curtis.. france and england right.. i have emailed them already but you do it too

the email is [email protected]

you guys are such sore losers...

that looks like multiple accounts to me....

Who does? Game looks free of multi's to me Guy

okay probably.. but that isnt in the spirit of gunboat as there is clear communication and collaboration between the two.. which in a gunboat (particularly anonymous gunboat) i dont expect or appreciate.. so i say metagaming

The fact that mat cauthon is in almost every game that henrytinkler played might mean something, but it proves nothing...

almost every game means 8 in 13... to be exact

there is even a gmae that they NMR at the same time (and they were allied)... suspicious I would say

That certainly is. Might be a case of metagaming (I haven't looked into that propperly). All I can say is its unlikely to be multiaccounting. Sorry not to be more helpful, but these can take time, especially when hard to prove!

sorry, i shouldn't jump to conclusions-- henrytinkler may just only play live games..but yeah, i was referring to the 8 in 13 games they have had together, and it appears that they have either done well together or done badly together. even if they are seperate players, based on their track record, it would not seem that far-fetched to message each other to see if they were playing the same gunboat game.

and even harder to prove when you post on the forum i would think. that lets the possible multi's know that they are being looked into.

i'm not a mod but yeah thats my opinion

I am not sure of what happened. It was my first game online.
Anyway, England not moving in the first year spoiled the game totally.
We should have cancelled as Russian player suggested later.
In Spring 1902 -->
(FRA) in Marseilles moves to Piedmont supported by (GER) in Tyrolia.
In Autumn 1902 -->
(GER) in Piedmont tries to move to Venice supported by (FRA) in Piedmont.
I thought they were moving very very coordinated without using messages.
What do you think about this?

guys curtis has played with doofman 4 times in his last 10 games. they must be the same person... its the only logical explination

hey figlesquidge.. just got your email.. cant believe i didnt post the gamelink...
yeah.. i would say Meta

mat cauthon is a cunt.. i cant believe you would ally with a twat like that

hey doofman. Are you up for another game? We had a good one earlier. It's WTA and password protected so no suspicious players.

yea man make sure it's password protected so no cunts get in!!

can matt and i join?

And mat cauthon and henrytinkler played together in their last 5 of 5 games!!!
I dont want to accuse no one. But i've seen what i've seen i'm not blind.
I dont care friends playing together, but not in a game without messages and anonymous. I think i will not play anonymous anymore. Bad experience for first game.

C-K... im in one now.. but send me the link.. you cunts can fuck off

If you let me know when you start your game (in this thread), if I'm still up I'll have a quick look through for any very obvious links. Clearly I couldn't find well hidden ones as I'm rather busy, but even so gives you a bit more confidence.

Hey... henrytinkler his name is matt from Matthew? I thought his nick was just mat cauthon.

henry and mat
are you playing in the same game now?

http://webdiplomacy. net/board.php? gameID=17606

@mel198 Sore losers? How many emails have you sent to the mods complianing about multi's and meta's I know you accused me, dave bishop, VAGG, ottovanbis of something or other and emailed the mods!

sorry denis.. but i cant see Mel's name in this thread

Oops read it wrong mat cauthoun sorry

If you are reading this, please...
look for the movements i speak about in my first post in this thread.
Take two minutes to analyze. And you will see if henrytinkler (FRA) and mat cauthon (GER) were talking. I thought that no communication was allowed in this game.

it shouldnt be.. it is obvious they didnt play in the spirit and anyone who says they did.. well i worry about your mental capacity

to the idiot who thought he got some clue out of tinkler calling me matt instead of mat... mat cauthon is a character from a book that the tinkler obviously hasn't read and thought my name is matt. good work though sherlock holmez

And the idiots (i didn't want to insult no one but in this case don't think i am doing so) that spoil games should learn how to play fair. Please dont spoil any other game. Play you both alone if you just need to win.

play you both alone? you can't speak english?

I'm glad you don't want to insult no one Wallace which is good cause you insured me! Job well done... Play us both alone? You would have to be 5 people at the same time? I thought u weren't supposed to be multiple people?

Hmm, there seems to be some collaboration there but you can't be sure unless you have a mod check it out....