Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Percy Williams]

I'm putting my vote on
##Xorxes
For two main reasons:
1. His posting is not conducive to his posting as town.
2. He's mainly focused on me all game providing little discussion on anyone besides me.

[Squigs44]

The only problem with Xorxes playing like this is that even as scum he isn't this bad. He's probably trying to get lynched at this point. Must be one of the useless scum PRs or goon.

[ChippeRock]

Oh God this thread was so much nicer without chippe :'(

When I wasn't pointing out that you weren't providing detailed analyses of your top scumreads?

[Balki Bartokomous]

Okay, I gotta run.

I still think all PRs should out and play in the open. But certainly, all townies need to freaking tryhard and make their alignment obvious. This is a big one.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Oh God this thread was so much nicer without chippe :'(

When I wasn't pointing out that you weren't providing detailed analyses of your top scumreads?

Just stop it.

Seriously -- you're both town. Stop it!

[ChippeRock]

I'm putting my vote on
##Xorxes
For two main reasons:
1. His posting is not conducive to his posting as town.
2. He's mainly focused on me all game providing little discussion on anyone besides me.

The vote doesn't actually count unless you

##VOTE xorxes

(quoted to avoid changing my vote).

[ChippeRock]

Oh God this thread was so much nicer without chippe :'(

When I wasn't pointing out that you weren't providing detailed analyses of your top scumreads?

Just stop it.

Seriously -- you're both town. Stop it!

Perhaps that's true, but there's at least a small decent chance that she's scum.

[Balki Bartokomous]

When I wasn't pointing out that you weren't providing detailed analyses of your top scumreads?

Just stop it.

Seriously -- you're both town. Stop it!

Perhaps that's true, but there's at least a small decent chance that she's scum.

She's like the towniest town in all of townsville.

[Percy Williams]

This is trying to fit in 101. Any townperson would read the last 15 pages before contributing. Things can change quickly and to do things just because theyve been promised...

Any Townsperson with TIME would. I was unexpectedly busy for the past couple days.Also as a Town, I don't want to make promises I don't keep as that makes me suspicious looking, and a Town gets lynched. I also wanted these questions to restructure the way we're looking at the game, to try and make some headway.

@Percy, theres only one left now. Wanna share?

It's about one of the town Prs left, sooo no.

You originally stated you would only do it when they were all dead now it only relates to the one left? That's scummy af

Then why did you you ask?
And if there is only one left they aren't all dead are they. And I wouldn't say which pr it was bad to die for me to reveal was I was trying to do to prevent scum from figuring out what I was doing. Ask me WHEN THEY'RE ALL DEAD. I'm not going to give the Mafia any information.

[Durga]

I don't understand this discussion between Neph and Percy. What is Percy talking about? What is he hiding?

[ChippeRock]

Just stop it.

Seriously -- you're both town. Stop it!

Perhaps that's true, but there's at least a small decent chance that she's scum.

She's like the towniest town in all of townsville.

With here lack of detailed reads and explanations behind her votes, I can feel so confident she's town... Like, WTF?

[Durga]

Percy please immediately explain what you're doing. The PR's are officially irrelevant and I want to hear this.

[Percy Williams]

Can you give me three bullet points on why you think Percy is scum? And I thought you said that a Xorx flip unravels more.

- PR hunting and BA hunting
- Above with little attempts at solving
- Hedgy play with the other whom I believe to be sum

A xorxes flip provides more although I think Percy is more likely. A Percy flip increases my xorx read which then allows me to be fully happy lynching him. I suppose I would lunch xorx today but would prefer percy.

You think I'm bussing Percy? I'm fine with that.

Only scum Xorxes is fine with this. I
If its Town Xorxes, then he knows we can't afford the misogyny on him even if he's certain I'm scum.

If it's scum xorxes, all he needs for scum to win is one town mislynch, and this relationship setup suggests that if/when I flip town, Xorxes was not bussing me and is town, which would put a scum xorxes in the clear.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Any Townsperson with TIME would. I was unexpectedly busy for the past couple days.Also as a Town, I don't want to make promises I don't keep as that makes me suspicious looking, and a Town gets lynched. I also wanted these questions to restructure the way we're looking at the game, to try and make some headway.

It's about one of the town Prs left, sooo no.

You originally stated you would only do it when they were all dead now it only relates to the one left? That's scummy af

Then why did you you ask?
And if there is only one left they aren't all dead are they. And I wouldn't say which pr it was bad to die for me to reveal was I was trying to do to prevent scum from figuring out what I was doing. Ask me WHEN THEY'RE ALL DEAD. I'm not going to give the Mafia any information.

Okay, bullshit.

Percy, you just openly speculated about who is the Innocent Child like two pages ago. What are you talking about?

[xorxes]

Also @durga @balki

What do you make of the weak case xorx made on Percy. I don't see how that can't be busssing

How was it weak for what we had available on D1?

[Durga]

Also @durga @balki

What do you make of the weak case xorx made on Percy. I don't see how that can't be busssing

How was it weak for what we had available on D1?

ok xorx. you have like a billion things available now!! solve the goddamn game for me thx

[Percy Williams]

I'm putting my vote on
##Xorxes
For two main reasons:
1. His posting is not conducive to his posting as town.
2. He's mainly focused on me all game providing little discussion on anyone besides me.

The vote doesn't actually count unless you

##VOTE xorxes

(quoted to avoid changing my vote).

Thanks, I was too busy thinking octothorpe as I voted.
##VOTE XORXES.

[xorxes]

Also @durga @balki

What do you make of the weak case xorx made on Percy. I don't see how that can't be busssing

Well, I mean, his whole game has been weak.

I am just looking at it from a perspective of camaraderie. I could see Xorxes bussing a teammate. But not just doing it all day long and into the next day, especially with a newer teammate (I'm assuming Percy is pretty new, is that right?). It does not fit, to me.

I don't think I have ever bussed as scum before, so if I was scum and bussing it would be a new experience for me. I'm not though.

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Percy, your stance is that you don't want to say something about something from Day 1 because it will tell scum something about our PRs. But three pages ago you said this:

I believe Chills is town. I think he would pretend to be more agreeable as scum. It just occurred to me, what if chippe was crumbing that he was innocent child, ergo Proving he is (Now) a vanilla town.

Please explain.

[Percy Williams]

You originally stated you would only do it when they were all dead now it only relates to the one left? That's scummy af

Then why did you you ask?
And if there is only one left they aren't all dead are they. And I wouldn't say which pr it was bad to die for me to reveal was I was trying to do to prevent scum from figuring out what I was doing. Ask me WHEN THEY'RE ALL DEAD. I'm not going to give the Mafia any information.

Okay, bullshit.

Percy, you just openly speculated about who is the Innocent Child like two pages ago. What are you talking about?

You mean the throwaway line about Chippe crumbling innocent child?
Please!
1. How do you know that that line of wasn't part of my strategy?
2. Even if the Pr I'm trying to cloud has been claimed, I'm not going to reveal information that could help scum find the real PR if they are choosing to remain anonymous.
3. Why do you think I would explain without all of them being dead or the game being over as I originally said?