M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[brainbomb]

SCUMTEAM

Vecna
Fox
kgray
flash

[e.m.c^42]

@emc, did you say you were aware the Chaqa was gonna make that EON post?

Yeap

[Nephthys]

ok so of the three I was suspecting (food, Chaqa, emc) Emc is the least likely to be scum.

##unvote

Could you please tell me why? I'm trying to townread emc, but I'm really not able to do it in any way, so I'd like to see what you think.

Now that you ask it I can't actually articulate anything

[Nephthys]

@emc, did you say you were aware the Chaqa was gonna make that EON post?

Yeap

So in what world would Chaqa die last night. Surely he must be aware that if you were scum then you just don't kill last night and them you're cleared.

Seems like a weird oversight from Chaqa

[TheMarche]

One thing that just occured to me, and so I'm gonna address it now.

If donny was town, wouldnt we expect something from EMC that indicates it. Some post, some crumb.

It seems weird that he had the ability to effectively de-janitor the kill and yet held on to it for so long...

Are you serious? Are you actually serious, you are not this inane lmao

I obviously wanted to stay hidden as tracker. When you are a decently significant town PR in a role madness game you generally don't want to claim.

See, from the scum point of view, they know that Donny was town and that he was likely telling the truth - which means they can safely assume that tracker (and watcher with it, as typically there's only one out of the two roles present) is out of the equation when considering night actions.

I'm an unlikely target for roleblock or NK typically, which meant that I had a pretty good chance of tracking a handful of people and succeeding.

I like this. But still, my vote is because of Donny. I could say emc is town for what he says and how he expresses/justifies himself, but I am uncapable of convincing myself Donny was town.

[brainbomb]

TOWN
~
NEVER LYNCH EVER
jamiet99uk
summit
xorxes
rdrivera
chaqa
emc
dargo

[brainbomb]

thank you
this heartwarming brainbomb read session is brought to you by busch light

[brainbomb]

On a side note I started trying heineken 0% alcohol bottles. pretty good actually. tastes like beer and you dont realize it isnt beer.

[DemonRHK]

thank you
this heartwarming brainbomb read session is brought to you by busch light

Jesus that's an insult to water, let alone beer

[e.m.c^42]

@emc, did you say you were aware the Chaqa was gonna make that EON post?

Yeap

So in what world would Chaqa die last night. Surely he must be aware that if you were scum then you just don't kill last night and them you're cleared.

Seems like a weird oversight from Chaqa

Lol I think he believed me by then, but wanted something out in case he got NK'd at any point before a chance at saying more about Donny in-thread.

[brainbomb]

thank you
this heartwarming brainbomb read session is brought to you by busch light

Jesus that's an insult to water, let alone beer

https://youtu.be/uJYWZ6GTN2g

[Chaqa]

@emc, did you say you were aware the Chaqa was gonna make that EON post?

Yeap

So in what world would Chaqa die last night. Surely he must be aware that if you were scum then you just don't kill last night and them you're cleared.

Seems like a weird oversight from Chaqa

To be honest it was a double bluff. By informing him, I guaranteed I wouldn’t die, but the message meant if I did, he would get caught.

EMC didn’t know exactly what I was going to post anyway.

[e.m.c^42]

A bit of both. It started out as genuine confusion, and as he explained more (from my perspective) it read as if he kept on retconning his reasons or grasping for something without care for what it was. In hindsight it was probably a mixture of that and refinement. At some point I decided to take advantage of the situation and poke a bit more.

Hmm. I thought you seemed honestly confused/frustrated when you thought he was making logical fallacies, and townread you for it... Maybe I'll have to reevaluate that.

kgray seems to be alot less punchy this game too

You don't think it's possible that I'm a more difficult person to be rough at? :v

[Chaqa]

TOWN
~
NEVER LYNCH EVER
jamiet99uk
summit
xorxes
rdrivera
chaqa
emc
dargo

I agree with all of this except Dargo and maybe xorxes.

[e.m.c^42]

Are you serious? Are you actually serious, you are not this inane lmao

I obviously wanted to stay hidden as tracker. When you are a decently significant town PR in a role madness game you generally don't want to claim.

See, from the scum point of view, they know that Donny was town and that he was likely telling the truth - which means they can safely assume that tracker (and watcher with it, as typically there's only one out of the two roles present) is out of the equation when considering night actions.

I'm an unlikely target for roleblock or NK typically, which meant that I had a pretty good chance of tracking a handful of people and succeeding.

I like this. But still, my vote is because of Donny. I could say emc is town for what he says and how he expresses/justifies himself, but I am uncapable of convincing myself Donny was town.

Hmm, so basically you are extremely arrogant in your ability to read Donny. Lmao.

I feel like most of my other votes are because of this as well.

[TheMarche]

I have to go. I stopped myself at page 132, and i'll finish reading later.

##Unvote. I'd still vote emc. But his posts are too town. I'll probably go on voting himself again later, because I'm looking only at the game's mechanics and not at the way someone expresses himself (Everybody can lie, and build townish posts). But i see the possibility for someone to see emc during the night and actually making all this clear.

[TheMarche]

I obviously wanted to stay hidden as tracker. When you are a decently significant town PR in a role madness game you generally don't want to claim.

See, from the scum point of view, they know that Donny was town and that he was likely telling the truth - which means they can safely assume that tracker (and watcher with it, as typically there's only one out of the two roles present) is out of the equation when considering night actions.

I'm an unlikely target for roleblock or NK typically, which meant that I had a pretty good chance of tracking a handful of people and succeeding.

I like this. But still, my vote is because of Donny. I could say emc is town for what he says and how he expresses/justifies himself, but I am uncapable of convincing myself Donny was town.

Hmm, so basically you are extremely arrogant in your ability to read Donny. Lmao.

I feel like most of my other votes are because of this as well.

It's my only clue. Donny shouldn't have known about the secretary if he was a new player. And, on the top of all, he never explained how he found that role.

[e.m.c^42]

In regards to brain's reads, I'd be lenient and give the fox/vec benefit of null until closer to EoD. Not really sure about kgray, would need rereading.

[DemonRHK]

thank you
this heartwarming brainbomb read session is brought to you by busch light

Jesus that's an insult to water, let alone beer

https://youtu.be/uJYWZ6GTN2g

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zJG7CIqLo9A

[e.m.c^42]

It's my only clue. Donny shouldn't have known about the secretary if he was a new player. And, on the top of all, he never explained how he found that role.

Hah, tbh I don't really know either. The only thing I can think of is that he skimmed a previous worcej game and it left an impression but not exactly what it was. He's been seen on-off reading the mafia thread before iirc.