M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[Hellenic Riot]

I suppose that's what I get for not reading the roles properly

What did you think was the pay-off for recruiting the traitor? Serious question, I don't always read the set-up closely first day, but we're well into the game now and even I knew what the traitor does.

Usually the payoff for recruiting the Traitor is that the Traitor is useless if you don't recruit them, so if the rest of the scumteam die, the Traitor being recruited keeps them in the game.

[seth24c]

Damo is a much better option than flash today. ##vote damo

[bozotheclown]

Anyway, seeing as Bozo's response since finding out there's a gun has been to disappear into the aether and go so far under the radar he's turning into flash, I think it's about time the ##vote Bozo wagon got going again.

Why bozo???

Why not???

What has Bozo done at any point this game? Where has his in-depth analysis been? What are his reads? Where are his cases? He voted Seth D2 based on three quotes across two short posts, and he's done literally nothing ever since.

My top scum reads are Donny and seth based on their D1, and I have not seen anything yet to convince me either one is town. I explained why I think Donny and seth are the most likely scum among those who avoided voting for summit.
I am sure you can find these post if you look for them, they were during D2, and I copied them again later.

[bozotheclown]

I can't remember, has bozo been around since start of day?

If you mean D4, yes, if you mean this calendar day, no.

[ghug]

Why bozo???

Why not???

What has Bozo done at any point this game? Where has his in-depth analysis been? What are his reads? Where are his cases? He voted Seth D2 based on three quotes across two short posts, and he's done literally nothing ever since.

My top scum reads are Donny and seth based on their D1, and I have not seen anything yet to convince me either one is town. I explained why I think Donny and seth are the most likely scum among those who avoided voting for summit.
I am sure you can find these post if you look for them, they were during D2, and I copied them again later.

Do you feel that we learned anything new from Bunny's being town?

[Maniac]

Hmmmm - you seem to know that scum haven't recruited the traitor which would give them a daychat. How could you know that if you're not scum?

Should we just kill Maniac?

Also getting tempting

He would make a good info kill as it would help us analyse D1. Also I've never liked him, reminds me too much of Dorian Gray.

[bozotheclown]

I can't remember, has bozo been around since start of day?

Yes, but that really just proves my point: Why can nobody remember if Bozo has done anything?

Why do you say nobody can remember? Did you read what I wrote about Donny and seth? If you disagree, can you tell me why?

[ghug]

##VOTE Maniac

[bozotheclown]

Yes, but that really just proves my point: Why can nobody remember if Bozo has done anything?

Hmmmm. I remember thinking he was really townie d1 but he definitely has not been on my radar since. I mean, I haven't really been around but still.

I think the way he voted for summit D1 wasn't very town!bozo at all.

In what "way" is that?

[Vecna]

You seem to be justifying a lot of scumreads based on the fact that they could be the traitor/3p. That doesn't seem like the best way to scumhunt to me.

Wut? I called out Bozo as a likely 3P. Thats the only mention ive made of 3p/traitor afaik? definately as a justification for a scumread.

And here im not even using it as justification to scumread him, just to further weaken his lame argument.

Why do you think I would play differently as 3P than as town?

Because you do? I called you out in your last game as 3p as well.

[Vecna]

Hmmmm - you seem to know that scum haven't recruited the traitor which would give them a daychat. How could you know that if you're not scum?

Should we just kill Maniac?

Also getting tempting

The holy trinity is in agreement

[seth24c]

Should we just kill Maniac?

Also getting tempting

He would make a good info kill as it would help us analyse D1. Also I've never liked him, reminds me too much of Dorian Gray.

This type of post isn’t helping anything if you are town.

[MoscowFleet]

How does scum Maniac make any sense? He's the only counterwagon that summit decided to jump onto after passing on nanook and damo.

[ghug]

How does scum Maniac make any sense? He's the only counterwagon that summit decided to jump onto after passing on nanook and damo.

It's pretty suspicious to not vote your only counterwagon that close to the deadline.

Speaking of deadlines, I just got scheduled to interview someone in ten minutes, so I'm outta here shortly.

[ghug]

Hi PRINCE WILLIAM

[Vecna]

How does scum Maniac make any sense? He's the only counterwagon that summit decided to jump onto after passing on nanook and damo.

He sure took him time though. Almost as if he was taking him time to make sure Maniac didnt actually get lynched, but to still have his vote on there to not rouse suspicion.

[bozotheclown]

I think the way he voted for summit D1 wasn't very town!bozo at all.

In what sense?

I also still think it's suspicious that this was the only time bozo interacted with summit or said anything about him at all. He spent a lot of time justifying his first vote on Maniac at the beginning of the game but didn't seem that interested in grilling summit or convincing himself/others that summit was scum even though bozo's vote put summit in the lead.

summit was looking worse as EOD was approaching and he was making no effort to make meaningful posts. I did not have a lot of time and I was going to be away for most of the remainder of D1, so I voted for summit because he was the more suspicious between him and Chaqa. Plus, I never bus (to the extent I would have had to be bussing summit).

[seth24c]

Hi PRINCE WILLIAM

Ghug traitor confirmed.

[Durga]

VECNA!! Each time you say the L word you owe me a drink at the next f2f tournament

[kgray]

How does scum Maniac make any sense? He's the only counterwagon that summit decided to jump onto after passing on nanook and damo.

He sure took him time though. Almost as if he was taking him time to make sure Maniac didnt actually get miskilled, but to still have his vote on there to not rouse suspicion.

I think everything summit did D1 was hesitant and reserved (except that random and awkward "nanook is town af" comment) so him waiting to actually place a vote says nothing about Maniac, imo.