Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[damo666]

I'm coming round to the unexpected busser theory but who?

[damo666]

And I've changed my mind about food, I have come to the conclusion he's town.

[Lord of Words]

LoW

I suspect the "reread 3 times" is out of date and explains the scumread of deadtown. Continuing to do so indicates being a long way behind.

This is giving him the benefit of the doubt.

When he next posts I want him to declare whether he was has caught up. Ofc if he hasn't he may not have read this so if there is no such declaration please badger him to say how far he has read to.

Once caught up I'd like to see a revised readlist.

Sparta - townpoints for that analysis.

I'm going to reread it the bot this time, but I'm going to ask either making a mistake or this being ploy puts me as scum in any world, especially it has put a wagon on me. I'm stating this generally for everyone.

I'm prioritizing this morning's posts, however.

[rdrivera2005]

Ok, finally catched up and even have time to look a bit at VCA.

I think Bona and Sweet are town, can´t see they bussing this way the GF with planty chance to bail out. Until half and hour they are the only votes on Will and probably any of them moving out will kill the wagon. Then I voted and I know I am town. Then king voted, he need to cast a vote as he was on unvote, so it could be a buss. Same is valid for Worcej, Bunny and Ghug, so I am not giving a pass for any of them because of this vote.

I also believe Ghug and Jamiet RB claims as I don´t remember Mafia ever making a a fake RB claim here. The one that wasn´t roleblocked by BB is town, the question is which as I can see Brain Jailing both. Anyway, not willing to vote any of them.

I think both newbies are good wagons, for different reasons. Lord isn´t really puting any real effort and even thinking is a kind of a coin flip I don´t think having him at the end is a good choice. Sparta on the other side is playing but seems to be more focused in surviving then catching scum, which is usually a scum tell.

I also suspect Bozo because his play today isn´t what I expect from town Bozo. Picking small things from Ghug, being obnoxius and not voting isn´t his town meta.

##vote Bozo

Well, nitpicking me is his town meta, to be fair. I can't remember many times he's townread me.

Well, you can say it better then me. To me the only thing that isn´t on Bozo scum meta his game is he isn´t tunneling anyone.

[Jamiet99uk]

##Unend

I notice that I have pressured Lord of Words into singing.

I shall need some time to interpret his song.

[Jamiet99uk]

Seriously, here is a player who has told us that he is an experienced Mafia player on other forums.

He has not indicated that he has any problems logging in or posting.

Most of his posts, it remains, are about promising to post in the future, which he continues to avoid doing.

VOTE HIM PLEASE

With respect, if I was scum, life happens, but wouldn't it be weird for me to miss a vote, especially one where my alleged teammate was on the chopping block? And conspicuously being absent wouldn't accrue to my benefit either.

So, why did you forget to vote?

(Maybe a later post will answer this, I'm just reading...)

[damo666]

LoW

I suspect the "reread 3 times" is out of date and explains the scumread of deadtown. Continuing to do so indicates being a long way behind.

This is giving him the benefit of the doubt.

When he next posts I want him to declare whether he was has caught up. Ofc if he hasn't he may not have read this so if there is no such declaration please badger him to say how far he has read to.

Once caught up I'd like to see a revised readlist.

Sparta - townpoints for that analysis.

I'm going to reread it the bot this time, but I'm going to ask either making a mistake or this being ploy puts me as scum in any world, especially it has put a wagon on me. I'm stating this generally for everyone.

I'm prioritizing this morning's posts, however.

Your wagon was due to lack of activity. The mistake is bizarre. It can be read as a ploy - "I don't know what's going on, I can't possibly therefore be scum."

You have about 8 hours to redeem yourself.

[Jamiet99uk]

Just checking, but we can link screenshots here, yes?

It would save me the trouble of linking Will's read list here and speed things up for me. I've reread this thread three times now and I'm not really trying to hunt for it on mobile.

You are allowed to post images but you are not allowed to screenshot any private messages from the GM or anything like that.

[damo666]

##unvote

[Jamiet99uk]

I feel like this is the first game where I’ve seen the use of “anchor.” What is that?

I provided a detailed explanation.

You give the impression you are not reading the game.

[rdrivera2005]

Is town!bozo usually this useless?


@bozo: has there been some irl changes for you?

I wouldn’t call him worthless, just tunneling randomly

He comes across as what I would expect from detective Bozo.

At this very moment perhaps he is being a bit annoying about a thing or two, but I don't understand why anyone would seriously vote him for it. I guess bunny is tunneled but I don't get rdr's vote.

Because Bozo usually have teeth when he is town and investigating, he asks and pushes and make cases. Here he is just asking questions but isn´t folowing, isn´t pushing and it looks like as he is just trying to mimick his town play. Look at his ISO. He started the day asking a lot of questions. People answerered and he juist said "Ok", to most of the answers.

[Jamiet99uk]

Read my posts! I want attention.

Here, Balki. Have a biscuit.

[Hamilton Brian]

I feel like this is the first game where I’ve seen the use of “anchor.” What is that?

I provided a detailed explanation.

You give the impression you are not reading the game.

I kind of wasn't; had about an hour spent on D1 and this D up to this point. Today should be a bit better.

[Jamiet99uk]

Sorry this took a bit to type; between work and some personal stuff I had a bit more than planned this week. Let just say that off the bat.

< Snip long reads list>

Finally something of substance, thank you.

[Jamiet99uk]

Foodcoats is the player I’m suspicious of because he was advocating for Will until the last minute at the end of Day 1. Other than that, I don’t have too much on him at the moment.

Wait a moment.

He re-read the thread three times and yet Foodcoats is alive in his read list?

Hmmmmmmm.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'll generate further reads on the remaining three players, but I feel confident enough in Vecna, Bozo, and Bunny to put that off for the morning.

That's an awful lot of town reads.

Could you tell me more about your opinion on Food and damo's connection?

Intelligent questioning from Sweet.

[damo666]

I feel like this is the first game where I’ve seen the use of “anchor.” What is that?

I provided a detailed explanation.

You give the impression you are not reading the game.

I kind of wasn't; had about an hour spent on D1 and this D up to this point. Today should be a bit better.

Read list when you've caught up please.

[Jamiet99uk]

DrFidelis, I’m having some trouble reading at the moment, so I’m really going to asking them direct questions for the remainder of the today to home in on them.

Uh. And this as well.

Good luck getting DrFidelis to answer your questions given that he subbed out over 48 hours ago and his replacement was killed by the Mafia.

[Bonatogether]

Well, I wanted to organize my thoughts around how the bee sting affair could happen. So I found I could not come up with a reason as to why Town would claim the kill. However, I found that Mafia may decide to claim it. Combined with the fact that it was so conveniently awful, it made me think damo was Mafia.

the post in question has a model of a town player who plays to survive by refusing to claim in order to avoid flak, and a model of a scum player who seeks towncredit by claiming it. how does that make sense? would not a scum player seek to mimic the town play, and could not a town player seek to be honest about mistakes?

it just seems to me a pre-fitted conclusion with warped logic

Well, you're right.

My logic around the RB was poor on multiple occasions. Which I recanted after hearing more from others.

I was also mad at damo and wanted to scumread him at the time, so my warped logic was biased against him from the start. It's unsurprising I managed to reach the poor conclusion that I did.

I didn't do it because I was scum, I made these mistakes because I was emotional and fog brained. Evidence of this is that I didn't end up campaigning for damo's death. Scum sweetandcool would absolutely be doing so, unless damo happened to be my teammate.

i don't understand the thought process behind this

[Jamiet99uk]

Oh man. I missed this wagon was full.

##vote Balki

"I missed this wagon was full"... what does that even begin to mean?

Why are you voting Balki here?