MINI MAFIA IV GAME THREAD

[xorxes]

Are you referring to your explanation that Dr's attempt to build an information management and analysis strategy was scummy?

What? Why are you making stuff up? When did I say that was scummy?

I'm referring to the made up reason he came up to vote for me.

In retrospect I should have gotten behind that proposal. Scum have all the information and so in theory will try to stop the development of new information. You're doing EXACTLY THIS by trying to get us back on your weak narrative about DrCJG - who was, conversely, trying to find a way to build information.

The proposal was never going to fly, but I said I would support it if there was a consensus. Neither the proposal nor whatever reactions everyone had to it are in the least alignment indicative.

You seemed pretty genuine in your arguments until today. Now you are staring to feel off.

[xorxes]

Also, NEITHER xorxes or worcej have really made significant reads or contributions to solving the game.

That's simply false. Just because people refuse to engage with my arguments doesn't mean I haven't presented them. Noone has yet explained why DrCJG's excuse for voting for me was not as scummy as it gets.

Lets take a different angle, would you vote for worcej? Why or why not?

Are you not reading the thread?

[foodcoats]

That's simply false. Just because people refuse to engage with my arguments doesn't mean I haven't presented them. Noone has yet explained why DrCJG's excuse for voting for me was not as scummy as it gets.

Lets take a different angle, would you vote for worcej? Why or why not?

Are you not reading the thread?

4 or 5 times now i think.

I want you to commit in word to your position NOW. Not just block quotes and question marks.

Yesterday i confidently lynched a friend. Today i catch a scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

I have a reason to think worcej is town but I'm not sure it's fairgame to use it, I'm going to anyway:

If worcej was scum, then damo's "rather" argument wouldn't be so silly after all, but then the GMs wouldn't have made fun of it.

The GMs made fun of it, therefore it was as silly as it sounds, therefore worcej is town.

This is a terrible post.

Never.
Second.
Guess.
The.
GM.

[Jamiet99uk]

Let me say it again:

If Worcej is scum, Damo's arguments about him using the word "rather" were still utter dogshit.

[xorxes]

Lets take a different angle, would you vote for worcej? Why or why not?

Are you not reading the thread?

4 or 5 times now i think.

Then why are you asking me whether I would vote for worcej when I just explained why I wouldn't?

(I only would in self-defense as a last resort.)

[brainbomb]

xorxes if youre pr you should claim so we have direction.

[brainbomb]

the only way I can see you as town rn is if youre a PR tbh

[xorxes]

Let me say it again:

If Worcej is scum, Damo's arguments about him using the word "rather" were still utter dogshit.

Probably, but still...

[brainbomb]

given the situation were in a massclaim might help us all have best possible poe today

[brainbomb]

foodcoats hasnt explained why tdhfrance is town. so im curious if thats a cop inno scan.

[brainbomb]

foodcoats hasnt explained why tdhfrance is town. so im curious if thats a cop inno scan.

if this is the case we probably lynch neph

[brainbomb]

##Vote worcej

[foodcoats]

foodcoats hasnt explained why tdhfrance is town. so im curious if thats a cop inno scan.

Sorry brain. Can that argument. I thought thd would not be so inactive as mafia. But since they are leaving the game my reasoning is invalid.

[brainbomb]

hi bozo.

any reads.

*smiles*


hiiii

[brainbomb]

how do you feel bozo?

[foodcoats]

##Vote worcej

Brain why worcej over xorxes? How do you feel about my arguments?

[brainbomb]

##Vote worcej

Brain why worcej over xorxes? How do you feel about my arguments?

your arguments are fine. and youre town. right now im just seeing if anyone comes to life.

[bozotheclown]

What are your unanswered questions? I will do my best to answer.

Here is the post you did not respond to:

Weren't you scum with damo is a game? It sounds like you are making an excuse for scum reading damo. If you preferred to lynch xorxes, why didn't you make a case against him? Why did you wait until EOD to move your vote back to xorxes, and why did you use an invalid format when you voted for xorxes?

Okay. I have subsequently answered all of this, I believe, mostly in response to foodcoats, so I refer you to those answers.

The one thing I see I have not answered is the very last part of your question. The answer is simply that it was a typo. On my phone keyboard, the full stop (period) is right beside the space bar, and the space bar is annoyingly narrow. I therefore hit the full stop by accident.

An important point in relation to this: I would remind everyone that, as I have often said before, the Peterbot is a useful tool, but it is not a replacement for the GM. Only the GM's vote counts and the GM's adjudications are official. My vote for Xorxes contained a small typo, but I would have expected the GM to accept it as a valid vote, to be honest. Therefore I reject any suggestion that I was deliberately attempting to cast an invalid vote.

I do not think you answered the part about whether you were scum with damo in a previous game, and if so, why you seemed to imply you have never seen him as scum before.

[bozotheclown]

how do you feel bozo?

I feel the thdfrance situation is a problem, since his D1 voting looks bad. I see your last two votes were for Jamie and worcej, I am still fine with lynching either of them today.