7 TOWN, 3 SCUM
TOWN
- DRCJG - A slinky slink type, whose routinely high W/Post count leads people to think he doesn't post much.
- Jamie -
- Seems very relaxed compared to usual... he got a little frustrated "defending Worcej," but otherwise he gave logical arguments and appeared to be taking in information from all sources rather than tunneling.
- Xorxes was off wagon when Jamie moved Damo to Xorxes and made it 4-3 Damo-Xorxes... scum!Jamie could have trusted scum!Xorxes to vote for self preservation... but several other people should have been around at EOD that could have jumped on Xorxes and all in all it seems like it would have been far to big of a risk for the reward... therefore I assume if Jamie is scum then Xorxes is not.
- RagingIke - With so little said, it is hard to have much of a feeling... but I thought his calling out of Jamie's vote as invalid in the final minute was a towny move. I also thought his exchange with Xorxes and reasoning for voting Xorxes was sound.
- Bozo -
- Extended discussion about mechanics can be scum indicative, but more so after D1. I found his hypoclaim and nolynch suggestions to be genuine, though it did slide towards more of polling and less of arguing merits.
- Brainbomb - The lack of tension between him and Jamie... or really anyone is surprising, but I am trying to keep it NAI as BB is clearly skilled enough to change styles and not always play the role of aggravating PR hunter. I have to believe he really missed EOD... because I would be willing to bet everyone a large supreme papa john's pizza that town!Brain would not have sat on Ike at the end of that day... speaking of his strange bets... his repetition of "im not wolf... with X" does look scummy, but again I think is just BB being... BB.
- foodcoats -
- I was reading him as town and a new player that I just generally disagreed with, but as I start to feel like he is more experienced I am starting to get a scum vibe from him like he is being pretty calculated with his posts.
- Was on the Damo wagon... and I do hope that wasn't a town only wagon
- Nephthys
- Despite foods claim that Neph is focused and aggressive, I find Neph to have been quite blendy... he didn't take any unpopular opinions... didnt push anyone.. and seemed to flitter between discussions and follow up with polite requests for elaboration
- Voted Damo to encourage discussion… when in face he pushed the wagon to 5-1 (granted almost 24hrs before EOD), but doesn’t mention Damo again until 3 mins before EOD to question why Damo wouldn’t defend himself and that he would be willing to move off Damo… reads as trying to prepare for Damo flipping town.
- Worcej –
- Most of D1 he spent defending rather silly accusations and I initially scumread him for failing to ignore it and add substance to other discussions… but he responded well to questions closer to the end of the day.
- Found his reasoning for voting Damo (to pressure him and then because he thinks Damo is dumb) to be foolish and poor play… but genuine… at the same time I would have expected town!worcej to engage with me at EOD regarding Damo’s absence and the lack of movement and consider another wagon given he admitted to having no read on Damo.
- I also find it suspicious that his counter wagon to Damo evaporated early. I voted him with 4 hours left to make it 4-3 Damo – Worcej. It seems others were critical of him and yet it stalled… for now I attribute it to him providing good answers/comments at the end of the day… but it was shot down early enough that he wasn’t in jeopardy in the final minutes.
- thdfrance
- Joins a vote on Worcej at the request of Damo then 2 posts and 24 hours later votes Damo stating he doesn't have any strong feelings but likes the arguments made on Damo and will park his vote there
- It’s a scummy way to vote and he followed it by claiming he is going to post full read lists, but doesn’t show up until 7 mins after EOD to say that he isn’t scum and that he doesn’t have a ton to contribute….
- Xorxes -
- Was reading closely enough to mock Jamie's misread of BB and the use of "rather" ... but provided superficial comments and questions
- Awkward accusation/pressure of Worcej to hardclaim town... not sure what he was really going for... scum!Xorxes could be trying to bus teammate? set up bozo? smear Worcej? ... town!Xorxes could just be being an idiot? I think Xorxes is better than that.
- My vote on him was my first attempt to get a true counter wagon to Damo making it 4-3 Damo-Xorxes. Brain left 30 mins later, Jamie with 6 hours left in the day. His defensiveness and aggression towards my vote seems scummy to me (but I am certainly bias and should watch myself for tunneling).
- If Xorxes is town, at least he may have drawn enough heat to not get fear killed N1.
- I understood his vote on Ike to be largely a joke/pressure... but he remained... he accused Worcej of knowing Damo would flip town... but only offered to vote me (which he didn't do even though if he scum read me and wanted to form a counter wagon then voting me made far more sense then remaining on Ike). Unlike BB who may have been gone at EOD... Xorxes clearly wasn't... and I don't think town!Xorxes would have let the day end that quietly.
@ Worcej - You never answered my question about what other wagon you would have liked to see formed to counter Damo. Do you think we can read into the struggles to form a counter wagon or do you think we have to chalk it up to a lack of EOD presence?
@ Xorxes - Why did you stay on Ike at the end of the day? You vocally scum read me more and Ike wasn't going anywhere and hadn't said enough to be a realistic counter wagon.
