And that cleared him? Wouldn't it be the ideal claim for scum then? That claim was NAI and complete wifom.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Jul 27, 2019 3:44 pm
You are incorrect if you think I have been assuming you are scum, and I am certainly not basing my reads off of it. I would say the opposite is true, I suspect you are scum because I do not see where your reads are coming from. emc claimed tree stump D1, with all of the scum fake claim roles available.
How could I know? I knew nothing about Hosuke, and still know very little. And if you remember, my starting position was NOT to lynch him, and the only reason I wanted to make a wagon on him was because he was the best way I had to save damo and Percy. And there was zero chance of a mislynch there. And if we lynched him correctly I was pretty sure Fox would be scum with him. And exposing the masons was not a big deal, because if we didn't do it that day we would have to do it the next day as Hosuke would still remain a talking point. I already explained this to you, so the fact you keep bringing it up is part of what makes me think you're scum.Do you really think ItsHosuke, as a new player, is equally as likely to choose a fake role to claim without being able to talk to his teammates as he is to claim his real role as town?
These were obvious town claims to me, yet you helped lynch emc D2 after forcing Foxcastle to reveal on the premise you did not believe ItsHosuke.
They were not obvious town claims to me, neither of them.
Fine, as I said I don't fully townclear them. You wanting to lynch Chaqa could even be justifiable. Your scumread of me I think is hard to justify, but I may not be objective there. Some of your other actions this game (regarding damo for example) I find very hard to justify.However, when Percy and Chaqa claim under pressure, you are confident they are town. My read on all four has nothing to do with what I think of your alignment. It is possible Percy and Chaqa are town and I am missing scum in flash, foodcoats, and Jamie, but I do not like how Percy and Chaqa are getting by after making scum indicative claims under pressure.