Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 202 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Lewis31 (100 D)
18 Jan 09 UTC
Scenario

2 replies
Open
DipperDon (6457 D)
17 Jan 09 UTC
Hall of Fame member with unusual game histories.
http://www.phpdiplomacy.net/profile.php?userID=3701
15 replies
Open
Pimpernel (115 D)
18 Jan 09 UTC
1 Hour game GMC 9 Jan @ 0600?
Any takers?
0 replies
Open
rratclif (0 DX)
16 Jan 09 UTC
By convoy by convoy?
Does it bother anyone else that you move from one shore to another "by convoy by convoy" in the finalize orders?

Not really a complaint, I understand Kestas and the Mod-Squad have better things to do with their time, but I was just wondering if I was only on this. Also, is it only certain convoys, or all of them?
10 replies
Open
Pandarsenic (1485 D)
18 Jan 09 UTC
Epic Win
http://www.theonion.com/content/news/u_n_acquires_nuclear_weapon

The Onion News has published the article, "U.N. Acquires Nuclear Weapon."
Hilarity ensues.
1 reply
Open
Friendly Sword (636 D)
17 Jan 09 UTC
Friendly Sword expresses some displeasure.
Explanation and supplementary query to follow;

25 replies
Open
paggas (184 D)
17 Jan 09 UTC
Rules question
If a move fails, does the unit that ordered it default to a hold? That is, does its power still count
for defending its area?
7 replies
Open
Captain Canuck (178 D)
18 Jan 09 UTC
"Supports Not Working?"
In a few games I'm in some players aren't able to support-move or support-hold in situations where they should be able to. Anyone experiencing something similar?
0 replies
Open
Yonder (100 D)
18 Jan 09 UTC
gameID=7519
im not sure what can be done about it, but gameID=7519 (name: 5pt death) has been paused due to a player beeing banned. Russia and england seem to have left the game and have not unpaused. can this be fixed? i.e. unpaused.
0 replies
Open
More Politics
http://leftwingconspiracy.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/09/motivator2708280.jpg
Discuss Clinton's time as president.
1 reply
Open
Gobbledydook (1389 D(B))
17 Jan 09 UTC
Look at this.
http://www.phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=7996
Top calibre game, and....FOUR players NMR!
This is getting bad. I'll have to learn not to trust the players (or the gamemaster?? they say it always processes the game just before they wake up).
No NMR's please!!!
3 replies
Open
TasteeDiner (100 D)
17 Jan 09 UTC
New game
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=8129
100 point buy in
regular game
0 replies
Open
mapleleaf (0 DX)
17 Jan 09 UTC
New game!!!
Love is my sin...Winner-takes-all, 36 hours/phase: Slow, Buy in 142
1 reply
Open
airborne (154 D)
17 Jan 09 UTC
End War
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=8123
5 point buy in
36 hour turns
1 reply
Open
mapleleaf (0 DX)
16 Jan 09 UTC
Unquadbium -New Game- 142 pt buy in- WTA - 24 hr phases.
All are welcome.
4 replies
Open
rratclif (0 DX)
17 Jan 09 UTC
Anyone ever notice this?
Let's say you lost an SC and had to destroy a unit, and you chose a fleet in the Norwegian Sea. Next Spring you have a fleet in Edinburg, and if you select the option "support hold", you're given the option to support the fleet in Norwegian Sea, even though it's not there anymore. I'm assuming this works for all instances, but I know the above instance does it. I don't know php, would this be hard to fix?
5 replies
Open
BPM aka HMF (100 D)
17 Jan 09 UTC
can you destroy your own units?
in order to build them back up at your home supply centers? like you tell your other units to attack them maybe?
4 replies
Open
saulberardo (2111 D)
17 Jan 09 UTC
More one needed - join for 43!
hey folk
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=8097
we need just one to complete the table!
Don't lose this wonderful opportunity!
0 replies
Open
PaddyK (100 D)
17 Jan 09 UTC
Newbie - Please forgive
Hi to all,
I just got here, with the help of DLQwijibo. Please forgive my naivete, but I want to play. I guess I'll pick things up as I go.
For all offences future and undefined....I plead the Newbie act.
2 replies
Open
SpeakerToAliens (147 D(S))
15 Jan 09 UTC
Admins! Help! Lawful orders offered but not accepted.
I can only select either "Hold" or "Move via Convoy" and then the target location is locked to single place, a place I don't want to go to (there are 16 convoy to locations offered and 4 normal move locations).
19 replies
Open
paggas (184 D)
16 Jan 09 UTC
Convoys don't show up well
I noticed that convoys often aren't shown in the minimap, they are displayed however in the large map! For instance, http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=8064 (unit placing). It this a knows issue?
2 replies
Open
xcurlyxfries (0 DX)
12 Jan 09 UTC
Actually screw it... 3 Variant games
100-150 Dagger buy in 3v3 PPSC 24-36 hour phases
50-100 Dagger buy in Gunboat WTA 36-48 hour phases
50-100 Dagger buy in Public Press PPSC 36 hour phases
Any takers? State your preferences if you want to play in any.
156 replies
Open
youradhere (1345 D)
11 Jan 09 UTC
The Leagues
Are there actually multiple levels? So far I have only seen the very best players in League games (Rait etc.)
When will the lower level games start?
39 replies
Open
Pimpernel (115 D)
16 Jan 09 UTC
lol-59
how can a game be unpaused when all players haven't unpaused it?
6 replies
Open
paggas (184 D)
16 Jan 09 UTC
Russia and Sweden
Can Russia get Sweden in two phases? Since Germany will probably get Denmark in the first phase, and then block Russia in the second phase from getting to Sweden!
9 replies
Open
stratagos (3269 D(S))
15 Jan 09 UTC
Not so hypothetical game question
Full disclosure: pertains to an active game, but the discussion will be couched in such a way that it should have no impact.
stratagos (3269 D(S))
15 Jan 09 UTC
Let's say you're Country A. You're an interior country, which means you have potential allies and enemies on all sides. It's a Winner Take All situation.

You successfully play countries B, C, and D off each other for a bit, then country D goes NMR. Country B moves in such a way that he can threaten you *or* Country D, and then country *E* goes NMR - which brings you into conflict with country F.

Many turns go by, and Country C is in position to win. Countries D and E are go, and B and F are in a pretty strong alliance. Country G is way the hell on the other side of the map, and doesn't really enter into discussions.

You can't make progress against the B/F alliance, and they're continuing to pressure you - but C continues to grow.

So you're in a position where you can keep your alliance with C, or you can turn on him to stop him from getting the win. Of course, while you're doing this, B and F will be eating you from behind, and at least one member of the alliance has made it clear they're much more interested in taking you down than in preventing C's victory - so you'll end up dead.

Given the above, do you attempt to stop the solo, even though you probably won't survive the experience? Or do you try to be a good ally to the end, even though you get nothing out of it?
stratagos (3269 D(S))
15 Jan 09 UTC
FYI - my decision on my course of action has been made. This is more of a 'what if' to the group as a whole
dangermouse (5551 D)
15 Jan 09 UTC
The "good ally" argument is irrelevant. This is a WTA game and allowing someone else to solo obviously means you lose.

That said, if other players aren't understanding that they need your help so that they won't also lose then perhaps you should point that out to them. If they still don't care then the question becomes: If you move to stop the solo what are your survival chances?

Your answer seems to be zero, that you will be completely eliminated if you move to stop the leader. If that's the case then I say screw the jackass who doesn't understand WTA games.

Of course, the better answer is to find a way diplomatically out of the situation. Convince player C to hold off on expanding or at least slow down while you move to crush a smaller player and that if he doesn't agree you'll punish him by stopping his victory. Or convince someone else that you're going to allow the victory unless they stop this player who's hitting you from the rear.
Chrispminis (916 D)
15 Jan 09 UTC
It's sad, but if it's a true WTA situation then I say fight the solo. There is a microscopically higher chance you'll win if you fight it than if you don't. If nobody else around you is willing to join you in the coalition then sucks to them because they've also lost by their lack of will. Congratulations to Country C.
paulg (358 D)
15 Jan 09 UTC
"Not so hypothetical game question [...] but the discussion will be couched in such a way that it should have no impact."

by changing the power names to letters

"FYI - my decision on my course of action has been made. This is more of a 'what if' to the group as a whole"

Then why not leave it until after the game has finished?
EdiBirsan (1469 D(B))
15 Jan 09 UTC
I have been in a position, in a World Tournament final qualifying round no less, where I have thrown a solo to a player because I was so angry at the people who were on the other side of me taking the attitude that:
"You have to stop the solo, so even if we take your centers from behind you must ethically fight the top winner."
Well they go the shock of their lives when I turned around and organized the victory for the soloist in 4 moves with the simple explanation to them that 'now we are all tied for second place, and we all score zero, not just me'
You are never committed to stop anyone or group when the rest of the players take the attitude that it is ok to play fast and loose with your centers.
Now sometimes, the best tactical plan requires you to give up centers to someone else to stop a solo or a team, but that is very different from someone trying to nibble away at you from behind while you are faced as the front line power against the solo threat.
Xapi (194 D)
16 Jan 09 UTC
Out of curiosity, Edi, was that one of many games in the same round, or was it direct elimination?

Or to put it differently, did the solo player guarantee his passing through the next round and the rest being out of the tournament or did you have another chance?

And, if you had another chance, how did you perform on the next games?

To stratagos:

I think your best strategy at this point is to tell C that if he doesn't stop growing and help you grow a bit more so that you may have the possibility for a 2-way draw, you'll attack him, thus eliminating his chance for a solo.

At the same time, tell BF that if they don't stop attacking you, you'll let C take the win, in fact, you'll ensure it.

If neither option works, if I were you, I'd let C win. He was your ally and didn't attack you, so given the chance to let one or another player win, I'd give the win to him.


7 replies
buzzkill08 (448 D)
15 Jan 09 UTC
Unpause, please
We elected to pause the game 7675 for christmas, but for 3 weeks now the turkey player has refused to unpause. Could we get a mod to please unpause this game manually so the rest of us can enjoy our game? thanks
3 replies
Open
Mr.Coolio (100 D)
16 Jan 09 UTC
New Game
I want to play a gun boat game, so http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=8102
its a 45 point buy in
10 replies
Open
wooooo (926 D)
16 Jan 09 UTC
Live game tonight (Very fast game)
Anyone want to play a 1 hour phase game starting in the next 1-2 hours?
17 replies
Open
Duality Pete (100 D)
15 Jan 09 UTC
Crouch End Game
Hey this is Piere L'ard thought I'd start a thread if any of ya wanna chat.
5 replies
Open
Page 202 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top