Mafia XL - A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum

[ghug]

Jesus Christ, if this scum play of ‘I have proof but you can’t see it’ works I’m going to rip every one of you a new asshole post game.

But if we are wrong and he is scum, we will get him tomorrow. It still isn't effectively lylo today even if scum got the other gun from the box (i.e. mislynch today, NK plus gun use tomorrow still makes us 5-4).

It's *much* better for town to get this right today. It gives us twice as many mislynches to use in catching the final three scum.

[DemonRHK]

Jesus Christ, if this scum play of ‘I have proof but you can’t see it’ works I’m going to rip every one of you a new asshole post game.

But if we are wrong and he is scum, we will get him tomorrow. It still isn't effectively lylo today even if scum got the other gun from the box (i.e. mislynch today, NK plus gun use tomorrow still makes us 5-4).

If you lynch me, it’s 7-4
NK makes 6-4
Lynch DrC, 6-3
NK makes 5-3
AND THIS IS WITHOUT THE POSSIBLE BOX EXPLOSION.

THIS IS A SCUM NARRATIVE THAT A MISLYNCH HERE IS OK.

[DemonRHK]

GMs confirm PMs are correct.

[bo_sox48]

##CALL GM - can you confirm that all, if any, PMs sent to RHK and Dr throughout this game have been correct?

[worcej]

Well, looks like I missed a lot from my last show up. DrCJG's move is... very interesting. I look at it like this:

1. If he is a town PR, he is doing this because he knows Demon lied and we are getting closer to mylo.
2. If he is scum and we lynch, we can then get him the next day and still avoid mylo.

To me, I think he is the town version of this. Why? Because Demon probably had the weird idea at the last second to claim a PR and then suddenly he didn't die, now he has to follow through with that lie.

I really don't understand why people are voting for DrCJG. Town were dead until he made that claim. Now we are back in the hunt (we have a guaranteed scum kill at worst tomorrow). If he is scum, it just makes no sense for him to out himself like this today. Until he made the claim, scum were coasting to victory...

I agree - we are not at mylo or lylo, so if demon is town, by DrCJG showing he is scum, he doesn't outright win yet.

This is one of those moments that Squigs has solved something and you all sheep me. Dr is town, Demon is scum. No further questions.

Can't argue with you - you solved 2 games I know of.

##vote Demon

I am confident flash...

@Ghug
@Durga
@Bozo
@Worcej
@Bo

If you don't believe me then vote me... but don't let this become a last minute shuffle.

I don't see why you as scum would benefit from this lie and you are fairly confident. You have Squigs with you, so I am in as well, thus the vote above.

What I don't understand here is - what scum motivation did DemonRHK actually have for claiming his role today? If he is scum and he didn't claim his role, there would have been no chance of a CC as both the doctor and observer are still out there.

Demon - are you be absolutely sure you shared with us the right results from your observations? Can you double-check? Double-check with the GM?

I would have loudly advocated for his lynch without a specific claim, and I hope I wouldn't have been alone, so there's that.

Double quoting, because ghug also addressed the same thing I would've said in response to this.

[worcej]

If you lynch me, it’s 7-4
NK makes 6-4
Lynch DrC, 6-3
NK makes 5-3
AND THIS IS WITHOUT THE POSSIBLE BOX EXPLOSION.

THIS IS A SCUM NARRATIVE THAT A MISLYNCH HERE IS OK.

You can also say that your passion could be because of this:

Your lynch, it's 8-3.

And then the box could possibly off you.

[DemonRHK]

You idiots, IF WE MISLYNCH HERE IT’S ALMOST A LOCK FOR SCUM.

The box goes random immediately. Scum could pull a gun TONIGHT, pass a detonating box to town, and we’re FUCKED.

[ghug]

The thing, worcej, is that a mislynch is a mislynch. There are four of them left right now. Trading one for one when you only need two more mislynches to win is a good trade for them. People were skeptical enough of RHK's claim to begin with that that would have appeared feasible. It makes even more sense if he's scummates with someone he thought would be lynched today.

[worcej]

possibly off your teammates.*

Again with the shitty typos...

[Squigs44]

Well, looks like I missed a lot from my last show up. DrCJG's move is... very interesting. I look at it like this:

1. If he is a town PR, he is doing this because he knows Demon lied and we are getting closer to mylo.
2. If he is scum and we lynch, we can then get him the next day and still avoid mylo.

To me, I think he is the town version of this. Why? Because Demon probably had the weird idea at the last second to claim a PR and then suddenly he didn't die, now he has to follow through with that lie.

I really don't understand why people are voting for DrCJG. Town were dead until he made that claim. Now we are back in the hunt (we have a guaranteed scum kill at worst tomorrow). If he is scum, it just makes no sense for him to out himself like this today. Until he made the claim, scum were coasting to victory...

I agree - we are not at mylo or lylo, so if demon is town, by DrCJG showing he is scum, he doesn't outright win yet.

This is one of those moments that Squigs has solved something and you all sheep me. Dr is town, Demon is scum. No further questions.

Can't argue with you - you solved 2 games I know of.

##vote Demon

I am confident flash...

@Ghug
@Durga
@Bozo
@Worcej
@Bo

If you don't believe me then vote me... but don't let this become a last minute shuffle.

I don't see why you as scum would benefit from this lie and you are fairly confident. You have Squigs with you, so I am in as well, thus the vote above.

What I don't understand here is - what scum motivation did DemonRHK actually have for claiming his role today? If he is scum and he didn't claim his role, there would have been no chance of a CC as both the doctor and observer are still out there.

Demon - are you be absolutely sure you shared with us the right results from your observations? Can you double-check? Double-check with the GM?

I would have loudly advocated for his lynch without a specific claim, and I hope I wouldn't have been alone, so there's that.

Double quoting, because ghug also addressed the same thing I would've said in response to this.

How is it that everytime you do something, even when it is exactly what I want you to do, you find a way to do it in a way I find scummy.

[bo_sox48]

You idiots, IF WE MISLYNCH HERE IT’S ALMOST A LOCK FOR SCUM.

The box goes random immediately. Scum could pull a gun TONIGHT, pass a detonating box to town, and we’re FUCKED.

Yes, or town could pull a gun tonight and do something stupid lol

[ghug]

Squiggles, if this was just a reaction test, you should retract soon so that we have time to force people to vote meaningfully.

[ND]

I really don't think demon is scum. I am not going to vote for him.

[worcej]

The thing, worcej, is that a mislynch is a mislynch. There are four of them left right now. Trading one for one when you only need two more mislynches to win is a good trade for them. People were skeptical enough of RHK's claim to begin with that that would have appeared feasible. It makes even more sense if he's scummates with someone he thought would be lynched today.

Okay, so under that narrative he would have to be trying to save Damo right now.

[Foxcastle]

VOTE COUNT

DemonRHK (7) — DrCJG, flash2015, Squigs44, rdrivera2005, bozotheclown, damo666, worcej
DrCJG (3) — ND, DemonRHK, ghug
flash2015 (1) — Durga
ghug (1) — bo_sox48

DemonRHK is set to be lynched.

Less than 30 minutes remain in Day 5.

[worcej]

How is it that everytime you do something, even when it is exactly what I want you to do, you find a way to do it in a way I find scummy.

Because I am the scummiest town player you'll ever play with.

[bo_sox48]

Dr ran away so ##VOTE DrCJG

[worcej]

You idiots, IF WE MISLYNCH HERE IT’S ALMOST A LOCK FOR SCUM.

The box goes random immediately. Scum could pull a gun TONIGHT, pass a detonating box to town, and we’re FUCKED.

Yes, or town could pull a gun tonight and do something stupid lol

Or it could just be listed and handed off, or blow up now too, we have no idea what the box will do.

[Foxcastle]

##CALL GM - can you confirm that all, if any, PMs sent to RHK and Dr throughout this game have been correct?

##GM NOTE: As far as I know, all PMs sent this game have been correct.

[bo_sox48]

Thanks Fox.