Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Foxcastle]

This is one of the most productive openings of D1 I may have ever seen

Because there's no joke phase.

[FlaviusAetius]

True, but there were also no other information or targets I can even go on. Also, how did last game finding my meta work out for you? It didn't. Not at all.
There's context to the scenario

[Percy Williams]

Wut?

I already asked him that
Pay up, punk

NO JOKE PHASE.

I don't think we're in a joke phase here, just seeing over 20 people engaged in jovial banter, the kind that keeps people interested and talking.

[MoscowFleet]

Chip chip cheerio chaps, it’s bloody burning outside, innit?

[TrPrado]

This is one of the most productive openings of D1 I may have ever seen

What are your findings?

It's a bit early for me to hand those out

But there's a lot to analyze. Foxy wished for a joke free early phase, and so we had a conversation about it instead and everybody had something to chime in on.

[FlaviusAetius]

Ok but Squigs just said that the other player in his game was super accurate with giving early reads, I'm in the middle of giving mine

[Percy Williams]

Chip chip cheerio chaps, it’s bloody burning outside, innit?

Aye Guv'ner!

[Squigs44]

This is one of the most productive openings of D1 I may have ever seen

You're welcome

[Squigs44]

You lied. That is a confirmable fact. It may have been a mistaken lie with no ill intent, but it was a lie nonetheless. You are being very defensive this game though

First game Im being accused of being scum :shrugs:

Last game when accused of being scum (As a town in Lylo) Flavius Aetius was less defensive and more accusatory of any other target.

Slight town

[TrPrado]

True, but there were also no other information or targets I can even go on. Also, how did last game finding my meta work out for you? It didn't. Not at all.
There's context to the scenario

I'm always not huge on using behavior in past games to inform how to read a player now, but there's definitely a better point in his read on you than just "oh his meta" and that shouldn't be dismissed

[connorcompton]

Chip chip cheerio chaps, it’s bloody burning outside, innit?

Aye Guv'ner!

I do say considering my time it's honestly a tad chilly.

[Squigs44]

Ok but Squigs just said that the other player in his game was super accurate with giving early reads, I'm in the middle of giving mine

They weren't super accurate, they were better than average accurate. It's more of a fun exercise than a reliable way to catch scum. When you say you are in the middle of your reads, I recall you giving reads on Fox and TrPrado. Did you give any other reads?

[Balki Bartokomous]

Ok but Squigs just said that the other player in his game was super accurate with giving early reads, I'm in the middle of giving mine

I'm not following this comment.Who are you talking to here? And how does the person the Squigs was referencing relate to you?

[FlaviusAetius]

Squigs-Town
Foxcastle-Town
Balki-Mafia
TrPardo-Mafia
Connor-Town
Percy-Mafia
darg-Town
Carl Tuckerson-Mafia
et-Mafia
Moscow-Mafia
Nepthys-Mafia

[Squigs44]

@Squigs My dad does this all the time.
MISTAKES DO NOT EQUAL LIES.
I clearly thought you thought that foxcastle was scum, you don't have to jump to conclusions and just call me a liar. Obviously, you could check that real quick, anyone could why even just call me a liar like that?

Anyways I also agree foxcastle is a townsperson
TrPrado, on the other hand, is probably scum

You lied. That is a confirmable fact. It may have been a mistaken lie with no ill intent, but it was a lie nonetheless. You are being very defensive this game though

So vote him then

I tend to use my vote early for pressure or to make a point. I think Flav already has enough pressure. Besides, his greatest crimes right now are being defensive and lying. Townies are defensive and lie all the time. What you have to do is look at why Flav lied and why he is being defensive.

[Durga]

Woah this is a really early start

[FlaviusAetius]

Ok I just realized thats a lot of mafia, but I think if everyone does that we can compare lists

[Squigs44]

Squigs-Town
Foxcastle-Town
Balki-Mafia
TrPardo-Mafia
Connor-Town
Percy-Mafia
darg-Town
Carl Tuckerson-Mafia
et-Mafia
Moscow-Mafia
Nepthys-Mafia

Hate to break it to you, but there aren't that many mafia.

Plus, there are bound to be mafia among the non-posters so far.

[FlaviusAetius]

You lied. That is a confirmable fact. It may have been a mistaken lie with no ill intent, but it was a lie nonetheless. You are being very defensive this game though

So vote him then

I tend to use my vote early for pressure or to make a point. I think Flav already has enough pressure. Besides, his greatest crimes right now are being defensive and lying. Townies are defensive and lie all the time. What you have to do is look at why Flav lied and why he is being defensive.

THANK YOU

[FlaviusAetius]

Squigs-Town
Foxcastle-Town
Balki-Mafia
TrPardo-Mafia
Connor-Town
Percy-Mafia
darg-Town
Carl Tuckerson-Mafia
et-Mafia
Moscow-Mafia
Nepthys-Mafia

Hate to break it to you, but there aren't that many mafia.

Plus, there are bound to be mafia among the non-posters so far.

I tried to put criteria to it, I think splatting paint on the wall is better than nothing, everyone should do the same and then we compare lists