Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 780 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
King Atom (100 D)
23 Aug 11 UTC
The First Forum Post Ever!
Kind of pathetic...
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/forum.php?viewthread=39#39
8 replies
Open
Riphen (198 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
I really think I am about to say FUCK DIPLOMACY!!
I wont post names or anything..and if you want to go further you can look at my game list and find which game is pissing me off..but IM DONE.......Its a fucking online game and people act like this is fucking there whole life........!!!!!!!
17 replies
Open
King Atom (100 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
Disturbing
Had to watch this for my summer assignment, and it scared me at parts...

http://www.snagfilms.com/films/title/state_of_the_union/
6 replies
Open
obiwanobiwan (248 D)
14 Aug 11 UTC
Maple, TC, Putin, abgemacht, krellin, KA --Let's Put Our Points Where Our Punditry Is!
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=65582
It was asked for, and here it is--a passworded game, for ALL we wondeful, talkative...occaisonionally trolling and bickering punits!

World Diplomacy...GLOBAL CHAT ONLY! It's passworded, so only the best of the best (or worst of the worst) will be getting into this War of the Words! Put 'em up, people!
Page 6 of 6
FirstPreviousNextLast
 
fiedler (1293 D)
16 Aug 11 UTC
Not defeatist, just realist. The german army was effectively destroyed in stalingrad and kursk. Realistically, the germans had lost the war by the end of 1942. Kursk was their last serious longshot gamble to beat russia.

"Rommel wanted them just out of bombardment range oh the ships."
- yeh that sounds good on paper - but I'm not sure how that would work in practice?
I don't see any way that the germans could have stopped d-day succeeding, even if they had perfect 'eye of god' information.

At any rate, the smart thing for germany to do at this stage of the war was to follow a low risk policy that minimised losses. Because there was no chance of germany beating russia + america + rest of the world. By conserving their forces they buy time and maintain bargaining power.

No doubt Rommel was a talented general and a decent man. His record shows he always tried to minimise loss of life. I don't think it's fair for people to condemn him because he didn't personally strangle herr hitler. That's the judgement of hindsight.

"I assume it was gruesome." - correct! :)
Fasces349 (0 DX)
16 Aug 11 UTC
"I don't see any way that the germans could have stopped d-day succeeding, even if they had perfect 'eye of god' information. "
The missions objectives were failed in 4 of the 5 beaches... The left the beaches hours after they were suppose to, which would have really exposed them if the Germans were actually allowed to send in reinforcements. However there were no German reinforcements simply because they were all in Paris and the allies successfully destroyed the rail lines between Paris and Normandy the following night.

Had Rommel been allowed any heavy weapons the already heavily fortified border of northern France would have been impossible.

And about you saying D-Day was guarentteed. Diepe failed which was their first attempt to land in France, similar operation and failed.
King Atom (100 D)
16 Aug 11 UTC
D-day would have failed granted that Hitler had his shit together.
Fasces349 (0 DX)
16 Aug 11 UTC
Hitler was to arragont, he had the brightest people in the world as his cabinet, and he made it a policy not to listen to them.

He had the choice on attacking Moscow and Kiev right before the Russian winter started, he chose Kiev which was taken and then the winter hit. Imagine being in Moscow before the winter?

He could have done a better job at fortifying france, and all his generals wanted him to.

All his generals were against attacking USSR, and Ribentrop, Hitler's foreign minister, claimed the USSR asked to join the axis pact.

Remember Dunkirk? The panzers had encircled the army and they could have destroyed them in a heartbeat, but Hitler chose to send in the brand new bombers to test their accuracy. The fog allowed them to escape.

Stalingrad was bloody simply because Hitler assumed the soviets wouldn't counter attack, they had counter attacked after almost every other lost battle thus far in the war, so why wouldn't they counter then?

Operation Sealion was abandoned? Why? All his generals were promising success, and had Germany landed on English soil England would have been driven out of the war.

Germany in the first year of the war focused bombing activities on enemy air bases, the result: Almost instant air superiority by Germany due to heavy fighter casualties before they could take off by the allies. So why did Hitler demand they moved from bombing industry to bombing civilian areas?

When Hitler was in the army, he couldn't advance past the rank of Corporal. He didn't know how to run an army properly and yet he tried to. Had he let those who knew what they were doing run the army and he focused on the politics, then Germany might have won the war...
King Atom (100 D)
16 Aug 11 UTC
Why did Hitler lead our race to shame? He really wasn't all that bright if you ask me...
fiedler (1293 D)
16 Aug 11 UTC

"The missions objectives were failed in 4 of the 5 beaches... The left the beaches hours after they were suppose to"

- So? Just because there are difficulties does not make the entire INVASION a failure.

"which would have really exposed them if the Germans were actually allowed to send in reinforcements."

- OK, let's say german reinforcements are sent in, and despite allied air supremacy and naval bomabardment, somehow they massacre every allied soldier landed thus far. How many casualties do you think this would cost the germans? And then the allies would simply keep going and land more troops. The allies would be quite happy to fight an attritional war on the beaches for as long as the germans wanted to suicide themselves.
By not attempting to battle the allies at the beaches, they avoided a massacre for both sides that the allies could easily recover from but the germans could not.

"Had Rommel been allowed any heavy weapons the already heavily fortified border of northern France would have been impossible."

- that makes no sense whatsoever. Impossible? Says who now?

"Diepe failed which was their first attempt to land in France, similar operation and failed."

- ah yes the Dieppe RAID. A port raid being slightly different from a continental invasion.

* Dieppe: 19 August 1942, involving 6,000 infantrymen (mostly canadians).

* D-Day: 6 June 1944, involving over 160,000 troops landing on the first day.
195,700 Allied naval and merchant navy personnel in over 5,000 ships were involved. Plus massive bombardments and commando operations leading up to it.

Yes, QUITE similar :P

"Remember Dunkirk?"

- no, wasn't there.
fiedler (1293 D)
16 Aug 11 UTC
"Operation Sealion was abandoned? Why? All his generals were promising success, and had Germany landed on English soil England would have been driven out of the war."

Hitler: Ja! let us invade ze Engerland! Zat will solve all ze problems. Ship lots of ze troops over there and keep zem supplied.

Vas? The Royal Navy? Sink them all! Zat vas easy!

Vas? The american navy? umm... ignore zem?

Vas? Zee amerikans have counter-invaded england? oh shit...

Vas? The russians have invaded germany from the east? Oh ficken eck. I am the worst military leader in history ;=(
King Atom (100 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
Riphen (Quebec) will be leaving soon, we will need someone to take his place.
King Atom (100 D)
23 Aug 11 UTC
^ Ignore: inverse bump


159 replies
Cockney (0 DX)
23 Aug 11 UTC
live in 10 mins
1 reply
Open
DipCastGuys (100 D)
23 Aug 11 UTC
DiplomacyCast lives on!
Episode 8 available tonight. Read more.
3 replies
Open
Compay (100 D)
23 Aug 11 UTC
About live games
If the people who joined a live game don't show up, it is the right thing to do, to cancel or draw the game, is not it?
So, today's question is: what is the appropriate name for those who refuse to and, enjoying an unfair advantage achieve an unearned win?
I personally would go with "douchebags".
3 replies
Open
krellin (80 DX)
14 Aug 11 UTC
DOMINION....and other board games.
Bought the game "Dominion" this Christmas for the family. I love strategy board games....*hate* "roll-the-dice-move-your-mice" games. Also own games such as Robo-Rally, Agricola, Pirate's Cove...
40 replies
Open
King Atom (100 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
Started a Game...
It was supposed to be for certain people, but nobody joined, so I'll let you all in. The password is 'Conlee'
gameID=65857
12 replies
Open
jmo1121109 (3812 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
Has anyone else noticed
That the number of CD players has skyrocketed the past few days. There went from being about 100 open games to nearly 140. Are there a lot of multi's being banned or are people just leaving games as soon as they get in a tight spot?
15 replies
Open
Macchiavelli (2856 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
CD in world dip - we need a new USA (strong position)
gameID=64682
in this game, usa went cd, and we need someone to take over
usa is in a solid position, several easy allies around him
0 replies
Open
King Atom (100 D)
21 Aug 11 UTC
Play Diplomacy
So, before I've even finished my first game at Play Diplomacy.com, I've created some enemies for myself.
13 replies
Open
PunxsutawneyPhil (382 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
New Game - 15D - PPSC - 2-day-phase
http://95.211.128.12/webdiplomacy/board.php?gameID=66103
0 replies
Open
FirstApple (100 D(B))
22 Aug 11 UTC
Just to be clear on the rules
Can two units of your own completely switch places without bumping? For example, you've got an army in Norway and a fleet in Sweden... can you order the fleet to Norway and the army to Sweden without them bumping or are they going to bump?
6 replies
Open
Yellowjacket (835 D(B))
21 Aug 11 UTC
Do conservatives make better Diplomacy players?
One would think so. A certain amount of ruthlessness is needed, so does having a "me first" political ideology give one a heads up in that area?

Alternatively, are liberals more successful at forcing a draw in WTA? By the same token, one could assume that they would be more successful at sacrificing their own potential for the greater good. Thoughts?
58 replies
Open
Onar (131 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
Talk diplomacy
Well, basically, I have the idea that in terms of diploming (in FTF, mostly) that it might be better to wait for someone else to approach you with an idea, rather than approaching someone else to discuss something. Thoughts?
20 replies
Open
King Atom (100 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
Racism/Sexism
To quote a famous trouble-maker: I have a Dream.

I suppose that most of you would be against a world where we call black people "boy" and where a woman never leaves the house. But I'm pretty much all for it. I'd just like to know....does anyone agree with me? Literally, ANYONE?
18 replies
Open
Guillaume (630 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
No messaging?
A quick question: I don't understand why there is the option on this website of playing diplomacy without messaging between players. Isn't the goal of diplomacy to do...diplomacy?!
7 replies
Open
King Atom (100 D)
20 Aug 11 UTC
STORY TIME WITH ATOM!
Hi, I'm King Atom. Writer of writings that critics have said the following about:
"Pure genius..." "I'm...blown away..." "...Love it...so much that I peed my pants." "You actually have some talent." "A++" "You stole my idea, bitch..." "And much more..."
And much more.
58 replies
Open
FirstApple (100 D(B))
19 Aug 11 UTC
The Non-English Thread
Como hay tantos estudiantes en esta comunidad, me imagino que hay muchos quienes tambien han aprendido o estan aprendiendo un segundo idioma que sea aparte del ingles. Si eso es el caso y Ustedes quisieran practicar de escribir y leer en un otro idioma, se pueden aqui conmigo.
70 replies
Open
Kind.of.slow (746 D)
21 Aug 11 UTC
Starting time, remaining time
For some reason, here in my Chrome browser all the games are marked as "Starting: Now" and while IN the game, I can't see the remaining time because it just say "Next: Now". How can I solve it?Thx
14 replies
Open
youradhere (1345 D)
21 Aug 11 UTC
Tripoli
It seems the Revolution in Libya has finally reached the endgame. What comes next for Libya?
9 replies
Open
Ranscott47 (2874 D)
22 Aug 11 UTC
Live Game sign up now Death with Honor
Annon players Regular Diplomacy game Start at 905 PM Central Standard Time
0 replies
Open
abgemacht (1076 D(G))
19 Aug 11 UTC
Per Atom's Request
The most interesting thing I could think of off the top of my head:

How does the probabilistic nature of Quantum Mechanics (QM) affect the debate on Free Will (FW)?
119 replies
Open
Yellowjacket (835 D(B))
21 Aug 11 UTC
Replacement france needed
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=64683

We need a replacement France. It's a lost cause, but still a small chance of stalemating Italy and getting a 5 way. Everybody else is on board... message me for password.
0 replies
Open
JackWalker (100 D)
20 Aug 11 UTC
Game dont starts after Server-change
Hello together,

the Game http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=63805 didnt start yet after the server-change. Only because two persons dont push unpause- I think they are inactive. Is it possible to unpause it?
2 replies
Open
King Atom (100 D)
20 Aug 11 UTC
I've Always Wondered...
Russia is freaking huge. So why does it only have four SC's/units? It's not like the rest of them have been captured by the Mongolians...
17 replies
Open
King Atom (100 D)
19 Aug 11 UTC
Seriously, People!
The forums pretty much suck right now, so I'd appreciate a really good thread that I can follow and think about before I go. So let's make one out of this.
58 replies
Open
Crazy Anglican (1075 D)
20 Aug 11 UTC
Hi all
Been a while, how is everyone?
7 replies
Open
MarshallShore (122 D)
21 Aug 11 UTC
School of War
Is anyone up for a SOW? I propose:
Students must have less than, say... 175(D) (inc. in games).
Teachers 1800(D) or more?
2 Day cycle for communication with teachers.
4 replies
Open
Page 780 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top