M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[Donny Dude]

Yeah, but a lot of my theory went out the window when I found that he did question summit D1. There's still some suspicion there though.

I didn't see anywhere that Tom scumreads bozo. The only time Tom gave a read of bozo was D1 where he was his strongest townread. This just seemed so random.

Tom, What made you start to suspect bozo as scum?

Are you encouraging scum reads of me because I scum read you?

No, I want to see how Tom progressed to a scum read on you because Kgray's post shows Tom mentioned you as a tr d1.

[Durga]

Worcej

What has worcej done differently that makes you question your read? Weren't you scumreading him because he wasn't ruffling feathers or yelling at you? He still hasn't done either of those things.

About the 3rd game in recent memory where I am trying to not be a dick sometimes and I get scummed.

Pick which worcej you want: dick/asshole or kinda nice but still blunt.

No, this is nice. This is an improvement. Even if this is just your scum meta, be like this forever

[Durga]

##vote flash

[worcej]

[snip]
If you want a case that covers all days, here is one for you: D1 you avoided voting for summit until he was ahead by 3 votes 7 minutes before EOD, you actively discouraged people for voting for summit during D1, yet after D1 you claimed you were indicating all D1 that you would vote for summit eventually. D2 you started voting for TrPrado, saying in the same post that you were OK with seth as well, yet at EOD when the wagons were BunnyGo vs. seth, you voted for BunnyGo instead of seth. D3 you voted for BunnyGo at the beginning of the day, even though you switched from BunnyGo to TrPrado at the end of D2, and nothing had changed with BunnyGo's claim yet. D4 you had your vote on damo at the 24 hour mark, and are now using damo as an example of why we should not be looking at suspicious activity from D1.

Man, this amount of analysis is too good to ignore. I am sheeping bozo on this one. This is town bozo through and through.

##vote Vecna

[worcej]

This is pretty much my poe pool for scum now. I townread pretty much everyone else, or have reasons to be ok with them.

Pretty big suspicion:
Durga
Hellenic Riot
damo666
flash2015

Maniac
Nanook

seth24c
(worcej)
Low'ish suspicion

feeling pretty good about these reads.

FWIW, this list was the first thing that made me question my thoughts on Vecna - I didn't understand how I suddenly fell at the bottom of his suspicion level rather quickly.

[kgray]

Worcej

What has worcej done differently that makes you question your read? Weren't you scumreading him because he wasn't ruffling feathers or yelling at you? He still hasn't done either of those things.

About the 3rd game in recent memory where I am trying to not be a dick sometimes and I get scummed.

Pick which worcej you want: dick/asshole or kinda nice but still blunt.

I'm not scumreading you, I wanted to know why Durga's read changed when you hadn't done anything different since she stated her read.

And kinda nice but still blunt please

[kgray]

Yeah, but a lot of my theory went out the window when I found that he did question summit D1. There's still some suspicion there though.

I didn't see anywhere that Tom scumreads bozo. The only time Tom gave a read of bozo was D1 where he was his strongest townread. This just seemed so random.

Tom, What made you start to suspect bozo as scum?

Are you encouraging scum reads of me because I scum read you?

I think it's a little defensive to interpret this as Donny encouraging a scumread of you.

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT 4.1.4

flash2015 (4) - Donny Dude, Fluminator, Vecna, Durga
Vecna (4) - ghug, kgray, Hellenic Riot, worcej
seth24c (3) - Nanook, bozotheclow, MoscowFleet
worcej (2) - flash2015, Maniac
bozotheclown (1) - Tom Bombadil

Unvote / No kill (1) - seth24c

NOBODY is set to be splattered.

Just over four and a half hours remain in D4.

[Durga]

I've decided it's NOT scummy for worcej to be nice.

[flash2015]

##vote flash

A nice naked vote you have there...

[worcej]

What has worcej done differently that makes you question your read? Weren't you scumreading him because he wasn't ruffling feathers or yelling at you? He still hasn't done either of those things.

About the 3rd game in recent memory where I am trying to not be a dick sometimes and I get scummed.

Pick which worcej you want: dick/asshole or kinda nice but still blunt.

I'm not scumreading you, I wanted to know why Durga's read changed when you hadn't done anything different since she stated her read.

And kinda nice but still blunt please

Yes, I'd also like to know why Durga just 'shifted' too.

My comment was more a general statement.

[ghug]

##vote flash

A nice naked vote you have there...

A nice naked entire fucking game you have there.

[worcej]

##vote flash

A nice naked vote you have there...

A nice naked entire fucking game you have there.

I was trying to do something nice and blunt to respond back to flash, but this captured my thoughts too well.

[flash2015]

Fine, whatever, waste a day.

[ghug]

Fine, whatever, waste a day.

If you are town, you're the one wasting a day by being useless. Only whining about other people scumreading you does nothing to help. Give us some thoughts.

[Maniac]

##vote Seth seems like Worcej isn’t happening at the moment.

I wouldn’t be adverse to a Vecna kill either.

[worcej]

##vote Seth seems like Worcej isn’t happening at the moment.

I wouldn’t be adverse to a Vecna kill either.

So then why don't you vote Vecna instead of perpetuating the 3-way tie?

[ghug]

##vote Seth seems like Worcej isn’t happening at the moment.

I wouldn’t be adverse to a Vecna kill either.

Can you give a bit of justification for all three of those scumreads? Who do you townread?

[ghug]

##vote Seth seems like Worcej isn’t happening at the moment.

I wouldn’t be adverse to a Vecna kill either.

So then why don't you vote Vecna instead of perpetuating the 3-way tie?

Three way ties are sexy business.

[Durga]

About the 3rd game in recent memory where I am trying to not be a dick sometimes and I get scummed.

Pick which worcej you want: dick/asshole or kinda nice but still blunt.

I'm not scumreading you, I wanted to know why Durga's read changed when you hadn't done anything different since she stated her read.

And kinda nice but still blunt please

Yes, I'd also like to know why Durga just 'shifted' too.

My comment was more a general statement.

I already said why