M53: Mafia 1 Redux

[brainbomb]

bob just defense voted and ignored 2 viable scumreads. kalel is still lynchable and he chose emc who wasnt even on his scumreads

[Vecna]

Im gonna try and put my hand in the fire to try and dissuade the BOB wagon.

I also had surface level doubts, especially to his entrance, but when I questioned him on it he had an extremely towny response. My gut has also been telling me that most of his posts following since have been town motivated.

im 95% certain lynching him will be a town flip. He'll be a good part of my townblock of people that should not be lynched.

how do know he isnt sk?

I dont read based on team compositions or whatever. The SK might be a bit harder to catch than scum, but I rarely townread 3rd parties since they will also have the genuine factor missing.

My townread on bob is not based on how he scumhunts. -that- would be easy to fake for an SK. Its his towny responses and general statements that ive liked.

[e.m.c^42]

Especially Bob.

more on him! Since there's some less point talking about others until later due to current circumstances lol

Contrary to what some said, don't think that him dropping the accentuated text style in defense is scummy - more of newish town? Like, would argue it's actually more scummy to have kept it up, since it was made generally clear that personal dislike of style was interfering with comprehension with at least three people iirc, most prominently Squigs.

but mainly, it's like when we lynched him day 1 as scum the last time he played, he just went limped/didn't attempt defense at all. Very different from what is currently happening.

[rdrivera2005]

Ill keep stating I feel 7/8 people on the top two wagons are the sketchy part of the game. #8 is defense voting.

Vecna, how do you feel about Kalel?

[e.m.c^42]

##Vote emc

Lmaoo rip, this is vaguely awkward considering post timing

oh well

[brainbomb]

how do you townread stuff like that? inexperience? striking blatant inconsistency?

I dont think my insta goto reaction is to say yep TOWN FOR SURE.
didnt push a scumread and chose to push the bigger wagon.

yep. totally town.

cmon vecna you think skeptical how is this not registering

[brainbomb]

My townread on bob is not based on how he scumhunts. -that- would be easy to fake for an SK. Its his towny responses and general statements that ive liked.

examples?

[Vecna]

Ill keep stating I feel 7/8 people on the top two wagons are the sketchy part of the game. #8 is defense voting.

Vecna, how do you feel about Kalel?

I really dont know/remember how he plays as town.

Part of me wants to equate his play to how he played as when he was on my scumteam. There are some feel'ish differences.

TLDR: I dont really know yet. He's far below my townreads

[e.m.c^42]

Trying to catch up for EOD. Have to pick up kids.

1) I’m fed up with EMC. I policy voted last game and will do again
2) Kalel is scummy scum scum
3) the rest looks noisy to me. Could be anything so far
4) I’m so glad BB is here. I’m surprised I’m saying that.

Bungo, on the other hand...

[brainbomb]

vecna wants to lynch jamie. not bunny or emc.


why is emc a bad lynch vecna?

[rdrivera2005]

how do you townread stuff like that? inexperience? striking blatant inconsistency?

I dont think my insta goto reaction is to say yep TOWN FOR SURE.
didnt push a scumread and chose to push the bigger wagon.

yep. totally town.

cmon vecna you think skeptical how is this not registering

If he isn't the second wagon with an hour to EOD it could be scummy, but self defense is NAI.

[brainbomb]

it isnt about the self defense.

its that kalel is one of his scumreads but he voted top wagon instead

[e.m.c^42]

oh huh, vecna came in too with bob dissuasion. Surprised he did not mention point in regards to defense, and went with feeling from other posts instead.

[brainbomb]

he wasnt talking about emc being scum at all

[rdrivera2005]

I am leaving work now, hope to be online at EOD.

I will ##vote Jamiet to make this EOD more interesting.

[Vecna]

My townread on bob is not based on how he scumhunts. -that- would be easy to fake for an SK. Its his towny responses and general statements that ive liked.

examples?

Read his large post on page 6. It described an original take on the gamestate that was disagreeing with the big posters. It resonated with me and was a genuine way to look at things.

Then look at his interactions with me on page 7. I accused him randomly, and he reacted in a pretty towny way (jumping on my push, questioning it, even after stating I change my mind he keeps prodding WTF i was doing, but he's willing to let it go and not make a mess of it, in a reasonable way).

[brainbomb]

a 3 way tie.

interesting choice rivera

[rdrivera2005]

it isnt about the self defense.

its that kalel is one of his scumreads but he voted top wagon instead

He was tied with EMC and he was voting Kalel with me and that wagon didn't get any traction

[brainbomb]

Salutations once again from Angonia. Continuing with my guesses on whom might be evil amongst us, I once again hath not much to report.

Contrary to Nephthys's feelings, I doth not think that Xorxes seemeth to be trying too hard. As it happens, I doth not believe anyone is trying particularly hard other than Nephthys himself, Kitsune and to some extent Xorxes. Bozo the jester couldst be considered trying, but thus far hath not proven that he ist actually doing anything. Being the first day of our wonderful village however, I doth not believe that until innocent villagers starteth dying that our populace shalt seriously consider what ought be done to preventeth any further deaths.

Having already stated my views upon the jester Bozo, I shalt now move on to Nephthys. Nephthys seemingly needlessly hath distracted Xorxes for a period of time in conversations upon the rules, to no apparent gain. Nephthys appeareth to hath made no meaning full contributions thus far. I shalt refrain from drawing conclusions from this at this point, as he is no different from any others here.

Kitsune hath started talking about the jester's plan, although not much else. She doth raise some interesting questions about opposition toward it. However, I am inclined to agree with Nephthys in that Bozo's plan doth not seem to have any inherent negative outcomes, although his method is somewhat questionable.

I still hath not felt many vibrations, either for evil or for good. I shalt update ye on my thoughts as more people elaborateth upon theirs. Ye may expecteth to see a more thorough analysis before the end of the first day in this village, along with an obligatory accusation of one member of our populace.

I assume you mean this vecna?

[Vecna]

vecna wants to lynch jamie. not bunny or emc.


why is emc a bad lynch vecna?

Im not sure it is. But EMC usually becomes very readable later on.

What has me worried on that wagon is how jamiet stated "If he is scum" when I made my -2 bussing EMC 1 on Bob- post. That sounded like a TMI slip, being upset at a correct'ish conclusion based on the wrong assumption.

If Jamiet it scum, that makes EMC suddenly look pretty good. While it would also give us good concern to look at those others that were voting EMC.