M62: PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF REVOLUTIONARY MAFIA GAME THREAD!

[worcej]

Other impressions:

Worcej usually posts what I was thinking. But this time he's posting a lot of sh*t. It's much more annoying than he usually is, but maybe he was bored holding his tongue last game as GM.

ND is annoying, but nothing he's done suggests to me that he knows what's going on.

kgray is not her normal self. I don't know what to make of that. The problem with D1s in general, and ESPECIALLY a D1 during the holiday. She's normally active, pushing, responding (both as scum and as town). So I guess it is holiday?

Aarodactyl is roughly what I'd expect him to do either as town or scum. I expect he'll be pretty decent at this game if he commits to it. I have no read on him though.

Yoyo has not surprised me yet, I still expect the slot to change hands.

ghug seems a little off to me. I don't recall him ever making votes just because someone he didn't scumread annoyed him.

Flum seems like town Flum.

Durga seems like town Durga.

Vecna seems like town Vecna.

you (CELAPH) are town.

bozo isn't normal bozo yet. I'm waiting for him to clown it up.

what are scum flum and scum durga like?

I have a scum durga tell which for obvious reasons I will not disclose, however she has not yet portrayed it, if she is does I will scream out loud her scumitudiness.

Has flum ever been scum?

I am curious if our tells are the same or not. It’ll be interesting to see if it shows up or not.

[Vecna]

Any of his long post there.

I see it as a left turn from how he had been playing. It seems eerily like trying to fit the mould of what hes known for as opposed to just being obnoxious because hes mad

I'm not the right person to ask on ND's merit.

did anything in his long post move the dial for you to scummier or townier?

It actually moved it towards scummier side for me sadly. ND knows very well his wagon wont be a "goldmine of information". Not any more than any normal wagon on D1. There being pissed off town votes on it actually strongly reduces the information. He truely doesnt care about the pressure Vash thing just because he skated to the endgame by lurking once upon a blue moon (we've all done that).

Also he blatantly kicked against the logic of it being a gambit to attract kills, saying he plays like this every game. Which is blatantly false, because all his games use different shades of playstyles. He has had plenty of games where he barely insults anyone, but just makes snide comments to show people his displeasure. This playstyle was done intentionally, and the mark is moving more towards scum wifom for me.

And before anyone asks: ND is a way more competent scum player than you guys currently imagine if he puts his mind to it. He is easily on Kgray's level.

[worcej]

Everyone and their mother has a secret scum Durga tell they won't reveal.

I mean, he should know - he has been scum with you enough.

[Vecna]

I'm not the right person to ask on ND's merit.

did anything in his long post move the dial for you to scummier or townier?

Uh, I mean I can see that post as a fuck I need to change my outlook or I'm gonna get day killed but really I'm voting him because he was hell bent on creating an incredibly toxic environment and that's not good for town in any circumstance. Whether he's actually scum... Dunno, he's a null. He can do this garbage as town or scum. Usually he's really easy to catch as scum tho

I feel youre having recently (recency? recensy? cmon fucking spelling checker, do your damn job) bias.

[Durga]

did anything in his long post move the dial for you to scummier or townier?

Uh, I mean I can see that post as a fuck I need to change my outlook or I'm gonna get day killed but really I'm voting him because he was hell bent on creating an incredibly toxic environment and that's not good for town in any circumstance. Whether he's actually scum... Dunno, he's a null. He can do this garbage as town or scum. Usually he's really easy to catch as scum tho

I feel youre having recently (recency? recensy? cmon fucking spelling checker, do your damn job) bias.

In what way?

[bozotheclown]

What do you think of my Jamie theory? reasonable, or too nitpicky rabbit hole?

I konw you were not asking me, but I think your theory is worth considering.

Also, no one listened to me last game when I said Durga was more likely to sub out D1 as scum, and I think that is probably true of bo_sox as well.

##VOTE Jamiet99uk

[Vecna]

Has anything of substance happened yet that I should read?

Town points for Fluminator for this reentrance.

Id have hoped that people learned that when Flum tries to pull the too cool for school card in a certain way it really is not town indicative

[Vecna]

I like this point.

@Hamilton Brian — what exactly did you do with the half of your day that you describe here? Plug things into Google Translate? Print out Bozo’s post and drive it over to the local cryptography club meeting?

We’re you exaggerating in your post? Why?

For someone taking most arguments quite literal, I wouldve thought you might have deconstructed this comment as hard as Kgray's argument - and concluded that that post was made on page 6.

Most reactions to it were done quite a bit earlier than the timemark of 63 pages.

What? The response was page 50

Did you read how HB interacted with it on page 7 for like one post and then moved on?

Just curious. Because I thought it was an obvious joke, and your post was really meh. But apparently it sparked interest.

[damo666]

The set up doesn't say how many scum there are. Is it 5?

Well you are either scum or incredibly lazy town.

Either way ##vote Durga

[bozotheclown]

Has anything of substance happened yet that I should read?

Town points for Fluminator for this reentrance.

Id have hoped that people learned that when Flum tries to pull the too cool for school card in a certain way it really is not town indicative

Where did you learn this?

[ND]

Nothing. I was commenting on ND.

Even better. People defending ND are likely scum motivated. Who doesn't want a person who triggers half the game and might be an easy miskill around (if ND is town)

Why is defending ND scum motivated? Is your preference that we just miskill him now?

FWIW - I think ND is town and therefor a bad kill on D1 over any resident lurker or non-contributor.

She has a strong personal dislike for me because I call her out on being intellectually dishonest and lazy and also for not reading the game. She can't get over that to see the game objectively. And then will be toxic for me for mentioning anything negative about her. It's whatever. She is pathetic.

[Vecna]

This long post by ND is an example of confirmation bias, versus natural adjustment

If its confirmation bias, then I am guilty of assuming ND has changed his attitude because he is scum.

if hes just changing because he realized hes been an ass and is gonna get murked for it, then its possible hes townie

If you really think that, why did you talk about him feeling disenfranchised when you voted for him? It looks like you're trying to provoke him.

Small slither of a teacon-town-talk?

[damo666]

The set up doesn't say how many scum there are. Is it 5?

7 scum would be 26%
it might be 6 or 7

Not you as well.

For Pete's sake.

[ND]

I'm not the right person to ask on ND's merit.

did anything in his long post move the dial for you to scummier or townier?

It actually moved it towards scummier side for me sadly. ND knows very well his wagon wont be a "goldmine of information". Not any more than any normal wagon on D1. There being pissed off town votes on it actually strongly reduces the information. He truely doesnt care about the pressure Vash thing just because he skated to the endgame by lurking once upon a blue moon (we've all done that).

Also he blatantly kicked against the logic of it being a gambit to attract kills, saying he plays like this every game. Which is blatantly false, because all his games use different shades of playstyles. He has had plenty of games where he barely insults anyone, but just makes snide comments to show people his displeasure. This playstyle was done intentionally, and the mark is moving more towards scum wifom for me.

And before anyone asks: ND is a way more competent scum player than you guys currently imagine if he puts his mind to it. He is easily on Kgray's level.

I would challenge you to re-read my post as i clearly said the last few games I played I did so in a provocative way. But, your opinion is your opinion.

[worcej]

The list I quoted in my post immediately before that one.

Another annoying response requiring me to have to go verify the information...

Stop being a damo please!

Oh I am so sorry that I make it necessary for you to read the game.

Re-read. I am also not as good as some others at going back and looking at info via my cell phone...

Are we at 2/30 now?

[damo666]

The set up doesn't say how many scum there are. Is it 5?

7 scum would be 26%
it might be 6 or 7

##call gm: how many scum are there

Try reading the set up or refer to your scumchat.

[worcej]

That was post #2, just for whiny Worcej.

[worcej]

7 scum would be 26%
it might be 6 or 7

##call gm: how many scum are there

Try reading the set up or refer to your scumchat.

Oh ohogogoohigogogjsvshdv

Did you see it or something?

[Vecna]

Scum neph thinking he could get ghug killed? Doesnt sound like thats in nephs wheelhouse of bravery

Back when neph was still active that was pretty much how every single game went

Agreed - memory serves me correctly that he tries to be a ‘lead investigator’ as scum

I did not mean that (at all, because I dont think thats accurate). I meant that ghug just died every game back then.

[Balki Bartokomous]

The set up doesn't say how many scum there are. Is it 5?

Well you are either scum or incredibly lazy town.

Either way ##vote Durga

Do you really think that not knowing the number of scum on Day 1 in a game this size means you are “incredibly lazy town,” if town?

I am town. I did not recall how many scum there were or whether the opening post mentioned how many scum there were. How about you?