Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 349 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
trainedkilla (444 D)
03 Sep 09 UTC
Quick Question
Can a fleet in Greece support another fleet's hold on the north coast of Bulgaria even though the fleet in Greece is unable to move to the north coast of Bulgaria from Greece?
15 replies
Open
Hamilton (137 D)
28 Aug 09 UTC
Hallucinogens
See Below, don't read if not interested.
184 replies
Open
Plastic Hussar (1375 D(B))
03 Sep 09 UTC
75 pt PPSC game: Rust Never Sleeps2
We tried this once, but England left the game in Spring 01. So now we are trying again. Five of the six who joined that game have signed up, so that leaves two open spots. Looking for someone who won't go CD. Password and game ID inside.
2 replies
Open
Attavior (1677 D)
03 Sep 09 UTC
Possible Error (Bug Reporting??)
It is a gunboat game so I am not sure if I can even post this, but I believe that there has been a error in the way that my moves have been processed. IT has happened twice (if I understand the rules correctly)
8 replies
Open
Zman (207 D)
03 Sep 09 UTC
Attack Question
Ok so:
Unit A and Unit B are attacking Unit C (A attacks, B supports.) Unit C attacks Unit A with support of Unit D. Unit E attacks Unit A's area with supp from Unit F.

Whats the result?
28 replies
Open
Bonotow (782 D)
03 Sep 09 UTC
Problem with a paused game
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=12924
We have paused but it says Next Phase: Now!
Was quite a shock when I looked at the game without having orders in so far and it says "Now" :-o
2 replies
Open
Ice Cold (130 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
Bug found. Pls look into it in 24 hours.
Bug found. Support move counts even after it was neutralised. More inside.
10 replies
Open
Timmi88 (190 D)
03 Sep 09 UTC
why did this move fail...
http://webdiplomacy.net/mapstore/117/11784/15-largemap.png
this move in in this game
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=11784#gamePanel
4 replies
Open
Jenny (1327 D)
01 Sep 09 UTC
Retreats
If somebody has to enter retreat orders but doesn't do so (e.g because he misses his turn or is in CD), what happens to the unit? There are several adjacent empty territories that the unit could theoretically retreat to. Thanks!
12 replies
Open
New WTA
I haven't been keen on a bit o WTA so I"m hoping this will help adapt me. Who wants in? WTA 50 point buy in.

http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=13114
pass: WTA
13 replies
Open
Serioussham (446 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
orders didn't process??
gameID=12940
is there any way of going back in time or am i just screwed now??
9 replies
Open
Tantris (2456 D)
28 Aug 09 UTC
Someone deciding they don't want to continue
So, I am in a few games right now. It seems like in most of the games I am in, someone has stopped entering moves. In one game, someone just announced they were not going to enter anymore moves, because they suspected someone of meta-gaming. They said they had no proof at all, the game was just making them "uncomfortable". It happened after the game started turning against them.
34 replies
Open
soccerblocker (159 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
Young Napoleans BDP Club!
Join the game. The password is our teacher's name NO Mr. NO caps
like that ---> mck***a
0 replies
Open
jmo1121109 (3812 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
Come and join SemiNoobs8 Gunboat (No Talking Allowed)
For new players or players who just want a cheap gunboat. 10 point buy in, points per supply center. All welcome!

Link:
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=13137
0 replies
Open
Le_Roi (913 D)
01 Sep 09 UTC
New WTA game
See inside.
16 replies
Open
DJEcc24 (246 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
sourceforge.net
i recently made an account but it says i haven't. does it need to accept me before i can sign in
2 replies
Open
DJEcc24 (246 D)
31 Aug 09 UTC
Ancient Mediterranean map
see more

45 replies
Open
Evilbert (361 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
Missing Unit
gameID=12861
Last turn I (at least I thought I did) put in build orders for fleet in Brest and army in Paris. I should have 6 units now but I only have five, the Paris army never arrived. The orders archive only has the order to build a fleet in Brest listed. Now, this is my first game, so I'm in no way ruling out that I made a mistake but I didn't think the finalize option appeared unless there were valid orders entered?
Maybe they're just having a glass of wine first...?
3 replies
Open
rlumley (0 DX)
31 Aug 09 UTC
Quadruple Russian Build
Has anyone ever gotten one in Autumn 1901? It'd be awesome to see I'd think, but of course would come down to a tremendous amount of luck...
Page 2 of 3
FirstPreviousNextLast
 
djbent (2572 D(S))
31 Aug 09 UTC
@StevenC - my most recently finished game was finished weeks ago, but it still says "Sun 6am" or whatever. it doesn't have a date. so, that's what i was basing it on. i don't know why some have dates and others don't, though.
StevenC. (1047 D(B))
31 Aug 09 UTC
It's probably the much older games that have dates.
Draugnar (0 DX)
31 Aug 09 UTC
But the question is are the mods going to do anything about it?
Draugnar (0 DX)
31 Aug 09 UTC
And how do these wins affect his Ghost-rating?
Xapi (194 D)
31 Aug 09 UTC
Draugnar, take your pills and wait, I'm sure the mods will take care of it in time.
Draugnar (0 DX)
31 Aug 09 UTC
I am. I just thought about the ramifications of someone cheating for such a large sum so long ago. Especially someone who actually has demonstrated he can play. It just boggles the mind...
djbent (2572 D(S))
31 Aug 09 UTC
yeah, it's really stupid. but he went CD in the league and hasn't shown up since, so i think it may all be a moot point. so do you think mods should waste time investigating it now, or only if he returns? i don't know, tbh.
Draugnar (0 DX)
31 Aug 09 UTC
It's only one person, but it does have some effect on the Ghost ratings, but I guess he'll drop down the list over time not playing any games.
Maniac (189 D(B))
31 Aug 09 UTC
I once opened up with St P to GoB, Mos-St P, War-Ukr and Sev-Black Sea. England and Turkey both NMR so the quadruple was on. Unfortunately Turkey woke up and I only got a triple :(
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
31 Aug 09 UTC
All of the data has been deleted for him, because it happened quite a while ago.
amonkeyperson (100 D)
31 Aug 09 UTC
All part of his master plan....
Jamiet99uk (865 D)
01 Sep 09 UTC
I think this guy needs to be banned. This is one of the most obvious cases of multi-accounting I have ever seen. Ban him at once please, mods.
Draugnar (0 DX)
01 Sep 09 UTC
He may have gone away anyways, but ban the account for multi-ing so it no longer appears near the top of the list here and will completely fall off the Ghost-ratings.
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
01 Sep 09 UTC
Banned accounts don't as yet fall off the G-Rating lists.
Centurian (3257 D)
01 Sep 09 UTC
Not that he has been banned...
jmo1121109 (3812 D)
01 Sep 09 UTC
while we are on this topic please take a look at http://www.webdiplomacy.net/profile.php?userID=12043
this is just blatant multi accounting..
Yes, ban him lol

At least he took a bit of time with the names ^_^
Jamiet99uk (865 D)
01 Sep 09 UTC
It does look very suspect.
mapleleaf (0 DX)
01 Sep 09 UTC
Will someone please name all of rratcliff's account names please? Has he been banned?
spyman (424 D(G))
01 Sep 09 UTC
Is rratcliff the highest ranking multi-accounter ever? (assuming there isn't an innocent explanation for everything - which seems doubtful).
Not to seem retarded but I first played Diplomacy (web or otherwise) about two weeks ago. What exactly are the mods? How does someone work out a ranking system? If, like I'm guessing, the rankings aren't based directly on points, how does multi-accounting actually give you an edge? Also, how much of this is actually skill? To me it looks more like the WSOP than the World Series in terms of the consistency in which skilled players win games. Rebuttal?
denis (864 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
well its all you in diplomacy no dice the only thing up to chance is the country selection and you can't now whats in the mind of your opponent and on this site rank equals points but not the case with ghost rating
redcrane (1045 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
I can just hear Denis gasping for breath
Mods are moderators. They keep everything in check.

If you get the chance, bow down ad kneel to any mods passing by

Acosmist (0 DX)
02 Sep 09 UTC
Well, country selection isn't really up to chance, as the buggy system here seems to make sure you get the same country several games running!
Alderian (2425 D(S))
02 Sep 09 UTC
The Ghostmaker's ranking system I believe is based on the ELO Chess ranking system. The better you do against better players the higher you climb. Beat someone you should beat and you don't get much credit. Lose to someone you shouldn't lose to and you drop.

If you mean the Rank on your profile, that is based on your available points and isn't terribly meaningful.

Multi-accounting gives you an edge in many ways. Allows you to sniff out what other players are really up to by hearing two sides of every tale. Allows you to sacrifice one country to benefit another, directly or indirectly. If done to gather points, having a higher amount of points allows one to be in better quality of games, with more experienced players and those who are less likely to go CD.

Funny that you should mention the World Series. In baseball if you can hit the ball 1 out of 3 times that is considered pretty good, right? On base percentage of half the time would be good right? So if a player can win or draw, against 6 other players a third to half the time, that's doing pretty dang good. And yes, the good players know the board, know peoples motivations, know what to say and how to say it to get the results they want. Not all the time, but enough of the time that they are more likely to end up on top than not.
spyman (424 D(G))
02 Sep 09 UTC
@LJ Tyler Durden - this game requires an enourmous amount of skill. (Too much for me sometime as it frequently makes my brain hurt.)
There is however an element of luck as you have deal with six other people - and their actions can be difficult to predict. The most skillful players win around half of their games I think).
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
Success rates (which I define as % of games won or drawn) of some top players:

cgwhite: 53%
Akroma: 67%
Madmarx: 67%
Babak: 65%
Jacob: 81%
V+: 69%
ag7433: 57%
Ivo_Ivanov: 60%
sean: 54%
Braveheart: 56%
Rait: 62% (With 52% win rate)
turley (117 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
is rratcliff banned yet? look at the autumn 1903 moves. All sorts of fishyness, such as germany literally handing over supply centres over to russia
jmo1121109 (3812 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
hey, ghostmaker, will you humor me and take a look at this account and the games he has won. I noticed in the new games column that a player with a fair amount of points was in a 600 point pot with 5 newbies who joined on the same day. After looking at the games with the rest of the people in my current games we all decided it was suspicious.
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/profile.php?userID=12043
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=13098#gamePanel
log in times are close for the suspect users.
Jamiet99uk (865 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
There's no need to further demonstrate that rratcliff has been guilty of cheating.

Come on, Ghostie, is he banned?

Page 2 of 3
FirstPreviousNextLast
 

69 replies
Persephone (100 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
How do you un-pause a game stuck in pause?
We voted for a pause 4 days ago, and all cancelled the pause 2 days ago, but its stuck in pause mode. Any info, much appreciated.
9 replies
Open
hellalt (80 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
Ghost Ranking 400-1000 game
If you are ranked anywhere between position no 400 and position no 1000 in the ghost rankings and you are interested in joining a game with players of your level say the word here and I'll create one. Also, try suggesting bet size, pace and whether you want it to be a WTA or ppsc game.
3 replies
Open
rlumley (0 DX)
02 Sep 09 UTC
Silent Night
Holy Night.
3 replies
Open
Jamiet99uk (865 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
Milking every last point...
Just a quick query. If you draw a game, the pot is split between the survivors. No problems there. But what if the pot does not divide evenly between the number of survivors? Does it round up, round down, or round to the nearest whole number? Thanks.
2 replies
Open
hellalt (80 D)
01 Sep 09 UTC
Ghost Rating 400-1000 game
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=13118
message me for the password
5 replies
Open
mb (549 D)
01 Sep 09 UTC
Why are new 6-player games cancelled?
We are a group of 6 who know each other in real life and have started a private game here. We expected the system to set Italy to CD like it was being done in phpdiplomacy. Now the game has been cancelled.

13 replies
Open
StevenC. (1047 D(B))
30 Aug 09 UTC
New Diplomacy 5.1: Allies vs Central Powers
24 hour phases
5 D bet
You must be committed to playing the whole game!
15 replies
Open
Crazy Anglican (1067 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
Starry, Starry Night
Paint your palate blue and gray...
3 replies
Open
denis (864 D)
01 Sep 09 UTC
Player Piano by Kurt Vonnegut
is it a good book having trouble Starting it and discouraged by the back
14 replies
Open
Crazy Anglican (1067 D)
02 Sep 09 UTC
I really don't mind if you sit this one out....
My word's but a whisper, your deafness a shout..
3 replies
Open
trainedkilla (444 D)
29 Aug 09 UTC
The Hurt Locker
Straight up, this movie stinks. I don't understand why it has received such good reviews. I almost walked out. I wasn't the only one in the theater who felt that way. Anyone who's seen it disagree?
10 replies
Open
Page 349 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top