M1036 Flipless Coven Hunt I Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

midway through day 1 i decided that the most likely scenario was that yavu was likely scum trying to get the third, then unclaimed mouse the poison. i took a pot shot at who i believed that third mouse was, as i did not plan on asking.<snip>

Based on this, why did you not shoot yavu and guarantee you didn't miss?

[BunnyGo]

##GM NOTE

Krr1ss has replaced ButterscotchReader

oh nice we have a sub ##vote krr1ss

i really do need to read through damo's posts again to see who would have benefited most from his death

Hii! Voting me out of the blue as a greeting? Nice to meet you too?

Btw can you put on a pfp, it makes it easier to remember people and read them? I legit suck at reading and remembering people without pfps

Hi Krr1ss!

I'm Bunny (That's me!)

Not to be confused with Chomps who has a bunny pfp. Mine are always theme relevant Patrick Stewart pfps.

I like walking on the beach, knitting, baking, juggling, and biking.

Sometimes I like playing webdip mafia!

Hope you have fun! And thanks for subbing!

[BunnyGo]

##vote glitter

Seems like the right vote I wanna follow that poe someone posted earlier it felt right

Can you elaborate? Why glitter from the whole POE?

[BunnyGo]

which poe?
or rather, whose?

okay let me search

I can't find it but glitterbomb is scummy and they were in that poe

Anything in particular about her being scummy? I find her hard to read.

[brainbomb]

Vote Tally 2.3

Gustav; one of the hunters arrived with several dead geese. He took them
To the kitchen and fired up a tobacco pipe. One by one he chopped the heads off and discarded them into a pail filled with duck heads.



DiplomacyandWarfare (3) BunnyGo GlitterBomb Chomps
yavuzovic (1) Bonatogether
Bonatogether (1) Jamiet99uk
Krr1ss (1) miminena
Chomps (1) DiplomacyandWarfare

Diplomacy and warfare was scheduled to be burned alive

Around 19.5 hours remain.

[BunnyGo]

Justwill died.
Damo died.

This is a limited-reveal setup.

worth pointing out that chomps claimed gravedigger with a scum check on will

Okay that's useful af thanks.

Also i saw people pushing chomps. Idk what's going on and I know I don't have any right really to read the game rn but my meta on chomps is that he's usually treated as easy ml from scum. I don't have any scum!chomps meta but as town he always got MLed xD

It's his uncaring playstyle sooo there's that. Also if he's gravedigger idk how useful killing one would be so early. How many scum do we have? I need to read that first page Kriss you idiot you are asking questions you can find answers to

Oh! Good reminder of some forum language changes:

We use "kill" here. So "miskill".

Started with 3 scum. Have unknown number remaining (although if Chomps is town, then there are 2 remaining).

[miminena]

ok small damo dive

up to #322 is relatively unrelated to why he might be nked imo

#323 he throws out the idea of dw/will/chomps. interestingly this contains at least one scum. points against our dear cyan dwarf imo

#330 he points out yavuz could have been pushing me as a play for the poison, while keeping the third one hidden

that looks to be about it for day 1; the rest of his posts don't seem to be relevant to what i'm looking for, someone can lmk if i missed one

#816 he says likely dw + one of glitter/jamie/butter. looks bad for everyone listed but a bit more for dw

#868 gives a weak pair of dw/jamie. worth noting imo that iirc he seems to have been one of the only ones pushing jamie

#890 is the poe i pointed out earlier today. rereading this i now realize i was way wrong about damo's opinions regarding butter and will likely move my vote at the end of this post. importantly he pushes a dk within yavuz/butter/glitter/jamie/dw and i think we should honor that since i don't think he seemed to exude the kind of energy that would draw a pr hunting scum team.

#893 he notes that no yavuz is the least likely in his opinion of his poe. also worth noticing that he did not believe there were any potential bussers other than yavuz.

#918 he drops yavuz from immediate poe when listing pairings

Conclusions:
yavuz probably isn't the right push today. he was technically in damo's poe but was phased out a bit later on
butter/krr1ss looks better from this. damo wasn't pushing that slot nearly as much as i thought.
dw is the obvious push from this due to how much damo was on him and maybe the simplest answer is the correct one here
jamie looks a bit bad from this. damo was the only one really pushing him (and still seems to be so) so he is likely the one who would have benefited from the kill the most out of anyone
glitter also looks bad, maybe around the same amount as jamie. it's annoying that i saw these two as likely town from posting but from the nk they seem like likely scum
overall i would rank how scummy the five are off the nk as dw>jamie=glitter>butter/krr1ss>yavuz
i think because dw and glitter already seem to have pushes today and the fact that jamie would have benefited a ton from the nk i want to ##vote jamie here but idk. i need to look at pairings with will and individual scumminess next

[BunnyGo]

In my mind webdip is trying to go through all the most suspicious town slots beacuse scum is not in a good position and i gave him a leg beacuse of how i play

But like, i am the gravedigger if you don't believe me kill me after i give my next check or wait for mafia lol, this is just so scummy

I mean...I don't think anyone doubts your role...

[miminena]

i need to look at pairings with will and individual scumminess next

and chomps a little bit on the off chance of will town

[BunnyGo]

"Irrespective of Glitter's alignment?"

But minutes earlier you were so sure of Glitter's scumminess that you ENDVOTED.

I have been wrong in the past, and chomps' vote is more likely to be a scum voting a town. What I was saying here is that chomps is mafia

No. You don't get to deathtunnel someone and then abandon that at the flick of a switch because someone else did something that triggers you.

That's either scummy or moronic.

Now I have to wonder which.

He switched from lying about me and ignoring my responses with the receipts to lying about Glitter when I took a 24 hour hiatus...

He's a witch!

[BunnyGo]

Honestly I do not mind dying at this stage, first dead town means an angel as perma dorcer

damo already dead...and if you are town, the fact JustWill can permanently block that power for the targeted nightkill...well, makes the angels pretty useless.

[Bonatogether]

"Irrespective of Glitter's alignment?"

But minutes earlier you were so sure of Glitter's scumminess that you ENDVOTED.

I have been wrong in the past, and chomps' vote is more likely to be a scum voting a town. What I was saying here is that chomps is mafia

No. You don't get to deathtunnel someone and then abandon that at the flick of a switch because someone else did something that triggers you.

That's either scummy or moronic.

Now I have to wonder which.

hardclaim moron

[miminena]

"Irrespective of Glitter's alignment?"

But minutes earlier you were so sure of Glitter's scumminess that you ENDVOTED.

I have been wrong in the past, and chomps' vote is more likely to be a scum voting a town. What I was saying here is that chomps is mafia

No. You don't get to deathtunnel someone and then abandon that at the flick of a switch because someone else did something that triggers you.

That's either scummy or moronic.

Now I have to wonder which.

this is an interesting post from jamie thinking abt his connection with dw. he was parked on dw at eod d1, and was voting him sod today, but interestingly jumped off when dw garnered a proper wagon. ofc this could just be town but i do think this doesn't feel a scum jamie pushing a town dw. so i think if jamie is scum he is almost always paired with dw and if he is town is says nothing about dw's alignment, thus ##vote diploma cyan should maybe be the better vote from my worldview but idk

[Bonatogether]

Shavua Tov, mother f***ers! (another traditional greeting)

I'm back and will catch up in a bit (got knitting and other stuff to finish up, and kid having a sleepover...so will be in and out)

I was thinking about Chomps' claim and they way he played EOD1. It seemed like a sudden switch; and a strange way to claim right at start of night. Almost like ha had it planned?

I wondered if he wanted to construct a situation? What if the apprentice isn't scum, then as Butter said, it's likely they picked gravedigger and knew Chomps was gravedigger.

Would scum!Chomps be worried?

Would he have planned to just claim the flip was scum?

Something makes me wonder.

And then I started wondering why Butter never called him on it.

So I need to reread, and I realize it's a stretch but maybe the team is

D&W-Chomps-Butter?

this dude is never a first to push

[miminena]

actually maybe i should keep pressure on jamie anyways if I scum read him a bit and dw already has a sizable wagon

##vote jamie

still also need to look at glitter and especially her relationship with dw

[BunnyGo]

And I'm caught up!

@Jamie, in case you skipped/missed my previous @you: you missed Bofa's clear and explicit claim saying that it went exactly like I said it did (and that he loves me...star crossed love, but still...).

I quoted it for you.

@Kr1ss: Hi!

@mimi: fun deep dive! But...I don't really get what you think I should learn.

Any thoughts on damo's power or whom he townread?

[Bonatogether]

bungar is too dismissive of others and accepting of facially insane theories to be plausibly town

Dude, get over yourself.

i forgot you're condescending as town too

[Bonatogether]

No:

Bona is almost certainly town.

I have a very high opinion of him as a player. Except he and I usually have trouble aligning as town. I think he does things that are unconsidered (read: bad) with mechs; he finds me condescending.

My low opinion of his ability to think through mechs and implications is part of why we've had trouble aligning; I shot him as an unCC'd PR because I thought his claim was impossibly dumb and couldn't be real.

If you reread his stuff, you can see he was trying to take a shot at me all game, and I didn't want to give him any insight to do it. I was hoping he'd not just gamble on my role...but what can you do?

why do you think you were shot at?

Because of your posts right before and after it happened.

do you think i post everything i think?

[Bonatogether]

You can go read when the shot happened and it’s pretty clear.

Also here:

that was literally me saying bing bing bong and nothing else

Also "it's a role claim"

You also said that I was going to get drummed, right before the shot rang out and you got excited because you thought it hit.

nope, i submitted the shot considerably before the third mouse was outed and so by that time i knew it missed

[BunnyGo]

I have been wrong in the past, and chomps' vote is more likely to be a scum voting a town. What I was saying here is that chomps is mafia

No. You don't get to deathtunnel someone and then abandon that at the flick of a switch because someone else did something that triggers you.

That's either scummy or moronic.

Now I have to wonder which.

hardclaim moron

Town!Bofa's town tell is that he picks fights with other obvtown and then tries to vote them. Amazingly that's town!Jamie's town tell too! Except Jamie also gets mad about not reading things or misreading things that are clearly there; even moreso this game!

Yay friends! We learn about each other!

And in this case are town picking fights with other town and letting the scum hide!