Mafia 56: Scout Camp

[Donny Dude]

Donny, do you really want to lynch a PR claim on day 2?

##vote donny

K. So me and you disagree on our reads on Chaqa/Jamiet.
Alright then.

[brainbomb]

even if I was scum I wouldnt have any of that data you just accused us of. kindly stfu

[Vecna]

worcej and xorx both putted claims at eon

Which just happen to be the two roles scum are most likely to claim

[Jamiet99uk]

why are we waiting til EON2 to lynch a confirmed maf

To give the Scoutmaster potentially a second shot.

Ok, I mean worcej claimed medic, you claimed medic. are we saying pump the brakes on seeing who gets caught flatfooted in PR claims?

last I checked a full specific pr claim could catch 1 from who was watched and 1 who doesnt know which to claim. thats 2 scum caught today

Xorxes claimed Cool Guy, not First Aider.

[Vecna]

even if I was scum I wouldnt have any of that data you just accused us of. kindly stfu

Well at least youre passionate about it, so I guess youre not just making stuff up

[brainbomb]

worcej and xorx both putted claims at eon

Which just happen to be the two roles scum are most likely to claim

So why are we uninterested in catching 2 scum today?

[xorxes]

worcej and xorx both putted claims at eon

Which just happen to be the two roles scum are most likely to claim

Do you think one/both of us are lying?

[Vecna]

Xorxes, im almost afraid to ask this in case youre doing some gimmick, but why did you end up claiming at EoN? Those roles are so great if theyre hidden

[Jamiet99uk]

worcej and xorx both putted claims at eon

Which just happen to be the two roles scum are most likely to claim

Yes because each of those roles is not directly cc-able without exposing both of them.

That was my concern when Bozo was demanding roleclaims at night.

[xorxes]

even if I was scum I wouldnt have any of that data you just accused us of. kindly stfu

Well at least youre passionate about it, so I guess youre not just making stuff up

Theoretically it is possible that they would be faking the result, but really unlikely and ridiculously risky, so let's not tinfoil there.

[xorxes]

Xorxes, im almost afraid to ask this in case youre doing some gimmick, but why did you end up claiming at EoN? Those roles are so great if theyre hidden

In case i was killed. It would be bad if I was killed with my role unclaimed, and I thought there was a good chance I would have been killed.

[Donny Dude]

How would they know if he was PR or VT?

Really?
I am still up for lynching Jamiet/Chaqa though based on their hard resistance to the mass claim.

I'm not voting jamie day 2. Chaqa's scumgame seemed much more relaxed. M55 was where I saw him freak out a time or two.

In M55 Chaqa was town, so him freaking out to you seems townish this time?

[Vecna]

Xorxes, im almost afraid to ask this in case youre doing some gimmick, but why did you end up claiming at EoN? Those roles are so great if theyre hidden

In case i was killed. It would be bad if I was killed with my role unclaimed, and I thought there was a good chance I would have been killed.

If you thought there was a good chance to be killed, you had two options to either prevent being killed, or to have us know your role in another way.

There really was no point to actually claim your role and make it mostly irrelevant. Unless youre doing a gimmick or youre naughty.

I dont really scumread you atm, but it does strike me as rather strange

[worcej]

worcej and xorx both putted claims at eon

Which just happen to be the two roles scum are most likely to claim

Yes because each of those roles is not directly cc-able without exposing both of them.

That was my concern when Bozo was demanding roleclaims at night.

Guess maybe this was the problem with the mass claim system.

If only someone spent all of D1 pointing this out... Oh wait...

[brainbomb]

the strangest thing is rivera coming out of the bleachers to post what would seem to be best optimal play for scoutmaster

[xorxes]

Xorxes, im almost afraid to ask this in case youre doing some gimmick, but why did you end up claiming at EoN? Those roles are so great if theyre hidden

In case i was killed. It would be bad if I was killed with my role unclaimed, and I thought there was a good chance I would have been killed.

If you thought there was a good chance to be killed, you had two options to either prevent being killed, or to have us know your role in another way.

There really was no point to actually claim your role and make it mostly irrelevant. Unless youre doing a gimmick or youre naughty.

I dont really scumread you atm, but it does strike me as rather strange

Remember that there was a 50% chance that my action would fail due to A/B switch.

[Vecna]

In case i was killed. It would be bad if I was killed with my role unclaimed, and I thought there was a good chance I would have been killed.

If you thought there was a good chance to be killed, you had two options to either prevent being killed, or to have us know your role in another way.

There really was no point to actually claim your role and make it mostly irrelevant. Unless youre doing a gimmick or youre naughty.

I dont really scumread you atm, but it does strike me as rather strange

Remember that there was a 50% chance that my action would fail due to A/B switch.

Guess you were never going to fail my silly tests

[Jamiet99uk]

Which just happen to be the two roles scum are most likely to claim

Yes because each of those roles is not directly cc-able without exposing both of them.

That was my concern when Bozo was demanding roleclaims at night.

Guess maybe this was the problem with the mass claim system.

If only someone spent all of D1 pointing this out... Oh wait...

Yes that's right. Someone did do that. I think his name was "Chaqa".

[xorxes]

the strangest thing is rivera coming out of the bleachers to post what would seem to be best optimal play for scoutmaster

Unless TRC was Scoutmaster, which seems incredibly unlikely, and unless whoever the guilty was was framed, which is also somewhat unlikely, then that scum is caught and we lynch them tomorrow, We don't need to worry about it right now. The best part is that the scumteam don't know which one of them was caught yet either, so bussing for towncred is not that great for them.

Rivera pointing out optimal play is NAI, as he probably knows someone else would have done it anyway, but I don't see anything scummy about it.

[Donny Dude]

If you thought there was a good chance to be killed, you had two options to either prevent being killed, or to have us know your role in another way.

There really was no point to actually claim your role and make it mostly irrelevant. Unless youre doing a gimmick or youre naughty.

I dont really scumread you atm, but it does strike me as rather strange

Remember that there was a 50% chance that my action would fail due to A/B switch.

Guess you were never going to fail my silly tests

Silly tests lol