M1036 Flipless Coven Hunt I Game Thread

[Jamiet99uk]

I have been wrong in the past, and chomps' vote is more likely to be a scum voting a town. What I was saying here is that chomps is mafia

No. You don't get to deathtunnel someone and then abandon that at the flick of a switch because someone else did something that triggers you.

That's either scummy or moronic.

Now I have to wonder which.

this is an interesting post from jamie thinking abt his connection with dw. he was parked on dw at eod d1, and was voting him sod today, but interestingly jumped off when dw garnered a proper wagon. ofc this could just be town but i do think this doesn't feel a scum jamie pushing a town dw. so i think if jamie is scum he is almost always paired with dw and if he is town is says nothing about dw's alignment, thus ##vote diploma cyan should maybe be the better vote from my worldview but idk

I'm town.

[Jamiet99uk]

actually maybe i should keep pressure on jamie anyways if I scum read him a bit and dw already has a sizable wagon

##vote jamie

still also need to look at glitter and especially her relationship with dw

Pressure why?

Is there something you want me to answer? I am today's top poster. I am not hiding anything.

[Jamiet99uk]

And I'm caught up!

@Jamie, in case you skipped/missed my previous @you: you missed Bofa's clear and explicit claim saying that it went exactly like I said it did (and that he loves me...star crossed love, but still...).

I quoted it....

Yes you did, but why did Bona then explicity deny having claimed?

[Jamiet99uk]

that was literally me saying bing bing bong and nothing else

Also "it's a role claim"

You also said that I was going to get drummed, right before the shot rang out and you got excited because you thought it hit.

nope, i submitted the shot considerably before the third mouse was outed and so by that time i knew it missed

So now you are back to claiming sniper after all.

Ok.

[Jamiet99uk]

midway through day 1 i decided that the most likely scenario was that yavu was likely scum trying to get the third, then unclaimed mouse the poison. i took a pot shot at who i believed that third mouse was, as i did not plan on asking.<snip>

Based on this, why did you not shoot yavu and guarantee you didn't miss?

because that doesn't help me as town - mimi gets nked if they don't get dked for having an accuser shot almost immediately, and the third scum mouse still gets the poison.

Assuming your theory is correct that there were two scum mice.

Which is a big assumption.

[Jamiet99uk]

So your theory is town!yav decided to out town!mimi and ended up lucking into exposing scum Will. Yes?

such a theory is so plainly unlikely that it basically necessitates a second scum mouse

Are you saying that I am scum? Because see from my perspective, a second scum mouse is only more likely if I am the scum mouse. If mimi was scum and I was town, the above actions would be literally the same for me. But for myself, I know I'm town. So either was this doesn't make sense. Mimi can be scum, but most likely above statement (that you opposed) is correct.

Yes. Bona's theory is that Scum!Yavu and Scum Will intentionally decided that one of you should suicide, in order for scum to get the poison.

[Jamiet99uk]

I think Bona is town. If just shared the identities of the mice in scum chat, he would have known me and mimi, so he wouldn't have missed. This might be a trick on us as well but still, wasting a shot sounds unlikely. I think DiplomacyAndWarfare is a good choice.
Should we push him for a role confession?

D&W has claimed his role.

[Jamiet99uk]

Ok I'm caught up.

[BunnyGo]

Anyways...we've all done things with a gun that we regret.

Let's go scumhunt.

Case 1: Chomps is town

Case 2: Chomps is scum

thoughts?

thought about case 1 overnight; napoleoff is almost always town there. if will is scum then 1. the coven know the identity of all mice and 2. they are likely trying to get poison. at the point the shot was made, yavuz was the leading wagon so a scum sniper could likely just shoot me, get yavuz voted out, and give will the poison.

If Just is scum AND napoleoff is scum is the case you’re analyzing.

In that case he’s now lying about the role he shot at.and has been the whole time. He wouldn’t have missed a mouse. He was hoping to catch a high value town PR.

[BunnyGo]

And I'm caught up!

@Jamie, in case you skipped/missed my previous @you: you missed Bofa's clear and explicit claim saying that it went exactly like I said it did (and that he loves me...star crossed love, but still...).

I quoted it....

Yes you did, but why did Bona then explicity deny having claimed?

Do not question the wsys of the Bofa. They are as ineffable as they are constant.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Anyways...we've all done things with a gun that we regret.

Let's go scumhunt.

Case 1: Chomps is town

Case 2: Chomps is scum

thoughts?

evidence for case 2: Chomps voted glitterbomb partially because she was allegedly in a poe that chomps has failed to provide

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

No. You don't get to deathtunnel someone and then abandon that at the flick of a switch because someone else did something that triggers you.

That's either scummy or moronic.

Now I have to wonder which.

this is an interesting post from jamie thinking abt his connection with dw. he was parked on dw at eod d1, and was voting him sod today, but interestingly jumped off when dw garnered a proper wagon. ofc this could just be town but i do think this doesn't feel a scum jamie pushing a town dw. so i think if jamie is scum he is almost always paired with dw and if he is town is says nothing about dw's alignment, thus ##vote diploma cyan should maybe be the better vote from my worldview but idk

I'm town.

you have got to be kidding me. I'm being voted, for a potential pairing withjamie???
this keeps getting more and more absurd

[Jamiet99uk]

And I'm caught up!

@Jamie, in case you skipped/missed my previous @you: you missed Bofa's clear and explicit claim saying that it went exactly like I said it did (and that he loves me...star crossed love, but still...).

I quoted it....

Yes you did, but why did Bona then explicity deny having claimed?

Do not question the wsys of the Bofa. They are as ineffable as they are constant.

What do you think of his theory that two mice are scum, and they planned to have one scum mouse suicide so that the scum could get a poison kill?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

There is absolutely no shot anyone is going to try and decode this

One day Dip will appear out of the shadows and decode and magically guess every single role or something

I'm currently having problems determining who the spiritualist is. Any thoughts?

WEIRD exchange...

weird joke?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I think Bona is town. If just shared the identities of the mice in scum chat, he would have known me and mimi, so he wouldn't have missed. This might be a trick on us as well but still, wasting a shot sounds unlikely. I think DiplomacyAndWarfare is a good choice.
Should we push him for a role confession?

perhaps you should read the damn thread and notice that I already revealed my role?

[Jamiet99uk]

Anyways...we've all done things with a gun that we regret.

Let's go scumhunt.

Case 1: Chomps is town

Case 2: Chomps is scum

thoughts?

evidence for case 2: Chomps voted glitterbomb partially because she was allegedly in a poe that chomps has failed to provide

Causing you to move in an instant from trying to end hammer Glitter, to voting for sChompy because they also voted her.

[BunnyGo]

this is an interesting post from jamie thinking abt his connection with dw. he was parked on dw at eod d1, and was voting him sod today, but interestingly jumped off when dw garnered a proper wagon. ofc this could just be town but i do think this doesn't feel a scum jamie pushing a town dw. so i think if jamie is scum he is almost always paired with dw and if he is town is says nothing about dw's alignment, thus ##vote diploma cyan should maybe be the better vote from my worldview but idk

I'm town.

you have got to be kidding me. I'm being voted, for a potential pairing withjamie???
this keeps getting more and more absurd

Towniest post you’ve made all game

[miminena]

actually maybe i should keep pressure on jamie anyways if I scum read him a bit and dw already has a sizable wagon

##vote jamie

still also need to look at glitter and especially her relationship with dw

Pressure why?

Is there something you want me to answer? I am today's top poster. I am not hiding anything.

i think if you are scum it's very easy for you to go under the radar which aligns with the damo kill. that and my earlier stated goal of wagon diversity. i do think dw is more likely scum than you, but i want to signal to anyone who think you're scummier than dw that you aren't untouchable.

i do have a question for you unrelated to your alignment: what do you make of the damo nk? is bunny right that it might have been a fear kill? am i mistaken in following within his Poe?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I have been wrong in the past, and chomps' vote is more likely to be a scum voting a town. What I was saying here is that chomps is mafia

No. You don't get to deathtunnel someone and then abandon that at the flick of a switch because someone else did something that triggers you.

That's either scummy or moronic.

Now I have to wonder which.

He switched from lying about me and ignoring my responses with the receipts to lying about Glitter when I took a 24 hour hiatus...

He's a witch!

this is a complete lie. No "receipts" were provided, merely your claim that you were planning to drop the gimmick anyways. Moreover, you keep claiming that I lied about glitter, but have provided no examples or evidence. Your claim consists of "Dip is lying because I said so".
##vote bunnygotohell

[BunnyGo]

Yes you did, but why did Bona then explicity deny having claimed?

Do not question the wsys of the Bofa. They are as ineffable as they are constant.

What do you think of his theory that two mice are scum, and they planned to have one scum mouse suicide so that the scum could get a poison kill?

Of the two remaining ones yavu is beyond doubt.

So while I town her, mimi is the only I’d wonder about.

Which doesn’t pair with Bofa’s theory