorxes does this?

So many townslips from this one.

@chip - mafia already knows who the other mafia are

[DoubtingThomas]

So let's talk through this. If you were scum, would you do this? Without coordination on the first day? If so, why? If not, why do you expect others to?

good points, ghug. very townie questions.

as for chippe, kinda absurd comment and assumption that really came out of nowhere. scum equity level increased to +2

Seems a little bit scummy to try making others appear scum...

Hm this one really sounds townie.. if its chippe’s first game.. i feel like it will be really hard for him to be so townie like this

[DoubtingThomas]

And with that “town slip” i see why ghug thinks chippe is townie in particular

Altho i guess the town slip is a really simple one so it could be manpulated? Hm

[ChippeRock]

Well I think snowy might possibly be trying to alert the others he's scum without alerting the townies...

Perhaps voting xorxes does this?

So many townslips from this one.

@chip - mafia already knows who the other mafia are

Really? I heard they only know who's who for the Night Kill of Day 1 and the first lynch is a blind lynch for the Mafia.

[ChippeRock]

Well I think snowy might possibly be trying to alert the others he's scum without alerting the townies...

Perhaps voting xorxes does this?

So many townslips from this one.

@chip - mafia already knows who the other mafia are

Really? I heard they only know who's who for the Night Kill of Day 1 and the first lynch is a blind lynch for the Mafia.

##CALL GM

Is what Squigs is saying true?

[quote=ChippeRock post_id=28117 time=<a href="tel:1533694581">1533694581</a> user_id=108]
Well I think snowy might possibly be trying to alert the others he's scum without alerting the townies...

Perhaps voting xorxes does this?

So many townslips from this one.

@chip - mafia already knows who the other mafia are
[/quote]

I'm confused, how is any of what I said a townslip?