Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[BunnyGo]

1. Unlikely
2. Scum withheld the RB to confuse, weakscum unnecessarily RBd their NK, Ham was RBd but for some reason hasn't told us (I doubt that last one)
3. If Ham were scum surely the scumteam would have agreed he claim Roleblock

I think you’re wrong.

But let’s continue.


You seem to strongly believe we’re in scenario 2. What can we conclude about the scum team? Include the fact that ghug (and probably Jamie) were RBd night 1.

Most plausible scenario

brain RBd Jamie N1
scum RBd ghug N1

N2 scum stupidly RBd gugh again despite the fact they were NKing him or withheld to confuse. Assuming the latter they could have motive whether Ham is town or scum however if Ham were scum surely the easier course would be to have Ham claim RB.

Scum are either devious or weak.

Ok.

Combining that analysis with D1 and D2 voting, what teams do you think are plausible if:

Devious

Or

Weak?

[damo666]

I think you’re wrong.

But let’s continue.


You seem to strongly believe we’re in scenario 2. What can we conclude about the scum team? Include the fact that ghug (and probably Jamie) were RBd night 1.

Most plausible scenario

brain RBd Jamie N1
scum RBd ghug N1

N2 scum stupidly RBd gugh again despite the fact they were NKing him or withheld to confuse. Assuming the latter they could have motive whether Ham is town or scum however if Ham were scum surely the easier course would be to have Ham claim RB.

Scum are either devious or weak.

Ok.

Combining that analysis with D1 and D2 voting, what teams do you think are plausible if:

Devious

Or

Weak?

I'm not gonna be that specific. I'll post likely teams in a mo but without the D/W classification. I'm not that rude.

[damo666]

LoW Vecna worcej

[Vecna]

i dont really have a lot of time for mafia today again sadly, but I guess i should vote elsewhere.

I dont particularly care for voting LoW or bozo. Im not so inclined to vote sweet anymore either.

Its a bit of a pickle if im reading this situation correctly.

[Vecna]

##vote worcej

[Vecna]

no rb claims today?

[damo666]

no rb claims today?

No. What do you make of that?

[kingofthepirates]

Testing done for now, anything major I missed? If not I’ll take my time catching up and nothing anything at finds my attention.

[Bonatogether]

we have an "outed cop" with no scans. fundamentally this is not pro-town. either hambone needs to claim scans, with no messing around with 'oh i sort of softed bongo but not really', or he needs to be voted off the island

[damo666]

Testing done for now, anything major I missed? If not I’ll take my time catching up and nothing anything at finds my attention.

Not really, mainly discussion re Ham and why we've had no RB claim.

[Bonatogether]

i promise i'll key in again when there's no more mechs talk

[damo666]

we have an "outed cop" with no scans. fundamentally this is not pro-town. either hambone needs to claim scans, with no messing around with 'oh i sort of softed bongo but not really', or he needs to be voted off the island

[damo666]

i promise i'll key in again when there's no more mechs talk

Well only play vanilla only games then.

Mech mech mechy mech!

[damo666]

I'll be more or less gone now.

[Bonatogether]

i promise i'll key in again when there's no more mechs talk

Well only play vanilla only games then.

Mech mech mechy mech!

literally that would be heaven-sent

[kingofthepirates]

Testing done for now, anything major I missed? If not I’ll take my time catching up and nothing anything at finds my attention.

Not really, mainly discussion re Ham and why we've had no RB claim.

Gotcha. No RB is really weird, scum is either up to something super devious, or they messed up hard, or they’re pretty stupid for not using the RB. Regarding ham, I ve thought it over slightly and am currently considering swapping my vote over there. The reasoning is starting to bug me ngl. Not the best vibes.

[Spartaculous]

Testing done for now, anything major I missed? If not I’ll take my time catching up and nothing anything at finds my attention.

Not really, mainly discussion re Ham and why we've had no RB claim.

Gotcha. No RB is really weird, scum is either up to something super devious, or they messed up hard, or they’re pretty stupid for not using the RB. Regarding ham, I ve thought it over slightly and am currently considering swapping my vote over there. The reasoning is starting to bug me ngl. Not the best vibes.

But then you have to explain why Ham was left off of Will's Day 1 reads.

[kingofthepirates]

Not really, mainly discussion re Ham and why we've had no RB claim.

Gotcha. No RB is really weird, scum is either up to something super devious, or they messed up hard, or they’re pretty stupid for not using the RB. Regarding ham, I ve thought it over slightly and am currently considering swapping my vote over there. The reasoning is starting to bug me ngl. Not the best vibes.

But then you have to explain why Ham was left off of Will's Day 1 reads.

A play? Perhaps will is clever enough to do this intentionally??? Idk if that’s something will would do though. And it gets into the circular argument that I’m not in the mood to deal with. Idk know though ((((

[Lord of Words]

i dont really have a lot of time for mafia today again sadly, but I guess i should vote elsewhere.

I dont particularly care for voting LoW or bozo. Im not so inclined to vote sweet anymore either.

Its a bit of a pickle if im reading this situation correctly.

You can literally vote for Ham, who there is strong case for.

Bozo, you can sheep us.

I'm doubtful we can get a wagon on Sweet or Damo, but Ham is way too sus.

I'd also love to hear the reasoning for train on me.

[sweetandcool]

Testing done for now, anything major I missed? If not I’ll take my time catching up and nothing anything at finds my attention.

Not really, mainly discussion re Ham and why we've had no RB claim.

Gotcha. No RB is really weird, scum is either up to something super devious, or they messed up hard, or they’re pretty stupid for not using the RB. Regarding ham, I ve thought it over slightly and am currently considering swapping my vote over there. The reasoning is starting to bug me ngl. Not the best vibes.

The argument about Ham not being RB indicating he is scum is silly.

Sure, Mafia "takes a risk" by not RB the Clerk claimant. However, Ham's acting D2 was so exquisitely poor that Mafia probably thought there was zero chance he was Clerk.

They still could have RB, just in case, but wouldn't it just be better to drive home the MK by withholding it and making Ham look incredibly suspicious?

And if Ham is Mafia, why not just claim RB? There is literally no reason.