Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 120 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Treefarn (6094 D)
22 Jul 08 UTC
Tips for Newbies
On the heads of the 'Stone Age' players thread, I figured maybe this would help. The rules of diplomacy are easy, its the strategy that makes this game difficult AND fun. But newbies frequently fail to think things through.
11 replies
Open
fortknox (2059 D)
22 Jul 08 UTC
50 pot game
Wanted to make a game for semi-noobs, so I figured a 50 pot game would be something a newer player with experience wouldn't mind joining:
<A HREF="http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=4724">http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=4724</A>
0 replies
Open
KaaRoy (0 DX)
21 Jul 08 UTC
Multi-account players
So are there any rules, and how are they enforced, for multi-account players in a game?
6 replies
Open
themonkeymon (100 D)
22 Jul 08 UTC
Uh, a bit of confusion.
In the game bunnies in the wind I am playing as Austria and I moved my unit into on the first turn. On the 2nd turn can I move that army and still keep Serbia or not?
2 replies
Open
andym (148 D)
21 Jul 08 UTC
Rules clarification
If I order a unit to support move, and the supporting unit is attacked, will the support move revert to hold?

If so, will ordering another unit to support hold the original unit provide a second defender?

Thank you.
10 replies
Open
keeper0018 (100 D)
19 Jul 08 UTC
wierd game
this is one of the wierdest games that i have ever played in, check it out... p.s. look at all the pretty colors!!!

http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=4630&msgCountry=Global
9 replies
Open
fortknox (2059 D)
21 Jul 08 UTC
Draw Request 'Quick, no CD, 9am-5pm EST'
I'm Italy and as you can see by the messages, all are in agreement for a draw...
3 replies
Open
Treefarn (6094 D)
21 Jul 08 UTC
Strange Numbers
There was a thread a couple weeks ago pointing out that I had just started game # 4444, and that I had 666 points at the time. My points have hit another unusual number today.
5 replies
Open
DeliciousWolf (112 D)
21 Jul 08 UTC
Rules Question - RETREATS ("Run away! Run Away!")
Okay, say I have a unit on Spain, I'm surrounded on all sides and an attack from Gascony succeeds and I'm forced to retreat. My only retreat option is Gascony, the place the attack came from. Can I retreat there, or am I forced to destroy my unit ? Thanks!
7 replies
Open
8668 (100 D)
14 Jul 08 UTC
Bounce question
Say there is an unestablished French army in Spain (i.e. Spain hasn't been taken yet), that moves to Marseilles while an Italian army is moving to Marseilles as well. The two will bounce off each other, but will Spain be completely captured by France? or will the army in Spain still have that blue box around it that shows that Spain hasn't been captured?
8668 (100 D)
14 Jul 08 UTC
I'm pretty sure France would still get Spain. Someone correct me if I'm wrong?
anlari (8640 D)
14 Jul 08 UTC
France will get Spain.
Fidobot (100 D)
14 Jul 08 UTC
Yeah, I'm pretty sure France gets it. I bounced off Sweden from Denmark in the same situation and got Denmark.
Shisuren (587 D)
14 Jul 08 UTC
Aye, that's one of my favorite (overused) tactics >.>
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
15 Jul 08 UTC
Beware when trying the classic Burgundy/Spain bounce over Marseilles of Italy ordering A Spain to Marseilles.
EdiBirsan (1469 D(B))
19 Jul 08 UTC
I think the classic response to France ordering Burgundy and Spain to Marseilles in Fall of 1901 is for the Italians in Piedmont to
order
A Piedmont Supports Army Spain to Marseilles,
this sucks the French out of Spain instead of into a self bounce.
Edi Birsan
MajorTom (4417 D)
19 Jul 08 UTC
Hmm, I though that one army against another one of the same nation would always result in a bounce, regardless of supports from other units of the same or other nations.

If that isn't the case how would these other senarios resolve?
- 2 French armies moving to an empty territory, 1 of them with support from another French army?
- 1 Italian army supports a French army into an empty territory while another Italian army moves into the same territory unsupported?
orathaic (1009 D(B))
19 Jul 08 UTC
i'm fairly sure
a) two against one the french armies would advance.
or
b) the italian support would hel pthe french into the territory.

you can't cut your own support, so Italy ordering piedmont to support Gulf of lyon into marsielles while also ordering tuscany to piedmont with support from venice, would not cut the piedmont support.

(you only want to do this to stop tyrolia supporting marsielles to piedmont, as mars hitting piedmont doesn't cut the support, but mars with support bounces against tuscany with support, and mars s dislodged. or course you'd normally be better off cutting tyrolia's support, but perhaps you need venice to hold so adr can support it, and not lose to tryolia supporting trieste into venice...) blah this seems rather over convoluted, but i can see it's like happening.
orathaic (1009 D(B))
19 Jul 08 UTC
oh, and no, as itlay you get an ally to lie to france, get (say) austria to tell france that piedmont is going to hold and thus france doesn't order spain to mars.

Actually giving italy a chance of taking marsielles.
(assuming france doesn't have an army in bur)
MajorTom (4417 D)
21 Jul 08 UTC
thanks orthaic, can anyone else affirm the outcomes of these senarios?
Croaker (370 D)
21 Jul 08 UTC
The rule is, as I know it, that you cannot dislodge yourself. If the territory is empty or held by another player, the strongest attack wins.
Chrispminis (916 D)
21 Jul 08 UTC
Well MajorTom, I'm not entirely sure about orathaic's point on not being able to cut your own support...

But I do know that if A-Bur-Mar, A-Spa-Mar, and A-Pie S A-Spa-Mar, would definitely result in Spain overpowering Burgundy and taking Marseilles, thus forfeiting Spain.

You cannot dislodge your own units with your own units. However, I'm fairly sure you can support an attack that dislodges one of your own units.
aoe3rules (949 D)
21 Jul 08 UTC
EdiBirsan: you forgot to mention something: that also means France can't build in Marseilles to attack Italy.


13 replies
sirhc (100 D)
21 Jul 08 UTC
How long does should a game stay in "Your games"?
I got knocked out of "The Spanish vol5" (game 4433) in Autumn 1909 yet it is still listed on my "Your games" page in Autumn 1910. Is this normal, or a bug?
2 replies
Open
RogueMcGyver (455 D)
21 Jul 08 UTC
No Press - One player needed for a CD power
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=4702&join=on&gamepass=e4f24bdd1599f0964abeb92ffb862f35
0 replies
Open
Kent C. Tugood (483 D)
20 Jul 08 UTC
Draw Game Request
After years of Bloodshed, the powers in this game: http://www.phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=4105 have decided to declare a draw.

Their posts shall confirm it soon enough.
2 replies
Open
anlari (8640 D)
19 Jul 08 UTC
Yet Another No Press Game
Anyone interested?
29 replies
Open
Gobbledydook (1389 D(B))
21 Jul 08 UTC
a new 1001-buy-in game?
For us high-rollers.

I am planning on starting a new 1001-buy-in game (PPSC though, don't like betting everything but only having 1/7 chance of getting it back...)though it can be WTA if you all want that...

It should start by the end of this week...and please all interested reply here to sign up.
0 replies
Open
Fidobot (100 D)
20 Jul 08 UTC
Could you support an attack against your own country?
Just a thought. Is it possible to support an attack against your own country?

Say, you were Italy. Could you support an Austrian attack into Italian occupied Venice?
5 replies
Open
belsherj (258 D)
19 Jul 08 UTC
Suspicious activity in "Does backstabbing come with blindsiding"
Turkey and Austria seem to have an unearthly level of cooperation and trust in "Does backstabbing come with blindsiding"

http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=4501

More details in 1st reply.
22 replies
Open
IBethune (519 D)
20 Jul 08 UTC
Feature request
Usually, if a player has no choice in their orders i.e. it's a Build phase and they have no builds/destroys or it's a Retreat phase and they have no retreats, then they get automatically finalized so nobody has to wait for that player to log in and finalize their blank orders.

There is one case that is missing - if a player has a retreat to make, but there are no valid areas to retreat to (they are surrounded, or it's an army and the only free areas are sea etc.) - in this case, they have to submit an order, but the drop-down list says - no valid destinations if you choose retreat, so you must choose submit.

Would it be possible in this case to auto-select that order and finalize the orders if there are no others for which a choice must be made?
5 replies
Open
Hyperactive Jam (299 D)
20 Jul 08 UTC
9 SC Austria in CD
http://www.phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=4483&msgCountry=Austria
0 replies
Open
cteno4 (100 D)
17 Jul 08 UTC
Point division upon end of PPSC games
What is the cap on the number of points a winner of a PPSC game can win?
10 replies
Open
Iidhaegn (111 D)
18 Jul 08 UTC
Civil Disorder
Is it considered good etiquette to go CD if everyone knows you're going to lose? (I know that only one of my games has someone CD, and I'm not trying to point fingers. I've just seen this a lot as I've looked down the games list.)
13 replies
Open
MadMarx (36299 D(G))
19 Jul 08 UTC
Kestas, why no reset to 100 points?
I'm a mere political puppet with a single point and was hoping to join a new no press game after just being eliminated from a game that ended on the same turn (Thermopylae), but no points, can you help me out?
8 replies
Open
DeliciousWolf (112 D)
18 Jul 08 UTC
Builds Question
Let's say I've lost my three original SCs, but I've captured several others elsewhere. Can I build at all ? Must I recapture one of my original SCs before building again?
9 replies
Open
thewonderllama (100 D)
19 Jul 08 UTC
UK member needed for non-Diplomacy related help
I live in the US and am trying to have a certain item shipped to me from the UK. Unfortunately, the distillery in question does not export the item in question. As I don't know anyone in the UK *not* from this site, I figured I'd make my plea here.

Is there any UK resident who'd be willing to let me use his or her address for delivery and then ship it along to me, postage and some sort of token of appreciation paid by me?
7 replies
Open
markthomas (110 D)
19 Jul 08 UTC
Support hold didn't work in game #4459
Hello, in game #4459 I support held Marseilles from Gascony, and Gascony wasn't attacked, yet the support from Gascony was broken. Is this possibly a bug?

Thanks.
5 replies
Open
Stevelers (3084 D(G))
17 Jul 08 UTC
Global Press Game, Round Two?
I just finished up a Global Press variant, and I found it to be a very interesting change to the game, and I'd like to start up a new one. I'd like to have some of the players back from the first game, although all are welcome to join, just express your interest here!
35 replies
Open
keeper0018 (100 D)
19 Jul 08 UTC
civil disorders
when i first joined this site, it used to be that in order for a country to go into civil disorder (CD), that player had to miss 3 consecutive turns. however, i just took over a country in a game that's only in the winter 1901 phase, where it is not possible for the player to miss 3 consecutive turns (none of his SC's were taken over, so he didn't have to retreat at all)... is it that if a country enters no orders for the entire first year they are replaced, or have the entire CD rules changed?
2 replies
Open
Dwon (100 D)
19 Jul 08 UTC
Think about it
If I can talk you into this game have I not already won?
Come on now, I am a new player and I want to give this a try.
0 replies
Open
Shino (113 D)
19 Jul 08 UTC
Macross frontier
New game 50 point kick in fee
0 replies
Open
fraushai (1781 D)
19 Jul 08 UTC
10,000 pot PPSC game
It's called etat de siege. Join here:
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=4689
5 replies
Open
Page 120 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top