Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 61 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
icanhazconquest (100 D)
08 Jan 08 UTC
new game: OPEN2ALL
5 point game.
0 replies
Open
Basil (107 D)
07 Jan 08 UTC
Checking moves
Is there a way to check what moves you entered to compare them with what actually happens?

I ask as I'm convinced the actual moves in my last campaign were not those that I entered! Is there any way to check?

It's probably just incompetence on my part. . .but it would be handy tool anyway.
4 replies
Open
prairie13 (25 D)
08 Jan 08 UTC
self-dislodging
I was reading somewhere where you can self-dislodge in this game.
I'm making
1) a move from A into B.
2) supporting another unit from C into A.

What happens if the first move doesn't work.
In regular Diplomacy you can't self dislodge but I wondering what would happen here...
does the original unit in A get to retreat or is it destroyed or does the supported move fail?
4 replies
Open
Razz (144 D)
07 Jan 08 UTC
DRAW Request, game 2302
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gid=2302

Apparently the consensus is to call this a draw.
2 replies
Open
Braveheart (2408 D(S))
05 Jan 08 UTC
Asian Games
I'd like to start a game in the next week or so for those in the Asia Pacific timezones - can you let me know who would be interested. I think it should make for a better game, as more communication should be possible during the day and we might be able to confirm orders earlier etc. Let me know who might be interested....
9 replies
Open
Signalseven (116 D)
01 Jan 08 UTC
In the beginning...
I always love the first two years of Dip. Such an intoxicating mix of anxiety and paranoia with a hint of confusion. The first moves are like riding a roller coaster. You are happy and scared all at the same time. It's just a great time to be alive.

Just a random thought I had while communicating with another player. Thought it was nice and I should share.
21 replies
Open
csibadajoz (527 D)
06 Jan 08 UTC
Is this a bug?
Unit A gives support unit B to move to C
Unit C attacks A

Does C cut support? I think no.....
15 replies
Open
Stephen V (345 D)
07 Jan 08 UTC
asking for draw
Dear admin,

in the game Magical Mystery Tour gryncat and I have decided on a draw. We are in the Autumn phase and at the end will have 17 units each. If the points could be split up that would be awesome.
1 reply
Open
shad08 (183 D)
01 Jan 08 UTC
Multiple accounts
lcls and slcl...every game they are in together, and yea..its kinda obvious with the names dude..comeon.
6 replies
Open
nyases (100 D)
06 Jan 08 UTC
I think I found a cheater
I have been playing a game for almost three weeks now and over the course of the game three players have been beaten down to one or two units and then mostly ignored. Each one of them stoped submitting moves, probably out of spite to slow us down. However, a new profile was made earlier today and for for no reason, joined as one of these hopeless nations in civil disorder. This was the first and only game he joined, despite there being other new games that he could have joined. Due to all this, I think that the only possibility is that another player in my game has created this acount to give himself an edge. I dont know if anyone can remove him from the game, but I would appricate it of you could.
4 replies
Open
Juanito (9 D)
06 Jan 08 UTC
Replacements
A suggestion to the game masters or what ever you call them, I think it would be good if it did not have any cost to join a game when you replace a country in civil disorder. It would cause more people to want to join the game, since they have nothing to lose. Second, since more people would join the replacement games, the balance would not be upset as much, as civil disorder countries always give one country a big advantage. Third, people replacing a country can still win the pot, giving further incentives to join.
3 replies
Open
thewonderllama (100 D)
03 Jan 08 UTC
Winning Distribution
I was just looking over my finished games and noticed there were a disproportionately large number of games won by Turkey. Now I realize I've only finished 17 games and haven't played any high roller games so my experiences may not be representative, so I thought I'd ask how other people's experiences worked out.

Kestas, would it be possible to add some basic stats like this? I'd figure this to be a pretty low priority, so maybe I'll try to dip my head in the php pool and see if I can hack something together for this...

Here's what I found:

Total games: 17
Turkey wins: 7
Italy wins: 2
England wins: 2
Germany wins: 2
France wins: 1
Austria wins: 1
Russia wins: 1
Draw (3-way): 1

(It may or may not be interesting to note that the draw included Turkey.)
33 replies
Open
EricHerboso (836 D)
07 Jan 08 UTC
Top 100
Contrary to popular belief, the top 100 only lists 100 names. The problem is that there is apparently a hidden entry in between #62 and #64. If you look closely, you'll find Horizon correctly labeled as #62, but immediately afterwardThe Mahatma is incorrectly labeled as #64. This is not due to a tied score, although the effect looks similar to what happens when two players have identical scores.

The only reason I can think of for such a discrepancy is that there might be a hidden test account that has enough points on it to fall between Horizon and The Mahatma; of course, I didn't bother checking the code, so I very well may be completely wrong.
1 reply
Open
crimson (501 D)
07 Jan 08 UTC
New game: 125 bet
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gid=2667
Check my profile for the password.
0 replies
Open
whoami (178 D)
07 Jan 08 UTC
(RTC) Lt. Crackers
Why does he still have points from his multiaccounting?
3 replies
Open
Stephen V (345 D)
05 Jan 08 UTC
DRAW
Dear game administrators. There is a game PFan, game ID is 2314, where myself (France) and Russia have talked and decided to call it a draw. We are both currently at 15 units and would like to split the win. Italy is still in the game but will is most likely to be fought over for the win and so can be placed in third for the ranking.

The others should be posting their reply too consent soon. Thank you for splitting up the point.
7 replies
Open
ranolf (102 D)
06 Jan 08 UTC
Adjudicator bug: Norway support for move from moscow to st peters should have worked
05:30 PM Autumn 1905, Diplomacy: Your army at Norway successfully supported the army at Moscow move to St. Petersburg.
05:30 PM Autumn 1905, Diplomacy: Your army at Moscow engaged the army at St. Petersburg head on; both units were equally matched so there was a stand off.
How can this be?
gameid=2477


2 replies
Open
keeper0018 (100 D)
06 Jan 08 UTC
question on disrupting a support move...
quick question-

there are turkish armies in st.p and sweden, and i have a fleet in norway. i moved norway - sweden, and he moved st.p - norway and sweden s st.p - norway. i could've swore that if you attacked a unit that was giving support, the support was cut. any help at all?

p.s. i got this message in the gamemaster...

"Spring 1912, Diplomacy: Your fleet at Norway couldn't prevent army at Sweden from giving a support move, because the support was being given to attack your fleet at Norway, and you had no support." (this makes no sense what so ever)

http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gid=2395&msgmembershipid=0
1 reply
Open
lmatt (100 D)
29 Dec 07 UTC
adjudicator bugs
I think it would be helpful if we all had a list of bugs/ features not implemented in the adjudicator. e.g. i have heard something about being unable to retreat from bulgaria
11 replies
Open
Lynius (100 D)
05 Jan 08 UTC
New 101 point game
Join up at http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gid=2657
1 reply
Open
Tman401 (126 D)
04 Jan 08 UTC
Draw Request for Battle of Kamino
As soon as the other players confirm please draw the Game Battl of Kamino (http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gid=2380)
I am Turkey and confirm the draw
5 replies
Open
whatusername (100 D)
22 Dec 07 UTC
Formatting looks horrible on Opera
I believe I brought this up some few months ago, but I'm not quite so sure, and it hasn't been fixed yet, so I'll bring it up again.

I can't really explan it in words (Don't have the right vocabulary to say it I guess) so here's a screenshot:
http://img.waffleimages.com/ac313e778561812f74bd3b3ee737b73a0c01f2c1/operacompatibility.JPG

Please get this fixed soon, it's annoying to open up Firefox just so I can get through a turn of phpDiplomacy.
18 replies
Open
flashman (2274 D(G))
05 Jan 08 UTC
One more player needed...
For Wombat 3 (password: wombie).

A cheapie game cos we're all mean and in penury.

Click my name and you'll find it listed.
0 replies
Open
Thucydides (864 D(B))
03 Jan 08 UTC
Are Sardinia and Crete fiercely nationalist or something?
No matter what territories you control in the vicinity, Crete and Sardinia remain orange, and it's not like every outlying island stays neutral. Look at Iceland. If anyone was going to make a case for a perpetually neutral country, it would be that, but it follows the allegiance of Clyde. So what's up? Could that be changed, for the sake of aesthetics?
16 replies
Open
Locke (1846 D)
05 Jan 08 UTC
Dip1
I've started game Dip1, please join if you can afford it for the chance to win some serious points!
0 replies
Open
bc2000 (990 D)
04 Jan 08 UTC
Draw request for gid=2260
Dear Kestas
could you please set a draw for the game HIMYM (gid 2260) as soon as the other player involved in it will confirm the request.
3 replies
Open
VIOLA (1650 D)
04 Jan 08 UTC
Full metal jacket
New game for top 100 players.
The pot is 125, join it!
0 replies
Open
lou89laj (276 D)
04 Jan 08 UTC
Draw request for gid 2378
Could you please give a three way tie for East as soon as the other players confirm this is what they want.
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gid=2378
2 replies
Open
Iggy24 (151 D)
04 Jan 08 UTC
ItsAllHere
Easy 10 Point Game. Need 2 More people. Thanks!
0 replies
Open
alamothe (3367 D(B))
02 Jan 08 UTC
omg
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gid=2551

this is not decent way to earn points, playing with anlari's multis... i think...
anlari (8640 D)
02 Jan 08 UTC
None of the accounts are mine, I think it is Diegohb flooding games.
Rait (10151 D(S))
03 Jan 08 UTC
the pot is rather impressive, I wonder where the multies got their credit? Or is it something with taking over CD countries? Could You take a look Kestas?
anlari (8640 D)
03 Jan 08 UTC
I think it is related to taking over.
dangermouse (5551 D)
03 Jan 08 UTC
The pot went way up when a couple of CDs were taken over.
sean (3490 D(B))
03 Jan 08 UTC
if that is deiglobs response to your thread stating your susp about him multigaming then thats not good..not good at all. is dieglob 13?.. 12? how low can one go.
sorry to any responsible youngsters out there.
Rait (10151 D(S))
03 Jan 08 UTC
I don't know if taking over CD-s is good enough explanation - it shouldn't be mathematically possible. I have not gone into the details of the points system, but just think about it:

When multies started the game, the pot couldn't be bigger than 700 credits, currently the pot size is 1890 credits. The year is 1905 (autumn) while 3 territories are in CD. From the log it can be seen that all the countries were active the first turn, then from the autumn 1901 until autumn 1903 all the countries besides English were inactive, apparently at the spring 1903 also English quit playing. Then Turkey entered once again into the game & submitted his moves at the fall 1903. Austria & English were reactivated at Autumn 1904 & fig probably took over Italy just now.

I'm assuming that that the first CD was taken over at the autumn 1903. By that time there were in total 27 units & SC-s (out of 34 possible). This means that the price for taking over Turkey should have been (at least around) 700/27*3 ~77 credits, so the total pot should have been around 777. By the time English & Austria were re-activated, there were still 27 units & SC-s occupied, which means that new English player contributed 777/27*8 ~ 230 credits (1007 in total) & Austria 1007/27*3 ~ 111 credits (taking that Austria joined after England, which is the least favorable in terms of proving the case) , making the pot total 1118 credits. Now, when Italy has been taken over, the number of SC-s is 31 & the number of units 28. However the pot is calculated (either SC-s of units, or something else, I have to admit that I still quite don't get it), 1118/31*3 or 1118/28*3, the total pot size can't be bigger than 1226 (or can it?). This calculation should be at least somewhere near to the truth unless some of the countries were taken over during this 5 years by third persons without them making a single move with their units & countries falling into CD again (and even then there should have been several such cases to make the pot size up to 1890).

Just correct me if I have got the points system all wrong (what are the alternative calculation possibilities for points - I know that mine are not 100% correct, as these calculations doesn't seem to correlate with the CD prices in the games list, but would it be possible that I have missed the calculation by 2 times!!?).

I almost got the urge to join the game to prevent Salmaneser or c4l3m having an easy victory :D
Merano (2046 D)
04 Jan 08 UTC
- I requested the game to be stopped some days ago, but was ignored by kestas so far
http://phpdiplomacy.net/index.php?viewthread=258761#258761

@rait: the point inflation is because units in civil disorder do not count to the total number of units when calculating the price for taking over a country in CD; so if almost everyone is in civil disorder, you have to pay a huge portion of the pot in order to join
Rait (10151 D(S))
04 Jan 08 UTC
ok
Brisreb (152 D)
04 Jan 08 UTC
but was ignored by Kestas? odd perhaps he has other things that required his attention.

Dont blame the admin who runs the site just cause someone else is being an idiot.


10 replies
Page 61 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top