M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[kgray]

Yeah I can get behind that. ##vote damo

[Fluminator]

##Vote damo

It's frustrating that we had to get a sizable wagon on Nanook for him to give us anything but I like damo getting votes.

[seth24c]

Okay, finally fully caught up and here to actively play. Like, actually.

Rereading EOD and trying to analyze a bit, I find it hard to believe damo isn't being widely scumread. He made zero mention of finding Maniac scummy in any way on day 1 and had Maniac as the 6th most town on his reads list pg 47, yet he voted for him in a very suspicious spot. Let's take a look.

On pg 60:

I'm getting towny vibes from Chaqa.

I'm not scum so all aboard summit please.

So okay. At this point he's pretty gung-ho about just killing summit, but this doesn't mean much as it's to save his own bacon with the vote count at 7 summit-5 damo and nobody else really viable at this moment. Now pg 62 at 6-6:

Two hours to go and it's 6-6 with summit not voting me. This is bad.

I'm not totally convinced summit is scum. I really hope another wagon develops.

If I do get dk'd look at my voters carefully. I suspect worcej and ghug are just misguided. Of the others TrPrado's vote looks very opportunistic to me, seth and MF are meh, Vecna I'm becoming suspicious about. He is not normally this quiet.

Now we see him waffling a bit on summit. Also odd where he says to look at his voters, but only really singles out 2 of them as scummy, one of them a dead townie. Also as damo mentions here, summit never voted for damo even with damo being the second wagon, which is pretty sus on its own.

Now the interesting thing here is that over the next few pages, Nanook was becoming very viable with 4 voters. So at one point it's 6 summit-4 nanook-3 damo, with damo losing steam and Nanook gaining. Yet summit never voted Nanook, and neither did damo. Instead the counterwagon that summit and damo both jumped to was Maniac - summit we know is scum, and damo listed summit as one his strongest scumreads and Maniac as a townread, so it's extremely suspicious. I've also noticed that damo usually almost responds to questions directed at him, even if it's benign one-word answers. The one question that he rather ominously ignored was bunny asking damo why he voted for Maniac.

So yeah. I could go on, but basically damo's Maniac vote, along with the fact that summit didn't want to vote for damo but jumped at Maniac, makes me feel pretty good about damo being scum and Maniac being town, or maybe 3p I guess. So let's get Tom to shoot him. ##Vote damo.

And if we assume damo is scum for a sec, then Nanook also comes out of it looking pretty sus as someone who both scum could've switched to but opted not to.

This is a good post.

[kgray]

##Vote damo

It's frustrating that we had to get a sizable wagon on Nanook for him to give us anything but I like damo getting votes.

Do you think what nanook gave was towny or scummy?

[Nanook]

##Vote damo

It's frustrating that we had to get a sizable wagon on Nanook for him to give us anything but I like damo getting votes.

It’s a coincidence of timing

[Vecna]

Personally I don't think summit calling you town af is that great of an argument for town!nanook considering how awkward that post of summit's was.

also, traitor/3p

You seem to be justifying a lot of scumreads based on the fact that they could be the traitor/3p. That doesn't seem like the best way to scumhunt to me.

Wut? I called out Bozo as a likely 3P. Thats the only mention ive made of 3p/traitor afaik? definately as a justification for a scumread.

And here im not even using it as justification to scumread him, just to further weaken his lame argument.

[seth24c]

##Vote damo

It's frustrating that we had to get a sizable wagon on Nanook for him to give us anything but I like damo getting votes.

Do you think what nanook gave was towny or scummy?

It was scummy to me. Felt like he realizes his ability to just keep joking was up so he scrambled to put up a lackluster defense.

[Nanook]

I’m still joking I just have time rn to do more too

[Vecna]

##Vote damo

It's frustrating that we had to get a sizable wagon on Nanook for him to give us anything but I like damo getting votes.

It’s a coincidence of timing

What a load of horseshit lol. You were right here to respond to the first 3 votes as well.

[Fluminator]

##Vote damo

It's frustrating that we had to get a sizable wagon on Nanook for him to give us anything but I like damo getting votes.

Do you think what nanook gave was towny or scummy?

I see a modicum of towniness which is enough for me atm. He reminds me of a mafiascum townie (that site is a dumphole) and by mafiascum meta it's kind of a townie way to play. (A reason why that site is a dumphole)

[Nanook]

##Vote damo

It's frustrating that we had to get a sizable wagon on Nanook for him to give us anything but I like damo getting votes.

It’s a coincidence of timing

What a load of horseshit lol. You were right here to respond to the first 3 votes as well.

I have time to do more than make flippant comments rn

That isn’t cause I have votes on me, it’s cause I have time IRL and had another game wrap up yesterday

[seth24c]

I’m still joking I just have time rn to do more too

That emoji gives me flashbacks to reading your iso. It’s almost worth it to policy you just because of that.

[MoscowFleet]

Maybe I'm biased because he spent a lot of time defending me but I also feel great about Tom as town.

[MoscowFleet]

We shoot damo, dk nanook, and then scum concede. Anyone?

[Nanook]

It’s a good emoji

[Fluminator]

Jailor should just take out Flash btw. He's useless.

[Donny Dude]

##Vote damo

It's frustrating that we had to get a sizable wagon on Nanook for him to give us anything but I like damo getting votes.

Do you think what nanook gave was towny or scummy?

I see a modicum of towniness which is enough for me atm. He reminds me of a mafiascum townie (that site is a dumphole) and by mafiascum meta it's kind of a townie way to play. (A reason why that site is a dumphole)

Ouch.
Yeah , I agree that type is just infuriating.

[Durga]

I think we should gun flash down, not jail kill

[Fluminator]

I think we should gun flash down, not jail kill

I'd support that too. Damo will likely actually participate in the next 24 hours. Flash won't.

[Vecna]

##vote Flash

I keep doubting my ability to read damo, so ill just sheep w/e u guys feel on that slot.

I feel the group of maniac/flash/nanook/damo has 2-4 of the remaining bad guys, so even if were wrong about a few, killing em all is bound to be a net positive.