I'm honestly wondering (and I don't want to drag this out, but I think it's important for the game in general): by the narrow definition of government, who would be considered famous for government, but not politics?Aristocrat wrote: ↑Mon Apr 29, 2024 6:26 pmIf you are going to take shots at least take them correctly. No one disputes that NASA is a government agency. The silliness is considering an astronaut famous for something to do with government.
20 Questions - Game 272
Forum rules
This is an area for forum games. Please note that to support mafia games players cannot edit their own posts in this forum. Off Topic threads will be relocated or deleted. Issues taking place in forum games should be dealt with by respective game GMs and escalated to the moderators only if absolutely necessary.
This is an area for forum games. Please note that to support mafia games players cannot edit their own posts in this forum. Off Topic threads will be relocated or deleted. Issues taking place in forum games should be dealt with by respective game GMs and escalated to the moderators only if absolutely necessary.
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
-
- Posts: 999
- Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2020 6:09 pm
- Contact:
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
So, apologies to everyone for taking the bait initially, but since you asked and maybe this can turn into something more productive than relitigating old games:Hominidae wrote: ↑Mon Apr 29, 2024 6:41 pmI'm honestly wondering (and I don't want to drag this out, but I think it's important for the game in general): by the narrow definition of government, who would be considered famous for government, but not politics?Aristocrat wrote: ↑Mon Apr 29, 2024 6:26 pmIf you are going to take shots at least take them correctly. No one disputes that NASA is a government agency. The silliness is considering an astronaut famous for something to do with government.
Personally, I think there are multiple broad categories of people (judges, directors of most government agencies, diplomats and other civil servants who focus on actual government, police commissioners, etc.) that would fall into "famous for government" but not "famous for politics," provided its not someone like Hillary Clinton that is firmly famous for both ends of the spectrum.
Then the area of dispute that I don't think has much value in continuing on is whether, e.g., an individual solder is famous for something related to government. I say no, others say yes, agree to disagree as long as the QM is upfront about it.
Edit: An extra broad reading of "famous for politics" would largely make "famous for government" superfluous though, at least in countries not run by the military/theocrats/royals.
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
Yeah, I think this is a good point, and it applies to authoritarian countries as well (for example, King Jong-un is definitely famous for politics, even though he's not in a democratic country).Aristocrat wrote: ↑Mon Apr 29, 2024 6:59 pmEdit: An extra broad reading of "famous for politics" would largely make "famous for government" superfluous though, at least in countries not run by the military/theocrats/royals.
But I think this is proving how subjective it can be, and I'm not sure where you draw the line between a bureaucrat and an astronaut. I prefer simply asking "political figure?".
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
No.Let's narrow it down. Born after 1900?
Is this meant to be a request for clarification for this game? It appears not, as there is no question or answer for today's subject that includes the word government. If you want clarification for this subject, please re-frame your request.I'm honestly wondering (and I don't want to drag this out, but I think it's important for the game in general): by the narrow definition of government, who would be considered famous for government, but not politics?
Yes.Born in North America, north of the 35th parallel north?
1,5. Real dead white male human.
2,10. Born 1800-1900.
9,11. Born in US or Canada, north of 35th parallel.
7. Died 1800-1999.
4. Native speaker of Indo-European language.
6. Primarily known for politics, military, sports, or religion (all defined broadly).
3. Not primarily known as inventor, composer, visual artist, or writer.
8. Not elected official.
- Jamiet99uk
- Posts: 32404
- Joined: Sat Dec 30, 2017 11:42 pm
- Location: Durham, UK
- Contact:
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
Speaking as a British civil servant, plenty of people work for the Government but are not involved in politics. Indeed, senior civil servants are expected to actively refrain from political activity of any kind.
The only person you're truly competing against, Wesley, is yourself.
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
Jamie, I agree, but I think astronauts also count as government officials who are not involved in politics. I think the best practice is to just be really specific about what you mean when asking the question.
That was not intended as a request pertaining to this subject. Sorry for not being more clear.
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
For the sake of the game, let's leave the appeals of the Jack Swigert game for discussion in that thread, if desired.
As Aristocrat says, we leave a lot of latitude for QM's to be creative. It is certainly not unreasonable to consider a government employee who achieved his fame on a government mission to have gained his fame from "government." You personally, may have answered the question differently. That would be your right as QM. Someone (not me) answered the Jack Swigert question correctly. That person thought creatively and won the game. As it should be.
Now, back to this fascinating game.
As Aristocrat says, we leave a lot of latitude for QM's to be creative. It is certainly not unreasonable to consider a government employee who achieved his fame on a government mission to have gained his fame from "government." You personally, may have answered the question differently. That would be your right as QM. Someone (not me) answered the Jack Swigert question correctly. That person thought creatively and won the game. As it should be.
Now, back to this fascinating game.
- Spartaculous
- Posts: 2131
- Joined: Sun Jun 11, 2023 4:43 am
- Contact:
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
The equivalent of this in the USA is the Hatch Act: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hatch_ActJamiet99uk wrote: ↑Mon Apr 29, 2024 7:13 pmSpeaking as a British civil servant, plenty of people work for the Government but are not involved in politics. Indeed, senior civil servants are expected to actively refrain from political activity of any kind.
But it is routinely violated (sometimes with consequences).
-
- Posts: 779
- Joined: Wed Mar 10, 2021 4:15 pm
- Location: Milky Way
- Contact:
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
Ever served as head of state, in national congress (or Canadian equivalent), or on the Supreme Court (or Canadian equivalent)?
-
- Posts: 999
- Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2020 6:09 pm
- Contact:
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
Yeah, but the question isn't/wasn't government official, or "the" government, it was government. There are government employees that don't actually govern.
As someone pointed out in the other thread, if accepting a check makes you famous for government, then Donald Knuth is more likely than not famous for government since his research was almost certainly funded by government grants, as university research tends to be.
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
No. Although we'd already established he was not elected to office, so that really only rules out the Supreme Court and a few Kings of Canada.Ever served as head of state, in national congress (or Canadian equivalent), or on the Supreme Court (or Canadian equivalent)?
1,5. Real dead white male human.
2,10. Born 1800-1900.
9,11. Born in US or Canada, north of 35th parallel.
7. Died 1800-1999.
4. Native speaker of Indo-European language.
6. Primarily known for politics, military, sports, or religion (all defined broadly).
3. Not primarily known as inventor, composer, visual artist, or writer.
8,12. Not elected official, on his country's Supreme Court, or King of Canada.
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
No.Generally thought of as an activist?
1,5. Real dead white male human.
2,10. Born 1800-1900.
9,11. Born in US or Canada, north of 35th parallel.
7. Died 1800-1999.
4. Native speaker of Indo-European language.
6. Primarily known for politics, military, sports, or religion (all defined broadly).
3,13. Not primarily known as inventor, composer, visual artist, writer, or activist.
8,12. Not elected official, on his country's Supreme Court, or King of Canada.
-
- Posts: 779
- Joined: Wed Mar 10, 2021 4:15 pm
- Location: Milky Way
- Contact:
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
whoopscdngooner wrote: ↑Mon Apr 29, 2024 7:52 pmNo. Although we'd already established he was not elected to office, so that really only rules out the Supreme Court and a few Kings of Canada.Ever served as head of state, in national congress (or Canadian equivalent), or on the Supreme Court (or Canadian equivalent)?
-
- Posts: 443
- Joined: Fri Nov 03, 2023 12:54 pm
- Contact:
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
Pass. May answer if you define what you mean by an appointed office? I mean, any "job" is an appointed office, defined broadly enough.Best known as the holder of an appointed office?
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
Born in what is currently Canada, Alaska, New York, New Hampshire, Maine, Vermont, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Ohio, Pennsylvania, or New Jersey?
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
Yes.Born in what is currently Canada, Alaska, New York, New Hampshire, Maine, Vermont, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Ohio, Pennsylvania, or New Jersey?
1,5. Real dead white male human.
2,10. Born 1800-1900.
9,11,14. Born in Canada, Alaska, New York, New Hampshire, Maine, Vermont, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Ohio, Pennsylvania, or New Jersey.
7. Died 1800-1999.
4. Native speaker of Indo-European language.
6. Primarily known for politics, military, sports, or religion (all defined broadly).
3,13. Not primarily known as inventor, composer, visual artist, writer, or activist.
8,12. Not elected official, on his country's Supreme Court, or King of Canada.
Pass: Best known as the holder of an appointed office?
- Jamiet99uk
- Posts: 32404
- Joined: Sat Dec 30, 2017 11:42 pm
- Location: Durham, UK
- Contact:
Re: 20 Questions - Game 272
Primarily known for a military role?
The only person you're truly competing against, Wesley, is yourself.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: yoak