M59 - Duck Season? - Game Thread

[summit_fever]

Ah, bozo. Full disclosure to all, I am totally down to off bozo on principle if people are interested. I don't care if I go next, still worth it.

This would be a horrible thing to do. I'd much rather principle-murder the low posters.

Horrible?

That is what I typed. Do you disagree?

[rdrivera2005]

Bozo? Thoughts? Maybe top 4 Town reads?

I will go along with whatever you want to ask for.

How about top for town?

Right now mine are:

Flum, Vecna, TRPrado, Rdr

This is an interesting choice. Could you explain why me and Prado? Vecna and Flum I can see some reasons.

[MoscowFleet]

Bozo is striking me as obvious scum, but the issue is that it was the same the last game I played with him. Gonna do my best for now to mentally block out his posts and focus elsewhere.

Foodcoats wagon seems meh. Seems to be the same as killing flash or gold or any of the other lurkers, and if he's town there's almost certainly one or two scum hiding on his wagon. Durga seems natural and I think her thoughts are flowing better compared to her scumgame. I have no desire to lynch worcej, kgray, or bunny for how active they've been, and kgray reads pretty strongly to me as town anyways.

I still don't like damo. He voted food for lurking, then doubles down after he shows up, which I think could be damo trying to keep the wagon together for a supposed legitimate reason, as it's likely it'll fall apart now that food has shown up and everyone on him was voting for lurking. ##Vote damo

The other person who seems scummy to me is macca. Calling HR very towny and bozo helpful are both fairly criminal imo.

Vecna seems really interested in getting someone to bite on calling me scummy, for what reason though isn't quite clear.

[rdrivera2005]

I think Kgray is completelly capable to fake his town meta, she did it last mini-game after I pushed her D1 for not been natural and giving bad reads.

This said, I think she is town this game and also summit and you. And probably Bunny.

I dont like thefourth and Moscow until now. I also don´t feel town Bozo, but I am usually wrong about him.

(Her)

Sorry. I should read whole post before correcting someone else’s pronouns. Clearly you know and had a typo.

It wasn´t a typo, just my bad english, lol. But I know it´s her.

[BunnyGo]

I will go along with whatever you want to ask for.

How about top for town?

Right now mine are:

Flum, Vecna, TRPrado, Rdr

This is an interesting choice. Could you explain why me and Prado? Vecna and Flum I can see some reasons.

Have you caught up to my explanation for Tom? Do you have 4?

[rdrivera2005]

I will go along with whatever you want to ask for.

How about top for town?

Right now mine are:

Flum, Vecna, TRPrado, Rdr

Fluminator, rdrivera, TrPrado, summit

Come on, I don´t want to die N1....

[MoscowFleet]

Also a couple people have called me out for demanding bozo's head. It was very obviously not serious, referencing how I'm still not over my last game with him.

[rdrivera2005]

If you thought his reasons were valid, I don't understand how you could townread Flum as well.

My top townreads are

Vecna - I do think he is misguided about Flum. Flum is pretty goofy, especially D1 - so the ridicule did not surprise me. But I think this is genuine hunting from Vecna.

hthefourth - Not afraid to share his thoughts as a relatively outsider among this group, especially contridicatory thoughts against the vocal opinions in the thread.

Moscow - I found his reactions to me early were both quick, natural and honest. I don't buy into his "over-explaining" being suspicious.

I guess I only really have three. I've liked kgray and Durga so far, but probably not enough yet to put them on this list

How can wee disagree so much on our reads of Moscow and hthefourth?
I think stating generic opinions like "there is a scum between top posters" and doing hockey comparisions a good way to seem usefull without really sticking his neck out.

[Durga]

Damo wagon is dumb imo. And this is coming from someone who always scum reads him

[TrPrado]

This would be a horrible thing to do. I'd much rather principle-murder the low posters.

Horrible?

That is what I typed. Do you disagree?

Can't disagree with a statement given without reason. What do you mean by horrible?

[Tom Bombadil]

If you thought his reasons were valid, I don't understand how you could townread Flum as well.

My top townreads are

Vecna - I do think he is misguided about Flum. Flum is pretty goofy, especially D1 - so the ridicule did not surprise me. But I think this is genuine hunting from Vecna.

hthefourth - Not afraid to share his thoughts as a relatively outsider among this group, especially contridicatory thoughts against the vocal opinions in the thread.

Moscow - I found his reactions to me early were both quick, natural and honest. I don't buy into his "over-explaining" being suspicious.

I guess I only really have three. I've liked kgray and Durga so far, but probably not enough yet to put them on this list

How can wee disagree so much on our reads of Moscow and hthefourth?
I think stating generic opinions like "there is a scum between top posters" and doing hockey comparisions a good way to seem usefull without really sticking his neck out.

I don't really think Moscow joke voting about hockey is him pretending to be useful, and you construing it that way is weird as hell.

I at least understand why we differ on hthefourth as my read of him is largely dependent on his defense of me when it was being tossed around that I was signaling traitor role to scum.

[rdrivera2005]

How about top for town?

Right now mine are:

Flum, Vecna, TRPrado, Rdr

This is an interesting choice. Could you explain why me and Prado? Vecna and Flum I can see some reasons.

Have you caught up to my explanation for Tom? Do you have 4?

I already listed my 4 in a post in page 26, but to avoid doubts:
Kgray, summit, Vecna and Bunny.

[Durga]

I don't really like food's gigantic reads posts. So unnatural. So planned out.

[kgray]

top 4 townreads given with day 1 confidence:

stronger:
bozo
bunny

weaker:
flum
vecna

Why is Bunny a strong townread?

[Durga]

Why is everyone listing four town reads. This is spam unless you have something substantive to say about them.

[kgray]

Also a couple people have called me out for demanding bozo's head. It was very obviously not serious, referencing how I'm still not over my last game with him.

Can you explain why you think he's obvious scum?

[rdrivera2005]

If you thought his reasons were valid, I don't understand how you could townread Flum as well.

My top townreads are

Vecna - I do think he is misguided about Flum. Flum is pretty goofy, especially D1 - so the ridicule did not surprise me. But I think this is genuine hunting from Vecna.

hthefourth - Not afraid to share his thoughts as a relatively outsider among this group, especially contridicatory thoughts against the vocal opinions in the thread.

Moscow - I found his reactions to me early were both quick, natural and honest. I don't buy into his "over-explaining" being suspicious.

I guess I only really have three. I've liked kgray and Durga so far, but probably not enough yet to put them on this list

How can wee disagree so much on our reads of Moscow and hthefourth?
I think stating generic opinions like "there is a scum between top posters" and doing hockey comparisions a good way to seem usefull without really sticking his neck out.

I don't really think Moscow joke voting about hockey is him pretending to be useful, and you construing it that way is weird as hell.

I at least understand why we differ on hthefourth as my read of him is largely dependent on his defense of me when it was being tossed around that I was signaling traitor role to scum.

The hockey reference I was thinking was from hthefourth (page 19), not Moscow.

[kgray]

If you thought his reasons were valid, I don't understand how you could townread Flum as well.

My top townreads are

Vecna - I do think he is misguided about Flum. Flum is pretty goofy, especially D1 - so the ridicule did not surprise me. But I think this is genuine hunting from Vecna.

hthefourth - Not afraid to share his thoughts as a relatively outsider among this group, especially contridicatory thoughts against the vocal opinions in the thread.

Moscow - I found his reactions to me early were both quick, natural and honest. I don't buy into his "over-explaining" being suspicious.

I guess I only really have three. I've liked kgray and Durga so far, but probably not enough yet to put them on this list

How can wee disagree so much on our reads of Moscow and hthefourth?
I think stating generic opinions like "there is a scum between top posters" and doing hockey comparisions a good way to seem usefull without really sticking his neck out.

I don't really think Moscow joke voting about hockey is him pretending to be useful, and you construing it that way is weird as hell.

I at least understand why we differ on hthefourth as my read of him is largely dependent on his defense of me when it was being tossed around that I was signaling traitor role to scum.

It seemed like he defended you before he realized that Bunny was suggesting you were signaling traitor.

[rdrivera2005]

I don't really like food's gigantic reads posts. So unnatural. So planned out.

I dislike it even more because he just ignored me on his reads. And included Gold and Flash, which make even less sense.

[Tom Bombadil]

How can wee disagree so much on our reads of Moscow and hthefourth?
I think stating generic opinions like "there is a scum between top posters" and doing hockey comparisions a good way to seem usefull without really sticking his neck out.

I don't really think Moscow joke voting about hockey is him pretending to be useful, and you construing it that way is weird as hell.

I at least understand why we differ on hthefourth as my read of him is largely dependent on his defense of me when it was being tossed around that I was signaling traitor role to scum.

It seemed like he defended you before he realized that Bunny was suggesting you were signaling traitor.

Ok. Maybe true, but that doesn't change my read. I don't see a situation where newbie scum would contradict the vocal opinion going on in thread. I start getting traction and then newb scum defends me seems unlikely.