Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Balki Bartokomous]

There's only one town PR after the innocent child and the judge, and it's a pretty useless reporter.

Besides, scum haven't been aiming for PR, they're aiming for people who won't get mislynched. Pretty sure Tom is VT.

We're probably losing this game because this BA is so anti-town, agh.

I was looking at the bot, and I am reading from where I left off,
I also read a bit of Tom's stuff

The BA so far has been quite self-preserving, probably killing people he thought suspected him
So Balki killing Tom makes some sense but not much, he only made some comments about Balki in the beginning of the Night, Im not so sure Balki would kill Tom for that

When it comes to Carl and Darg I also looked about at them
Carl never even suspected Balki except for one moment in Night one, makes no sense that Balki killed him
So then I looked at darg
Darg >DEFENDED< Balki Night one

If the BA has been self-preserving, then there is no way its Balki

I did not kill Carl or Darg. I sent my dog out, and got back a scan on a player with a Power Role. Scum killed Carl and Darg.

[Durga]

There's only one town PR after the innocent child and the judge, and it's a pretty useless reporter.

Besides, scum haven't been aiming for PR, they're aiming for people who won't get mislynched. Pretty sure Tom is VT.

We're probably losing this game because this BA is so anti-town, agh.

I was looking at the bot, and I am reading from where I left off,
I also read a bit of Tom's stuff

The BA so far has been quite self-preserving, probably killing people he thought suspected him
So Balki killing Tom makes some sense but not much, he only made some comments about Balki in the beginning of the Night, Im not so sure Balki would kill Tom for that

When it comes to Carl and Darg I also looked about at them
Carl never even suspected Balki except for one moment in Night one, makes no sense that Balki killed him
So then I looked at darg
Darg >DEFENDED< Balki Night one

If the BA has been self-preserving, then there is no way its Balki

what the FUCK are you talking about

[ChippeRock]

I scanned on N1 because I didn’t want to risk being scanned by the reporter. But by N2, I felt pretty strongly that I had to kill scum have a chance.

I solicited votes to try to help get reads, and I actually tried on Day 2! For Town!

Well, I don't recall TrPrado receiving a vote - so why did you even ask for a vote count if you weren't going to follow it?

[Durga]

I have no idea how to interpret that entire message.

Is it a scum slip? Is he deliberately pretending he doesn't know who killed who as if it isn't completely obvious?

Is it a town slip? Does he not know the difference between the assassin and the BA?

[et]

Sorry, the Prado kill is my bad. That makes it very hard for anyone but scum to win.

Though, Rivera, I think this was a mistake to claim so overtly given the game state, but I understand why you did.

Are you BA? What did you Night1?

[FlaviusAetius]

Guys, judge can't use their power on consecutive days. Please everyone go re-read the OP so that we stop having stuff like this happen.

Ah, right. Fuck. Innocent Child needs to reveal though.

They can reveal tomorrow to help the Judge determine who to make candidates, but not a moment before, unless they are about to be lynched

[FlaviusAetius]

I have no idea how to interpret that entire message.

Is it a scum slip? Is he deliberately pretending he doesn't know who killed who as if it isn't completely obvious?

Is it a town slip? Does he not know the difference between the assassin and the BA?

I LITERALLY went back to the bot and saw who killed who, what are you talking about

[rdrivera2005]

So I think we need to stop hunting for the BA at this point, since its most definitely not Balki, and no need for someone to counter claim ##vote Balki

This is really scummy.

[ChippeRock]

I scanned on N1 because I didn’t want to risk being scanned by the reporter. But by N2, I felt pretty strongly that I had to kill scum have a chance.

I solicited votes to try to help get reads, and I actually tried on Day 2! For Town!

Well, I don't recall TrPrado receiving a vote - so why did you even ask for a vote count if you weren't going to follow it?

You're not convincing me right now Balki...

[FlaviusAetius]

Know what Im tired of, Im tired of everyone saying Im a noob at this game. You know what? Thats ridiculous you guys just dont want to listen to me Im trying to help Im trying to participate, Ive been responding to EVERYTHING
Ive read every single word on every single page and all I get is ridiculousness

[rdrivera2005]

##unvote by the way.

Need to consider the options. If Balki is scum we are in Mylo?

[damo666]

There's only one town PR after the innocent child and the judge, and it's a pretty useless reporter.

Besides, scum haven't been aiming for PR, they're aiming for people who won't get mislynched. Pretty sure Tom is VT.

We're probably losing this game because this BA is so anti-town, agh.

I was looking at the bot, and I am reading from where I left off,
I also read a bit of Tom's stuff

The BA so far has been quite self-preserving, probably killing people he thought suspected him
So Balki killing Tom makes some sense but not much, he only made some comments about Balki in the beginning of the Night, Im not so sure Balki would kill Tom for that

When it comes to Carl and Darg I also looked about at them
Carl never even suspected Balki except for one moment in Night one, makes no sense that Balki killed him
So then I looked at darg
Darg >DEFENDED< Balki Night one

If the BA has been self-preserving, then there is no way its Balki

what the FUCK are you talking about

Ditto

[Durga]

I have no idea how to interpret that entire message.

Is it a scum slip? Is he deliberately pretending he doesn't know who killed who as if it isn't completely obvious?

Is it a town slip? Does he not know the difference between the assassin and the BA?

I LITERALLY went back to the bot and saw who killed who, what are you talking about

How does the bot tell you who killed who?

[Durga]

##unvote by the way.

Need to consider the options. If Balki is scum we are in Mylo?

i mean, we've got pretty good chances of lynching another one even if we don't lynch him right. between you me and squigs we should... figure out.. something

[damo666]

##VOTE Flav

[Balki Bartokomous]

I scanned on N1 because I didn’t want to risk being scanned by the reporter. But by N2, I felt pretty strongly that I had to kill scum have a chance.

I solicited votes to try to help get reads, and I actually tried on Day 2! For Town!

Well, I don't recall TrPrado receiving a vote - so why did you even ask for a vote count if you weren't going to follow it?

You're not convincing me right now Balki...

Welp, I don’t think I can win anyway.

Do you want me to reveal my power role scan? Pretty sure it’s on a Townie.

[FlaviusAetius]

TrPrado near the end of N1 called for a FoxCastle lynch. At the start of D1 he went after Fox aggressively with what I thought was a weak case. Before he died tonight Fox and teacon were his top two scumreads.

From what I can see TrPrado could have very likely scanned FoxCastle as guilty. Going to re-read more of TrPrado, but others should look at this as well.

I assumed he scanned you, actually. Because he clearly refers to his view on you shifting. If he had a real scan on me, why would he call it a "feeling" that he also shares with teacon?

I dont think we can really tell if he pushed FoxCastle enough becaus of the whole Judge thing, and I dont even remember him saying anything about him in the Night, I think he probably scanned people he somewhat suspected and then stopped mentioning them except in his big reads

[ND]

I'm going to ##unvote for now and hear this out. If there is a chance Balki is the BA considering lynching BA would be a mistake right now I think it's best to hear him out. I don't really get the whole night BA vote thing thu so hopefully he elaborates more on that.

[Durga]

Well, I don't recall TrPrado receiving a vote - so why did you even ask for a vote count if you weren't going to follow it?

You're not convincing me right now Balki...

Welp, I don’t think I can win anyway.

Do you want me to reveal my power role scan? Pretty sure it’s on a Townie.

dont do it

[rdrivera2005]

Know what Im tired of, Im tired of everyone saying Im a noob at this game. You know what? Thats ridiculous you guys just dont want to listen to me Im trying to help Im trying to participate, Ive been responding to EVERYTHING
Ive read every single word on every single page and all I get is ridiculousness

If Balki is really the BA we might need to keep him alive. Killing the BA now is probably giving Mafia the win. But we need to weight the risk he is just lying.