M1036 Flipless Coven Hunt I Game Thread

[GlitterBomb]

There was just a whole conversation about how he claimed sniper.

Why did you feel the need to make this post?

because that's my watchman info

....and why did you feel the need to claim Watchman at this point in time?

Also curious on this…. Bc my understanding was Bona already claimed watchman? Unless I totally screwed up reading that claim too…. But that’s what I interpreted bing bing bong to me…. Click/watch, am I off on that? Straightforward claims would sure be appreciated…. Geesh.

[Jamiet99uk]

because that's my watchman info

....and why did you feel the need to claim Watchman at this point in time?

Also curious on this…. Bc my understanding was Bona already claimed watchman? Unless I totally screwed up reading that claim too…. But that’s what I interpreted bing bing bong to me…. Click/watch, am I off on that? Straightforward claims would sure be appreciated…. Geesh.

Bona apparently claimed Sniper, not Watchman.

[GlitterBomb]

....and why did you feel the need to claim Watchman at this point in time?

Also curious on this…. Bc my understanding was Bona already claimed watchman? Unless I totally screwed up reading that claim too…. But that’s what I interpreted bing bing bong to me…. Click/watch, am I off on that? Straightforward claims would sure be appreciated…. Geesh.

Bona apparently claimed Sniper, not Watchman.

Bing bing bong means sniper????

[Jamiet99uk]

A sane watchman would not claim midway through D1.

[GlitterBomb]

A sane watchman would not claim midway through D1.

The bing bing bong “claim” was at night. But I still don’t get how it translates to sniper?

[Jamiet99uk]

Also curious on this…. Bc my understanding was Bona already claimed watchman? Unless I totally screwed up reading that claim too…. But that’s what I interpreted bing bing bong to me…. Click/watch, am I off on that? Straightforward claims would sure be appreciated…. Geesh.

Bona apparently claimed Sniper, not Watchman.

Bing bing bong means sniper????

bing bing bong is just how Bona talks.

The point is that he claimed at a time when the Sniper shot was being discussed.+

Moreover, reading back to that section, I notice that right before the shot was announced by Brainbomb, Bona indicated that (a) he was very excited about something and (b) he was particularly excited to see that Brainbomb was online. This all points to him having just sent in a gunshot PM to Brain.

[yavuzovic]

Since there was at least one scum among the mice, does that mean there is at least one scum among the rabbits?

[GlitterBomb]

Bona apparently claimed Sniper, not Watchman.

Bing bing bong means sniper????

bing bing bong is just how Bona talks.

The point is that he claimed at a time when the Sniper shot was being discussed.+

Moreover, reading back to that section, I notice that right before the shot was announced by Brainbomb, Bona indicated that (a) he was very excited about something and (b) he was particularly excited to see that Brainbomb was online. This all points to him having just sent in a gunshot PM to Brain.

Ok, that tracks. He said verbatim that the bing bing bong was a role claim and of course I fell for that. I saw the excited thing but thought that might’ve been him posturing. So we have a not sane sniper on our hands then… :)

[Jamiet99uk]

Bing bing bong means sniper????

bing bing bong is just how Bona talks.

The point is that he claimed at a time when the Sniper shot was being discussed.+

Moreover, reading back to that section, I notice that right before the shot was announced by Brainbomb, Bona indicated that (a) he was very excited about something and (b) he was particularly excited to see that Brainbomb was online. This all points to him having just sent in a gunshot PM to Brain.

Ok, that tracks. He said verbatim that the bing bing bong was a role claim and of course I fell for that. I saw the excited thing but thought that might’ve been him posturing. So we have a not sane sniper on our hands then… :)

I think so.

But he spaffed his shot anyway so he's basically a VT or a Goon at this point, but we don't know which for sure.

[GlitterBomb]

We got last minute free tickets to go to Hamilton tonight! So we are dropping off the kids and getting out! Will be out of the loop for a bit. Happy weekend all!

[Bonatogether]

The chances of two mice being scum must be fairly low...?

explain to me why town mice would kamikaze into each other

A town mouse does not know the alignment of the other mice, only that they are mice.

but they don't want to die, so they wouldn't set up 1 for 1s with an unknown alignment third mouse

[Bonatogether]

...and scummy?

Not to my eyes.

So your theory is town!yav decided to out town!mimi and ended up lucking into exposing scum Will. Yes?

such a theory is so plainly unlikely that it basically necessitates a second scum mouse

[Jamiet99uk]

explain to me why town mice would kamikaze into each other

A town mouse does not know the alignment of the other mice, only that they are mice.

but they don't want to die, so they wouldn't set up 1 for 1s with an unknown alignment third mouse

Explain to me why scum mice would want to die.

[Bonatogether]

bungar is too dismissive of others and accepting of facially insane theories to be plausibly town

[Jamiet99uk]

Not to my eyes.

So your theory is town!yav decided to out town!mimi and ended up lucking into exposing scum Will. Yes?

such a theory is so plainly unlikely that it basically necessitates a second scum mouse

And yet Bunny confirmed that this is, in fact, his theory.

[Bonatogether]

A town mouse does not know the alignment of the other mice, only that they are mice.

but they don't want to die, so they wouldn't set up 1 for 1s with an unknown alignment third mouse

Explain to me why scum mice would want to die.

trading 1 for 1 in exchange for getting the poision means an unrevealed second scum mouse gets poison, making it a two town for one scum exchange. net effect is pro scum. mimi revealed the third mouse though, so the plan failed

[Bonatogether]

So your theory is town!yav decided to out town!mimi and ended up lucking into exposing scum Will. Yes?

such a theory is so plainly unlikely that it basically necessitates a second scum mouse

And yet Bunny confirmed that this is, in fact, his theory.

1. something seems to obviously point to a certain player X being scum
2. player Y denies this without real reason
3. ergo player Y is scum also

[Jamiet99uk]

but they don't want to die, so they wouldn't set up 1 for 1s with an unknown alignment third mouse

Explain to me why scum mice would want to die.

trading 1 for 1 in exchange for getting the poision means an unrevealed second scum mouse gets poison, making it a two town for one scum exchange. net effect is pro scum. mimi revealed the third mouse though, so the plan failed

But in that scenario why wouldn't the town mouse reveal the third mouse?

[Jamiet99uk]

such a theory is so plainly unlikely that it basically necessitates a second scum mouse

And yet Bunny confirmed that this is, in fact, his theory.

1. something seems to obviously point to a certain player X being scum
2. player Y denies this without real reason
3. ergo player Y is scum also

Ergo you are sure the scum team is Yav and Bunny. Yes?

[Jamiet99uk]

Bona, if the intention of Bunny, Yav and Will's plan was to get Will and Mimi killed, why didn't they NK Mimi last night?