Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 1326 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
peterlund (1310 D(G))
20 Jun 16 UTC
Report from a Donald Trump rally
http://politicalscrapbook.net/2016/06/a-journalist-went-to-a-donald-trump-rally-yesterday-and-came-back-shocked-here-are-his-tweets/
And this clown/maniac/new Hitler will be the republican party nominee. Shame on you.
94 replies
Open
JimTheGrey (968 D(S))
25 May 16 UTC
(+4)
WDC: One-Month Warning!
First stab at the 2016 World Diplomacy Championship in Chicago is one month from today. More info at http://windycityweasels.org/wdc2016
37 replies
Open
peterlund (1310 D(G))
08 Jul 16 UTC
(+1)
Policeman in USA murders black man already lying on the ground
How disgusting can things be? I thought I had seen it all, but NO I had not ;(
18 replies
Open
faded box (100 D)
09 Jul 16 UTC
Quick Question
I'm trying to figure out if I can move from east Caribbean sea to the island "DOM" dominican rep."Modern dipo 2". Is there like a hex map I can look at, that shows all moves
1 reply
Open
brainbomb (290 D)
09 Jul 16 UTC
What kind of cat food should I feed my cat?
I've been giving her surfin turfin treats. But I gave her a can of friskies the other day and she hardly touched it. Shes 5, and seems to eat too much actually.
2 replies
Open
DammmmDaniel (100 D)
08 Jul 16 UTC
Pokemon Go
Any one else think that this game is great asf!!??!?!?!?!?! THIS IS MY CHILDHOOD IN REAL LIFE IM FUCKING FREAKING OUT
MY pkmn are actually really good as a side note ;) top 3 have over 200 CP :)
2 replies
Open
glo2018 (1697 D)
03 Jul 16 UTC
Qustion about scoring system
in this game (http://95.211.128.12/webdiplomacy/board.php?gameID=92049#gamePanel) i saw a scoring system called Survivors-Win Scoring, but when i tried to create a game with this type of point scoring system i couldn't find it in the advanced settings. so, my question is, how do i create a game with this type of scoring system?
3 replies
Open
abgemacht (1076 D(G))
08 Jul 16 UTC
(+1)
Mario Machine Learning on Twitch
https://www.twitch.tv/mikseri123321

If anyone is interested; we're doing some basic optimizations to get a computer to play Mario
2 replies
Open
bo_sox48 (5202 DMod(G))
06 Jul 16 UTC
(+4)
Turning Over a New Leaf
I just want to take a moment to say that I've been so proud of this forum in the last few days. The entire world has been buzzing with insanely controversial, easily polarizing political events in the past few days and we haven't had a vitriolic, stupidly biased thread so far. Kudos to everyone.
23 replies
Open
Ogion (3882 D)
08 Jul 16 UTC
Weekend sitter needed for two early gunboat games
Hey folks,
I'm heading out for a weekend, and I have two 24 hour phase games that will need some builds and the like entered. Should be pretty easy.
Any takers?
2 replies
Open
ssorenn (0 DX)
29 Jun 16 UTC
I'm in London for two days.
Where should I eat ??
8 replies
Open
glo2018 (1697 D)
06 Jul 16 UTC
one more person
i have a live game starting in 2 hours called Amazing game (http://95.211.128.12/webdiplomacy/board.php?gameID=180862) i just need one more player, please join.
1 reply
Open
steephie22 (182 D(S))
29 Jun 16 UTC
How much would building an island for a million people in international waters cost?
I'm talking excluding living supplies etc. Just building the island. Alternatively, an island chain will do too.

Just some big numbers-math for fun. Anyone wants to do an estimate?
37 replies
Open
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
04 Jul 16 UTC
(+2)
The Boston Massacre / webDip F2F tournament
As above, within this intertubelink:
https://sites.google.com/site/bostonmassacrediplomacy/tournament-info

4 replies
Open
Halls of Mandos (1019 D)
05 Jul 16 UTC
World Game
It's that time again!
I was thinking of starting a world game some time early August when I get home. Post below if interested:
0 replies
Open
TrPrado (461 D)
17 May 16 UTC
NBA Finals
We're now at the Conference finals for both West and East, and the first game was last night. What do you guys think? Could this be the Thunder's year to win it all?
196 replies
Open
Hamilton Brian (811 D(B))
01 Jul 16 UTC
(+4)
Happy Canada Day
Someone had to start this thread. Happy 149th Birthday!
9 replies
Open
KingCyrus (511 D)
27 Jun 16 UTC
Special Replacement Needed
Good evening webDip. I am in need of a replacement for a special rule UN game.
10 replies
Open
paulyork64 (351 D)
27 Jun 16 UTC
(+2)
Brexit swiftly followed by Engxit
Congratulations iceland. You were great. We were garbage. I will support your campaign to be a supply centre on the diplomacy map.
14 replies
Open
taos (281 D)
01 Jul 16 UTC
(+2)
taos is back!
Hi !
I am back to the game after more than a year.
If you know me so please join my game and if you don't know me join too.
Many changes since i was inactive?
4 replies
Open
Valis2501 (2850 D(G))
23 Jun 16 UTC
(+2)
WDC 2016 #weaselmoot Live Thread
The 2016 World Diplomacy Championships are happening!

http://www.windycityweasels.org/wdc2016
https://twitter.com/WindyCityWeasel
80 replies
Open
orathaic (1009 D(B))
22 Jun 16 UTC
Any exercise in hypotheticals
http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20160621-i-have-never-felt-sexual-desire

What do these people want? And are their demands reasonable?
39 replies
Open
jengamaster (2132 D)
23 Jun 16 UTC
(+1)
Why do you simply save and not ready?
Unless you always save, or you always ready, which conditions lead to you choosing to do one or the other?
22 replies
Open
brainbomb (290 D)
28 Jun 16 UTC
Game of thrones - S6 - reactions
Discuss.
20 replies
Open
Crazy Anglican (1067 D)
20 May 16 UTC
Vegetarians, Vegans, et al.
I am just getting started with this lifestyle change. I am leaning towards a whole foods plant based diet as in Plant Pure Nation. Any suggestions of things to try? Recipes? etc.
110 replies
Open
????? (0 DX)
27 Jun 16 UTC
Question: Can you message during builds?
I am new to the website. I don't seem to be able to message during the build phase?
2 replies
Open
Jamiet99uk (808 D)
16 Jun 16 UTC
Mafia XXI Sign-Up Thread
This thread is for signing up to play PROHIBITION WARS, which is the 21st game of Forum Mafia. There are up to 22 slots available however the game can be played with less than this. I would ideally like 20 participants at least.
233 replies
Open
WDC 2016 (0 DX)
25 Jun 16 UTC
(+1)
WDC 2016 Live coverage Sunday
Live coverage of World Diplomacy Championship Final Table.
9:00Am Sunday (East coast USA time)
Twitch.tv/diplomacycast
@DiplomacyCast for more info
16 replies
Open
y2kjbk (4846 D(G))
24 Jun 16 UTC
(+1)
Higher stakes gunboat games
Stop on in for higher stakes gunboat games.
6 replies
Open
kasimax (243 D)
14 Apr 16 UTC
(+5)
public commentary gunboat - peanut gallery
gameID=177609

read the rules inside before you post!
Page 6 of 8
FirstPreviousNextLast
 
Patburu (0 DX)
25 Apr 16 UTC
I'm going to go by how i rank the players in how they've done and who I think has the best odds of winning

1. Austria
Very solid game so far and looks to be going after Turkey with the fleet moving to Albania. The one worry is the Turkish fleet in the Black Sea. If Russia decides to hit Galicia, it makes the Austrian support system a guessing game that Turkey could capitalize on.

2. Turkey
Despite being on par with three other 5 SC nations and having a solid chance of losing Moscow, I think Turkey has the second best chance to move forward in this game. The Russian player is absolutely clueless it seems, so there is a good chance Turkey won't lose an SC this year. Even if he loses Moscow, a retreat to St. Petersburg may be very possible. The guessing game I spoke about if Russia cuts Galician support also gives Turkey a great chance to gain ground on Austria. Whichever of those two wins out should be the winner of the Eastern game with Russia a non-factor and Italy occupied in the West.

3. France
I'm hard pressed to put the one Western country with a home SC occupied in this spot, but his way to SC number 6 just seems much easier than anyone else's. He is deadlocked in the south with Italy. However, a Burgundian jump into Munich is begging. He also has English SC's just 2 moves away, depending on where that Yorkshire army is planning to convoy to.

4. Germany
I think Germany had the chance to absolutely dominate the West early on and he missed the boat by helping France into Belgium. That being said, he's still in a tremendous position. He has a great chance to secure Sweden this year and get that sixth SC. His issue is that England has outpaced him in fleets, even though he has 1 less SC. Priority one should be figuring out a way to get a fleet built in Kiel. Whether France looks to move to Munich will be a huge factor in German control of the West.

5. Italy
Italy was bold in the early game and it paid off, giving him 2 builds and 5 SC's after the first year. His greatest mistake, in my opinion, was building a third army instead of a third fleet He is in a better situation than most Italys, who are on their back heels by this point, but he is absolutely deadlocked with France, and it seems as if there is no way forward. I would have loved to put him higher on this list, but I don't know where SC number 6 is coming from.

6. England
Number 6 is not as bad as it seems. There's an argument for anyone in the West to be anywhere from 3-6, and one brilliant move by any of them could move them into an obvious 2. That out of the way, England is going to have difficulty expanding because of his lack of units. He could move Yorkshire into Scandinavia, but that will leave the mainland completely empty, not a position I would be very comfortable with. He does have Germany in a tough spot, though, and he should be able to keep his units stationary for the most part trying to hold the coast. A 5th unit would be immensely helpful, and Brest is just across the channel.

7. Russia
This is obvious enough. Down to 3 units, a Turkish fleet in Sevastopol and an army in Moscow He looks to be trying to hang onto Scandinavia when there are more pressing issues. I can't see him making it to 1905 unless someone is using him as a buffer for their own territories.
thorfi (1023 D)
25 Apr 16 UTC
Movement is in! No retreats. Whee.

@Germany whaat? Mun-Ruh? Are you begging for France to take Munich?

Does anyone else have a plausible explanation for A Ruh? Because I don't see one, but maybe I am missing something. And Sweden is a long way from guaranteed thanks to F Nth.

The RTA hate triangle is still a triangle, lol
Patburu (0 DX)
25 Apr 16 UTC
army Mun-Ruh is to support hold Holland. Ironically, it may end up costing him an SC
thorfi (1023 D)
25 Apr 16 UTC
Hrm. Yeah. Dubious.
paulyork64 (351 D)
26 Apr 16 UTC
Patb. I agree england needs to leave the army at home to guard against a french attack.

Think russia will now make a supported attack on moscow but this gains little if norway doesnt block the retreat to st pete. So norway could be a freebie for england but can he keep hold of sweden too to get a build.
paulyork64 (351 D)
26 Apr 16 UTC
If austria goes to ionian does he risk distracting italy. The italy- france stalemate suits him just fine for now.
thorfi (1023 D)
27 Apr 16 UTC
Oh man, that spare Italian army sitting around doing nothing for the whole game... painful.

What Austria does with F Ion is gonna be interesting, regardless of where it goes. :-)
paulyork64 (351 D)
27 Apr 16 UTC
Think that army mat have to cover naples just to be safe. Surprised the fleet didnt retreat to tunis.

Which unit will france disband i wonder.

England really didnt need germany getting a build. Will be hard to keep denmark or take sweden so he could be back down to 4 and germany up to 7.
trip (696 D(B))
28 Apr 16 UTC
Bump
principians (881 D)
29 Apr 16 UTC
(+2)
if England just were aware there are convoys in this game
seth24c (5659 D)
30 Apr 16 UTC
Bump, us players are desperately in need of your expert opinions.
Patburu (0 DX)
30 Apr 16 UTC
wow completely new lease on life for Russia.
MajorMitchell (1874 D)
30 Apr 16 UTC
04_retreats after a quick glance, I like moves from player with Germany..helping Russia get Norway and invading France....and the Austria, Turkey Russia squabble is providing it's usual and amusing sc roundabout
MajorMitchell (1874 D)
30 Apr 16 UTC
OK had a look for those discussion rules on page one...ummmm...couldn't find them....had a look at maps to see moves in game...I think the player with Austria did well to pull of the high risk strategy of not occupying Serbia in the first year that gained him Rumania I like player with Italy's game, ally with Austria but leave Russia and Turkey to him and go for France

at the. retreats 04 stage..
I think England is in a difficult position strategically, if France falls and Italy breaks out to MAO...needs to get Russia and Germany fighting each other...
Two pairs, Austria & Italy cooperating for a short time with Germany and Russia to eliminate France England and Turkey...???
Peregrine Falcon (9010 D(S))
30 Apr 16 UTC
(+1)
@MM: It's the very first post of the thread. Not that hard to find.
Bump
kasimax (243 D)
02 May 16 UTC
wow turkey is still attacking russia?
kasimax (243 D)
04 May 16 UTC
now's probably the last chance for turkey to start working with russia.
principians (881 D)
05 May 16 UTC
(+1)
kasimax, have you been putting attention?
Turkey actually tried to retreat since spring 03, maybe he could have made clearer moves, but if he has only 3 units now, it's cos he decided to follow the thread suggestion of starting work with Russia
principians (881 D)
05 May 16 UTC
(+1)
of course, when he sees that Russia won't hear, well, it seems he's not sooo interested now
principians (881 D)
05 May 16 UTC
Now it seems too late, Turkey won't be able to keep the fight for long. And France has a disaster. Now the Italy-Austria alliance is in his way to just walk over the board.
kasimax (243 D)
07 May 16 UTC
game-changing nmr from austria.
seth24c (5659 D)
07 May 16 UTC
(+1)
Let's get some more commentary, come on folks you don't get this opportunity often.
Lethologica (203 D)
07 May 16 UTC
It's only game-changing if Italy decides to change directions. Otherwise, War was always a bit of a speculative unit, and Turkey's still going to die. I'm not sure what would change with, say, Bud in Gal, or Alb in Gre.
kasimax (243 D)
11 May 16 UTC
well, turns out leth was right. nmr isn't that much of a game-changer. unless something surprising happens, a 3-way draw between germany italy and austria is the most obvious result at the moment. if one of those countries wants to change that, the eventually have to think about who they'd do that.
thorfi (1023 D)
12 May 16 UTC
France is dead, long live France.

Turkey is toast in short order, this seems certain.

England, maybe not trivial - there are guessing games to be had, so might die fast, might take quite a bit longer.

Russia will live for a while yet - I can't imagine Germany can really afford to send units in his direction, and Austria will have to clean out Turkey before he can really make headway, no?

Italy's the only one of the three already straddling the main stalemate line... Not that that's the only thing that matters, of course. :-) 1SC stabs where the stabbed is likely to be picking up at least 1SC if not more elsewhere are a bit foolish, so that seems not too likely.

Germany I think is in for some deep issues within the next couple of years, but we'll see what happens.

Austria has plenty of slow growth available, but IMO must be having a slightly itchy back, even if Italy stabbing shouldn't be a serious concern yet. :-)
NoFog (9073 D)
12 May 16 UTC
Autumn 1906. Question: What is the benefit of Italy moving F Western Med to Spain? Answer: There is none. Supporting Portugal to MidAtlantic would be the natural and better choice.
NoFog (9073 D)
12 May 16 UTC
Why did Turkey not move F Con to Aegean Sea to at least postpone Austia for a turn? Austrian moves were quite obvious.
thorfi (1023 D)
13 May 16 UTC
"Why did Turkey not move F Con to Aegean Sea" - insufficient consideration of all the units involved? Doing so would risk losing Con but only in the case of use of F Smy to take Con, so still only 1 SC down. And maybe arguably Con down is better than Smy down, but it's pretty marginal, really. Either way you're looking at a disband, and I'm not actually sure that Austrian F Gre instead of F Aeg would make much difference. Con is gone by the end of this year anyway, and Ank isn't (barring some outlandish Austrian attempt at convoying and shuffling which is probably asking for just failing to even take Con). And next year Ank would be gone either way.
NoFog (9073 D)
14 May 16 UTC
@Thorfi. I like to give you a full analysis of the Autumn-1906-situation between Austria and Turkey.

Let us first define some sets of moves the players could consider:
Turkish alternatives were:
T1 := [F Con support move to Smyrna from Syria, F Ankara support hold Con, A Syria move to Smyrna]
T2 := [F Con move to Aegean Sea, F Ankara move to Con, A Syria move to Smyrna]
Austrian alternatives were:
A1 := [F Greece move to Aegean Sea, A Bul move to Con, F Smyrna support move to Con from Bul, F Eastern Med support hold Smyrna]
A2 := [F Greece move to Aegean Sea, A Bul support move to Con from Smyrna, F Smyrna move to Con, F Eastern move to Smyrna]

My claim is Turkey should go for T2, while you claim T1 would result in a better or indifferent outcome for Turkey. (A look on the board shows T2 would have been better than T1 given what Austria did, assuming that you agree that an Austrian fleet in Greece is "better" (or less worse) than an Austrian fleet in Aegean Sea (see later.)).

First let us have a look on the general situation of each player:
On the one side Austria is in a very good position, so he has no need to play risky moves, but can slowly develop his armies/fleets and can try (and will manage!) to take out one Turkish SC each year.
On the other side Turkey is in a very bad situation and will likely be eliminated by Austria, if nothing happens. Here comes the crucial point: he has to hope that something happens in his favor elsewhere on the board (like an Italian stab) to distract Austria. So to better his chances of surviving, he has to postpone Austria to extend the time, so something can happen.

You will agree that Austria is postponed if his fleet is not in Aegean Sea but in Greece at the end of 1906, won't you? You may argue it is only a slight advantage, but is definitely a ">"-situation, not just a "=". So it is something to play for. If you want to improve as a player you always have to collect theses small advantages. You may still lose from time to time, but your overall performance will rise.
So why will Austria not play A2? Because it is a risky move - remember no risky moves needed for Austria. Since if Turkey plays T1, which is not that unlikely (he did it in this game!), Austria gets his fleet in Smyrna destroyed and Turkey still has all his 3 SCs. Not to mention that this fleet needed years to get there. In a (T2,A2)-situation Austria would still only get 2 SCs, so there is no real reward for that risk! In conclusion: Never ever would Austria go for A2!

Now if Austria does A1, Turkey is better off with T2, because it results in no fleet in Aegean Sea. To conclude: T2 is superior to T1. My claim follows.

Page 6 of 8
FirstPreviousNextLast
 

218 replies
Page 1326 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top