Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Foxcastle]

TrPrado near the end of N1 called for a FoxCastle lynch. At the start of D1 he went after Fox aggressively with what I thought was a weak case. Before he died tonight Fox and teacon were his top two scumreads.

From what I can see TrPrado could have very likely scanned FoxCastle as guilty. Going to re-read more of TrPrado, but others should look at this as well.

I assumed he scanned you, actually. Because he clearly refers to his view on you shifting. If he had a real scan on me, why would he call it a "feeling" that he also shares with teacon?

[Durga]

I was roleblocked. I think Tom has to be town mechanically.

What the heck is this comment

[ChippeRock]

TrPrado near the end of N1 called for a FoxCastle lynch. At the start of D1 he went after Fox aggressively with what I thought was a weak case. Before he died tonight Fox and teacon were his top two scumreads.

From what I can see TrPrado could have very likely scanned FoxCastle as guilty. Going to re-read more of TrPrado, but others should look at this as well.

Emphasis on *near the* end. He only gets his results back at the END of the night, so we can't really read too much into that (still something worth noting).

[Durga]

Guys, judge can't use their power on consecutive days. Please everyone go re-read the OP so that we stop having stuff like this happen.

Ah, right. Fuck. Innocent Child needs to reveal though.

[Squigs44]

TrPrado near the end of N1 called for a FoxCastle lynch. At the start of D1 he went after Fox aggressively with what I thought was a weak case. Before he died tonight Fox and teacon were his top two scumreads.

From what I can see TrPrado could have very likely scanned FoxCastle as guilty. Going to re-read more of TrPrado, but others should look at this as well.

I assumed he scanned you, actually. Because he clearly refers to his view on you shifting. If he had a real scan on me, why would he call it a "feeling" that he also shares with teacon?

Hmmm... you're probably right here actually. I originally iso'd around the last couple posts of N1 and first couple posts of D1 since that would be the best place to signal things to us. But upon further re-read his post here he puts me above you in his scumlist, so a scan on me is more likely.

[Durga]

TrPrado near the end of N1 called for a FoxCastle lynch. At the start of D1 he went after Fox aggressively with what I thought was a weak case. Before he died tonight Fox and teacon were his top two scumreads.

From what I can see TrPrado could have very likely scanned FoxCastle as guilty. Going to re-read more of TrPrado, but others should look at this as well.

I assumed he scanned you, actually. Because he clearly refers to his view on you shifting. If he had a real scan on me, why would he call it a "feeling" that he also shares with teacon?

You assumed he scanned Squigs? When did you figure this bit out. Does that mean Squigs is town?

[Squigs44]

I was roleblocked. I think Tom has to be town mechanically.

What the heck is this comment

Two different ideas, unrelated.
1) I was roleblocked
2) Tom was janitored, but mechanically we know he was town rather than BA or mafia.

[Durga]

I was roleblocked. I think Tom has to be town mechanically.

What the heck is this comment

Two different ideas, unrelated.
1) I was roleblocked
2) Tom was janitored, but mechanically we know he was town rather than BA or mafia.

??? Why would mafia kill themselves? And BA is immune from mafia kill. Mafia can't kill anything BUT town. ANd they certainly wouldn't jailor a random dude they weren't killing.

Pls

Also I think you're town now

[ChippeRock]

TrPrado near the end of N1 called for a FoxCastle lynch. At the start of D1 he went after Fox aggressively with what I thought was a weak case. Before he died tonight Fox and teacon were his top two scumreads.

From what I can see TrPrado could have very likely scanned FoxCastle as guilty. Going to re-read more of TrPrado, but others should look at this as well.

Emphasis on *near the* end. He only gets his results back at the END of the night, so we can't really read too much into that (still something worth noting).

But perhaps he was trying to signal that his opinions were changing so that if the scan brought back unexpected results, his shift in opinion wouldn't seem so sudden.

[Squigs44]

Okay well in that case, Tom's reads have Percy as his top scum which lines up with what I was already thinking so I feel good about my vote for now. Will spend some time iso'ing Percy and coming up with questions for him. I feel like the EP et stuff we did yesterday was helpful, so something similar to that.

[ChippeRock]

What the heck is this comment

Two different ideas, unrelated.
1) I was roleblocked
2) Tom was janitored, but mechanically we know he was town rather than BA or mafia.

??? Why would mafia kill themselves? And BA is immune from mafia kill. Mafia can't kill anything BUT town. ANd they certainly wouldn't jailor a random dude they weren't killing.

Pls

Also I think you're town now

WTFing over this seemingly confused response of yours.

[Durga]

That really has to be the most useless statement I've heard. God.

If we mislynch today its 8-5-1. At that point, BA **cannot** use their NK because it would be stupid and HAS to track, and it'll be 7-5-1. It's not the end of the world.

[Durga]

Wait is there 6 mafia

[Durga]

Lol ignore me pls

[teacon7]

80 pages of reading is... a lot. So I'm coming up for air to post on current events. Things don't look good here either.

Did prado leave any clues re: his scans? I mean, the cop was pretty nerfed anyway, but still.

Thoughts on play hereforeward:

• The judge should NOT use his/her power until the innocent child is revealed. We don't want to get locked into voting for only one candidate because the other one gets gm-confirmed inno.
• If the innocent child reveals, does this bit of information help to reveal voting patterns that lynches us scum today? Having a confirmed town would make an obvious maf target, but there's a chance it gives info for today. We kinda need that.
• SK should probably not fire unless they're certain they're gonna hit scum. @SK: sniffing for maf PR would be way more helpful at this point.
• Let's discuss the prudence of a reporter claiming, in the event they've seen anything. No one gets cleared, but the information and its implications could come in handy. There's more scum roles out there than mobile PR, so imo the reporter seeing ANYTHING is going to be helpful.

A couple impressions from my catchup while I'm still reading:

What's everyone's read on squiggs/balki/xorxes? Does anyone think they're scum? They don't seem like the sort of players who should go uninvestigated.

more later. 80 pages is going to take a while.

[Durga]

That mod kill fucking sucks

[Squigs44]

What the heck is this comment

Two different ideas, unrelated.
1) I was roleblocked
2) Tom was janitored, but mechanically we know he was town rather than BA or mafia.

??? Why would mafia kill themselves? And BA is immune from mafia kill. Mafia can't kill anything BUT town. ANd they certainly wouldn't jailor a random dude they weren't killing.

Pls

Also I think you're town now

Yeah, that's what I am saying. Tom had to have been the mafia kill since he was janitored. He couldn't have been mafia since mafia wouldn't kill one of their own, and he couldn't have been BA because he is immune to the mafia kill.

I was stating the obvious because lately in this game people don't understand the obvious.

[Durga]

teacon just fucking stop reading and engage with us, it'll be more useful for everyone. you can go back and read shit that turn out important

[Squigs44]

So the only way the TrPrado kill makes sense is if SK scanned him N1, got a PR result, and killed him entirely on that basis. It would have made sense for a TrPrado scan since he was scumread by several people D1. That means our BA could be among the D1 TrPrado voters. I just am not sure if going after the BA is helpful to us right now, but definitely something to keep in mind.

[Squigs44]

Those kills actually gave us a lot more information I think. I feel good about today guys.