M59 - Duck Season? - Game Thread

[seth24c]

Alright somewhat caught up now, thanks Bunny/Bozo for making it so hard to tell the difference between your posts. I think the only difference is whether a youtube link is included. That said, I am not sure why the multiple back to back votes by bozo was a thing, that felt a little off to me.

[TrPrado]

opposition through humor and ridicule is noted. If youre town, the proper response would've been suspicion. Easy targets, try-harding

What's the point of pressuring someone if you just instantly reveal what you're looking for?

Sharing my thoughts.

I do find it odd that if youre town, your first impression is not to think im tryhardnig there by coming up with some bullshit to read the two of you as partners on p1.

Instead both your reaction was ridicule, which often (not always) infers that you already know im town.

I believe the term is "implies" but more importantly what's wrong with a little bit of ridicule?

[TrPrado]

Yeah, I just realized what you meant, but I really doubt Tom would be so blatant about it...

That's my inclination too. And I don't think he's likely to "double bluff" like that. But it was strange. And I didn't like it.

I don't think I understand this discussion

They're WIFOM'ing a Tom post

[BunnyGo]

That's my inclination too. And I don't think he's likely to "double bluff" like that. But it was strange. And I didn't like it.

I don't think I understand this discussion

They're WIFOM'ing a Tom post

Very concise summary

[TrPrado]

Why you ignored hthefourth defense of you?

His post seems less a defense of me and more an attack on Bunny (which indirectly defends me, but I don’t think that was the intention. I can see why people would scumread Bunny in general because of how he plays. I also don’t know hthefourth, like I do bozo and damo

I disagree a bit. There were other post shading people before and hthefourth jumped on BunnyGo when he shaded you. On his second post. This look like a defense. But let's him answer this when he gets back.

Answer what exactly?

[TrPrado]

That makes three of us.

Basically, I think you’re just farting around to help make this game more interesting. I don’t think you really misunderstood my post about Goldie. And I don’t expect your vote to stay there long.

@Bunny what do you mean he misunderstood your post about Goldie? Is this what you're talking about? What was there to understand about you asking if goldfinger knows about the bot?

You're asking a lot of filler questions. You've already played with Gold, do you really think he doesn't know about the bot yet?

##Vote Gold though

Yup. Flum knew I'd played with gold several times. Gold and I are both fairly known quantities to all here (except hthe).

Hmm? Sorry, I can't be bothered to learn anyone's meta, it's like the most boring thing to do in Mafia

[TrPrado]

Question 1) do you have a picture of you in the Taz shirt to share?
Question 2) did you realize that mentioning you knew almost everyone and then mentioning Taz could be construed as a (admittedly obvious and ham handed) signal?

1) Maybe? I mean, I can check but I’m not digging through the attic or anything.
2) I don’t see how me mentioning I knew almost everyone can be construed as anything tbh. The Taz mention was what it seems on the surface - a comment on the flavor. The google doc in the setup thread had no flavor names and that was the setup I was reviewing so, yeah.

Are you saying you did not read the game setup in this thread to see if there were any updates since the sign up thread?

Do you think that would be scum indicative?

[worcej]

14 pages to read and insert irrelevant timed comments on.

WCGW?

[worcej]

POWERTHIRST!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qRuNxHqwazs

Needs more crowtien.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BEMlvjJ9uxo

Powerthirst is still better.

[worcej]

POWERTHIRST!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qRuNxHqwazs

I can’t even type after watching this.

You're welcome :D

[worcej]

Super Bingo is also a good one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CMdPYya3IoA

[TrPrado]

In case I was not clear, I voted for you the first time because you were defending kgray in a way that could be an attempt at pocketing, and I voted for you the second time because of you asking MF not to lurk as he "always" does, without an attempt to determine if that claim is accurate. When was the last time you played with MF?

Wow, this is a great example of why I don't bother learning people's metas!

[TrPrado]

Interesting defense of Tom. Out of the blue.

I thought so too.

@hthefourth, assuming you now know why Bunny thought Tom's post seemed odd, do you still think he has scum motivations for bringing it up?

I mean, I think the reasons are pretty thin. However, that may be more an indication of me being a noob to this game online (i.e. without the benefit of body language/tone) than anything else. Most times I've played, the bit "such and such looks suspicious" without further elaboration is just lazy shit-throwing, which doesn't help the town win even if the person doing it is actually town.

Now that I have seen that Bunny has rationale for their accusations, I can't complain.

You probably still can complain. Do you have thoughts on anyone else?

[worcej]

Now that I have you attention I would just like to point out the fact that I’m still lurking.

Are you knew? I've never seen you before.

I am knew to mafia, this is my second game. I’ve seen most of you before though. I’m enough to have been playing diplomacy here before mafia was played here.

You're also not new at stabbing your good English Ally (me) in an expensive game of gunboat and then getting kicked for reliability!

##vote seth24c

(Also, the stab was my own fault for being too open - I am aware of my failure lol...)

[worcej]

Wow so many people I like in this game, I'm so excited

Who is in the 'like' pile and who is in the 'not like' pile?

[worcej]

Does kgray do this rabid questioning thing as town too?

From my memory, yes.

[worcej]

##vote macca

because I like to bus.

Two-fer right here baby!

[worcej]

Focusing on the actual game, HR's single post to comment on mass-claims is kind of weird. Flum is funny. And the people who I haven't played with yet have all kind of blended together. Pretty desolate start as far as having something to go off of goes.

Can you be more specific on who these people are?

[worcej]

If you're town I expect a full 180 of your scum meta

Maybe my town meta is the same as my scum meta. Who know? I don't, this is my first town game.

This is perhaps the least believable sentence I have ever read

It did strike me as weird...

[TrPrado]

This doesn't answer the question, damo. If you didn't think he was the traitor, what were you referring to when you said "Is it worth taking the risk?".

I don't follow. It is what I was referring to.

..ooookay, I'll make it easier to follow.

Is it worth taking the risk?

##vote Tom

Can you explain exactly what you meant by this post and vote? If you think you've already explained it, humour me and explain again, thanks.

This is kind of painful to read, I thought it was pretty clear what damo meant and the sentence "it is what i was referring to" should have made it pretty clear that the question was answered. Why keep asking the same question over and over? Are you just not reading?