Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Percy Williams]

Percy
Is a top read for me. Percy is playing a different games then the ones I have seen before. I haven’t really seen anything from Percy that has impressed me. He has kind of impressed me as a rising player on this website in previous games prompting me to townread him in those games. This game he has basically been MIA. NAI by itself, but when you look at him in the bigger picture he kind of is like Damo or Conner he has been coasting, not doing much, trying not to make waves. That’s the kind of play I would expect for someone playing scum. His votes have been Fox D4 so we can’t draw conclusions from that, Teacon D3 (town) over Xorxes, Espresso (town) D2, Bozo (town) D1. Important to note that out of this list so far both Percy and Damo chose to vote Teacon over Xorxes D3. Both also chose EP over ET D2. Who else voted for EP over ET? Balki and Xorxes.

This is straight up a lie. I voted for Xorxes Day 3 and was the second vote on him! I know that I've been busy so haven't helped town much, but and scum reading me needs to argue that Xorxes bussed me from almost the beginning of day one, and bussed me to his death bed, and that I bussed him before a wagon had really formed.

[FlaviusAetius]

I recommend you put your scumread of Fox down in your mind and concentrate on other candidates. It's what I am doing with ET. No one gives AF about ET so I am concentrating on other candidates.

I mean arent we all voting for damo tomorrow? We can focus on whoever the heck we want

[ND]

Percy I apologize. That is my mistake. I was looking at the metric and confused you with Peterlund. I guess because both names start with a P. I retract the vote metric point from my read.

[FlaviusAetius]

I did give an explanation - I want today to be fun.

By raise of hands who actually thinks the spreadsheet=obvtown Fox?

he already said he's done something similar as scum

No. You said that to throw shade and then never followed up, presumably hoping someone else would look into it. BECAUSE YOU ARE NOT SOLVING.

I pointed out how it was different.

Nor. Are. You.

[Durga]

actually you know who can read fox really well? tom.

what did tom bomb say before he died

He suspected FoxCastle as well, I need to know what made you switch

Teacon was being really annoying

[FlaviusAetius]

##VOTE FOXCASTLE

This is how serious I am that Durga needs to be considered as scum. AND THE REST OF YOU ARE NOT DOING THAT.

No she doesnt what are you even talking about, again with more accusations and NO actual cases my god

[FlaviusAetius]

actually you know who can read fox really well? tom.

what did tom bomb say before he died

He suspected FoxCastle as well, I need to know what made you switch

Teacon was being really annoying

That isnt a reason

[FlaviusAetius]

I voiced my suspicions early on. No one listens to my opinions though...

You make it so, so hard to do that, though, Chippe.

It's a pity if people let their personal opinions of me affect their reads of other people when I start pointing out the flaws in their gameplay.

Big Facts

[Percy Williams]

I'm coming around on Flav being scum again. His tunnel on Fox with 0 contribution or thoughts beyond that doesn't seem very townie to me. I don't see how he's trying to figure out the whole picture. I'd definitely be interested in flipping him after Fox and damo

And I dont understand how I cant push a scum and also still help solve the game Fox is guaranteed scum at this point, everyone needs to realize that...

Step back, how is Fox guaranteed scum? Please explain. And I don't want to hear the words "obvious" or "clearly", or any generalizations like "everyone". Just state evidence, Quote any relevant material, and show us how you got there, instead of just repeated your conclusion.
Thank you.

[FlaviusAetius]

wow interacting with chippe has really taught me how to control my temper. this is better than meditation

... Just stop

[FlaviusAetius]

I'm coming around on Flav being scum again. His tunnel on Fox with 0 contribution or thoughts beyond that doesn't seem very townie to me. I don't see how he's trying to figure out the whole picture. I'd definitely be interested in flipping him after Fox and damo

And I dont understand how I cant push a scum and also still help solve the game Fox is guaranteed scum at this point, everyone needs to realize that...

Step back, how is Fox guaranteed scum? Please explain. And I don't want to hear the words "obvious" or "clearly", or any generalizations like "everyone". Just state evidence, Quote any relevant material, and show us how you got there, instead of just repeated your conclusion.
Thank you.

Are you even reading the game? Did you even see my ISO on him? My ISO of his three days? My ISO on his votes? My ISO on literally every single dead towny suspecting him
SIGH

[Percy Williams]

Percy I apologize. That is my mistake. I was looking at the metric and confused you with Peterlund. I guess because both names start with a P. I retract the vote metric point from my read.

With that in mind, an I still a strong scum read for you? You are entirely allowed to, but I know your scum read of me factored into your read of the team (as it should), so I'm wondering if that changes your scum team reads.

[damo666]

Where's Connor? Missing as usual.

[ND]

Percy I apologize. That is my mistake. I was looking at the metric and confused you with Peterlund. I guess because both names start with a P. I retract the vote metric point from my read.

With that in mind, an I still a strong scum read for you? You are entirely allowed to, but I know your scum read of me factored into your read of the team (as it should), so I'm wondering if that changes your scum team reads.

It makes it a lot weaker.

[worcej]

NIGHT HAS ENDED, PLEASE HOLD.

[FlaviusAetius]

Judge is probably a town liability, but could be helpful in the right hands. don't forget that the bailiff started out knowing who the judge was, so that's a way to create clears.

@durga, if I made the case that it was someone not-durga that did it, would you consider whether or not Neph got played?

Wow I completely forgot about that lol

[worcej]

EON4 Flavor

Phoenix sat behind a desk in the courthouse, studying the evidence. He had made some breakthroughs in the case so far, but there were still several people to be found and put back into jail. If only he could crack the case…

Suddenly the door bursts open and a bailiff runs in. “Phoenix! We have a terrible situation!!!”

The bailiff runs off, Phoenix goes after him. They arrive in the courtroom to see the Judge, hanging dead from the rafters of the courtroom. On the Judge’s bench, the words “You can’t Judge anymore!” are painted in what looks to be blood, and on the ground near the bench is a dead lady. Phoenix walks over and examines the lady to find a familiar face.

“Wait a second…” Phoenix mutters “This is Lana Skye… I thought she was in jail…” He looks closely to see bite marks all over her and ultimately her throat slit.

Phoenix looks up into the courtroom, confused to see an old face he assumed was still in jail, and distraught knowing the current Judge is now dead...

Nephthys HAS DIED. HE WAS JUDGE, THE TOWN JUDGE!
peterlund HAS DIED. HE WAS Lana Skye, THE MAFIA FRAMER!

Day 5 has begun. You may now post.

[connorcompton]

I mean, well done BA. Wait, does this mean it's me or damo?

[Durga]

Omg!! BA MVP

[connorcompton]

No way did BA-damo fake claim roleblock.