M1028: The Sweet Food Consensus - Game Thread

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I was going to be paranoid of you this game no matter what you did also. And you went ahead and did about the scummiest things you could do right out the gate. So for me to change my mind on you being town means tonally you are just not scum this time around

uh.. thanks?

[brainbomb]

I figure damo is town as well because he is already annoying me

[brainbomb]

kak could be mafia. thats one of those coin flip kinda things. I have to just sort of guess with him because he is always so ethereal

[brainbomb]

ghug is a slight scumlean. I dont understand the ghug, or why he does votes as if they are trophies to hand out. It makes it hard to discern between authentic scumreads and jokes. I find this sort of behavior to be unecessary character fluffing, and it justifies his own weirdness at end of days of flitting around mindlessly from popular wagon to popular wagon.

Stay tuned on if any of this matters. As with all things my mood changes and mind changes.

So my scumleans are like
kak, ghug, maybe jamie though his explanations are...eh

townleans
damo, will

nulls
non posters

and then theres D&W, racing to find a course of action. No idea what to think of this, but my mind goes to worst case scenarios for town and trying to put myself in the shoes of "what if hes"? and I dont wanna go that route just yet.

Jamie is totally justified in thinking it was scummy. because its not very normal?

I dont know what it means, and he will probably be a popular wagon all day especially if his participation levels stay low like he normally does

[Kakarroto]

@Kak games usually start on a Monday evening and I tend to be unavailable.

alright, fair, I think I remember you have some things monday going, though what was it again? pub quiz night?

still, you didn't think that pressuring worcej might cause him to claim if he is PR? That is just atypical of the damo that openly is against any slightest comments that might give mafia the edge in PR hunting. This feels more like mafia damo trying to use a joke to get info so to out a PR or make the pool for it smaller.

[Kakarroto]

your flow is alot less agendified than previous chaotic evil will

Hehe chaotic evil

do you mean, mayhaps, chaotic e-Will?

[Kakarroto]

kak could be mafia. thats one of those coin flip kinda things. I have to just sort of guess with him because he is always so ethereal

I guess I'm a good scan candidate, since we have no godfather, right? hm, RD would be a good one too, I guess. Maybe just flip me D1 as I suggested in sign ups

[Kakarroto]

but from the whole dispute, I feel like jamie and will aren't mafia together, so if either flips that, the other should be clear. Looks more like t v t to me though. Then again, I've misread jamie early and was blinded, so maybe brain is just right here.

hmm, if jamie is mafia here, would maf brain do this gamble? a full buss this early?

what I'm confused at, how can brain put damo into town here? @brain please elaborate, I think that's much more in the ballpark of maf damo, trying to set up an early claim or being able to remove worcej from a 'possible PR' list. Or am I wrong here?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

kak could be mafia. thats one of those coin flip kinda things. I have to just sort of guess with him because he is always so ethereal

I guess I'm a good scan candidate, since we have no godfather, right? hm, RD would be a good one too, I guess. Maybe just flip me D1 as I suggested in sign ups

Let me bus you please

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

but from the whole dispute, I feel like jamie and will aren't mafia together, so if either flips that, the other should be clear. Looks more like t v t to me though. Then again, I've misread jamie early and was blinded, so maybe brain is just right here.

hmm, if jamie is mafia here, would maf brain do this gamble? a full buss this early?

what I'm confused at, how can brain put damo into town here? @brain please elaborate, I think that's much more in the ballpark of maf damo, trying to set up an early claim or being able to remove worcej from a 'possible PR' list. Or am I wrong here?

I think Jamie may be mafia

[Kakarroto]

kak could be mafia. thats one of those coin flip kinda things. I have to just sort of guess with him because he is always so ethereal

I guess I'm a good scan candidate, since we have no godfather, right? hm, RD would be a good one too, I guess. Maybe just flip me D1 as I suggested in sign ups

Let me bus you please

sad bus.png (30.69 KiB) Viewed 140 times

[brainbomb]

Its a bit much to think damo is a mastermind who is gonna push PR worcej to claim here.

worcej is not posting, its a perfectly reasonable person to vote in RVS. finding nefarious motive behind the move seems a little bit reachy. damo has been around, has posted, has voted, and articulated total disinterest in anything that jamie said was content. He didnt have any interest in will, or jamie or myself in any of that.

scum damo would probably not even have anything to do with any of it.

the only scum pair that would make sense is if jamie and damo were scum and the whole thing about bank notes and bonds was to look like they are disconnected and fluff the thread with crap.

and nah. I dont think it was that. damo is more of a behind the scenes evildoer, not a forward early game mastermind. he is a good PR hunter at night as scum, and by day just hides

[ghug]

I think we should ask the real important question here. Like:

-) if we change the tomato sauce into ketchup, would a pizza become a sweet fruit pie?

-) is a cake filled and garnished with carrots a sweet dish?

-) why is damo, who's normally absent in the joke phase and a proponent of anti-bad townplay, suddenly voting the player who is a great PR but also prone to easily claim?

yeah, I don't like it a bit. ##vote damo

I don't think replacing tomato sauce with ketchup really moves pizza on the sweet/savory spectrum. Both are sweet and typically eaten in savory contexts.

Carrot cake is obviously sweet.

[brainbomb]

if damo is town the best thing I can do for myself, is to speak coherently, and loud enough to make other players actually listen. I know from experience that no matter how artful, accurate or factual my scum pushes are, he simply will go his own way and disregard it all as brainbombisms.

[ghug]

It's probably just worcej/Kak.

ok, a bit confused here, do you mean Will + one of worcej/me or that the team is 'only' wor and me? Because I can guarantee you that the latter would be wrong

ah well, I guess you can't make a cake without breaking some eggs and stuff anyway

Sad I caught you?

[ghug]

##VOTE Will

Ghug, you silly old space cube.

Did you deliberately post this vote in an invalid format, or did you not realise?

I wanted to call him Will.

[Kakarroto]

Its a bit much to think damo is a mastermind who is gonna push PR worcej to claim here.

worcej is not posting, its a perfectly reasonable person to vote in RVS. finding nefarious motive behind the move seems a little bit reachy. damo has been around, has posted, has voted, and articulated total disinterest in anything that jamie said was content. He didnt have any interest in will, or jamie or myself in any of that.

scum damo would probably not even have anything to do with any of it.

the only scum pair that would make sense is if jamie and damo were scum and the whole thing about bank notes and bonds was to look like they are disconnected and fluff the thread with crap.

and nah. I dont think it was that. damo is more of a behind the scenes evildoer, not a forward early game mastermind. he is a good PR hunter at night as scum, and by day just hides

hmm. I guess I still have a subconscious grudge against him being the reason for my last getting D1ed. that's pretty good reasoning.

hmm ... maybe I should just trust you in this. ##vote jamie

[ghug]

Only 5 pages is kinda silly. Already 12 hours into the game

Well, it's a small game. There are only 7 of us.

1. Jamiet99uk
2. JustAGuyNamedWill
3. ghug
4. worcej
5. Diplomacy&Warfare
6. Rdrivera2005
7. Damo666
8. brainbomb
9. Kakarroto

Oh brain, you walked right into that one...

[brainbomb]

Well, it's a small game. There are only 7 of us.

1. Jamiet99uk
2. JustAGuyNamedWill
3. ghug
4. worcej
5. Diplomacy&Warfare
6. Rdrivera2005
7. Damo666
8. brainbomb
9. Kakarroto

Oh brain, you walked right into that one...

Okay so you endorse that Jamie was laying some absurdist trap to catch will?

[ghug]

Regarding participation?

the topic of this was who was active, and why there were so many pages.

there are 7 town, and this has nothing to do with the page count or participation levels up to now.

there are only 9 players, in the context of why the game was so silent would have at least painted a full picture.

I am not sure if this statement by you assumes that the 7 town have done all the talking so far and the mafia have not even posted yet- which if true seems to contradict your logic on D&W. So that cant be what you were trying to imply.

Explain?

Sigh.

You are a very uppity Beancomb today aren't you?

What I was trying to do was bait a reply from Will (to whom my deliberately inaccurate comment was addressed), but you decided to jump in.

But… you responded with “oh, I meant my team”

As in you made a genuine error in what you meant to say

How did Jamie manage to turn two other people into Jamie?